Why sleep paralysis can feel like a supernatural encounter

You wake in the middle of the night. Your eyes are open and you know where you are, but your body refuses to move.
Then comes the truly unsettling part: a weight on your chest, perhaps, or the unmistakable feeling that somebody else is in the room.
Sleep paralysis has inspired supernatural explanations around the world for centuries. Now, neuroscientist Baland Jalal, who has studied the phenomenon across different cultures, is interested not simply in why paralysis occurs, but why the brain can turn those strange few moments into such convincing encounters.
FMT Lifestyle previously explored the condition with sleep disorder specialist Dr Rajveer Singh Saren, looking at factors such as stress, sleep deprivation, irregular sleep schedules and underlying disorders.
The basic mechanism is relatively well understood. During rapid eye movement, or REM, sleep – the stage strongly associated with vivid dreaming – the body temporarily suppresses most voluntary muscle movement.
During sleep paralysis, consciousness returns before that paralysis has fully lifted. The result is an extraordinary overlap: part of the brain is awake and taking in the bedroom around you, while elements of dreaming can still intrude.
That may help explain why the experience can feel so real.

A recent Guardian profile of Jalal’s work describes people seeing threatening figures, sensing another presence or feeling pressure on their chest. Some also report floating, leaving their bodies or seeing a double of themselves.
The brain, Jalal argues, is attempting to make sense of a deeply confusing situation: you appear to be awake yet cannot move, and your normal sense of where your body begins and ends may briefly be disturbed.
Culture can then supply the explanation. In a cross-cultural study comparing people in Egypt and Denmark, Jalal and his colleagues found striking differences in how sufferers interpreted essentially similar experiences.
Nearly half of participants from the general Egyptian population attributed sleep paralysis to djinn. Elsewhere, the phenomenon has acquired its own supernatural characters: researchers have documented accounts involving the “Old Hag” in Newfoundland, ghost oppression in China, and the Pandafeche – a witch-like figure – in parts of Italy.
The hallucinations themselves do not appear simply to be invented by culture. Instead, research suggests that sensations such as immobility, pressure and an unseen presence occur across societies, while cultural beliefs help shape the story the mind builds around them.

And those beliefs may, in turn, affect how frightening the experience becomes. Jalal’s research has found associations between supernatural interpretations, greater fear and more distress surrounding episodes – raising the possibility of a cycle in which fear of sleep paralysis makes subsequent experiences even more alarming.
Knowing what is happening may therefore help. Jalal encourages sufferers to recognise the episode for what it is, avoid struggling against the paralysis, turn their attention towards something emotionally reassuring, and relax their muscles rather than trying forcefully to move.
A small pilot study of Jalal’s approach involving people with narcolepsy produced encouraging results, although larger studies would be needed before firm conclusions can be drawn.
For people who experience sleep paralysis repeatedly or find that it is seriously disrupting their sleep, medical advice is still worthwhile, particularly because it can occur alongside conditions such as narcolepsy.
But perhaps the strangest thing about sleep paralysis is not simply that the brain can conjure a presence in a darkened bedroom. It is how powerfully that fleeting experience can draw upon the stories, fears and beliefs we already carry with us.
Subscribe to our newsletter and get news delivered to your mailbox.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.