Hayden drops 'more smoke' remark, questions Australia's handling ball-tampering scandal
![]()
Cameron Bancroft and Pat Cummins
Eight years after the infamous Sandpapergate scandal rocked Australian cricket, the controversy surrounding the 2018 ball-tampering incident refuses to die down. Fresh revelations from Cameron Bancroft and Usman Khawaja have once again brought questions of accountability and transparency into focus, with former Australia opener Matthew Hayden now calling for a fair and independent assessment of the entire episode.Hayden believes several questions surrounding the Cape Town Test against South Africa remain unanswered and has urged Cricket Australia to establish a transparent process that allows everyone involved to present their version of events.
"It's just undeniable that there is a lot more smoke to come out of this fire," Hayden said while speaking on JioStar's 'Sandpapergate: The Unsettled Debate'.The former opener stressed that Australian cricket needs to move beyond the original sanctions and establish whether the full extent of the incident was ever investigated.
He also insisted that reconciliation and trust would remain difficult as long as doubts continued to surround the scandal.
Hayden calls for independent inquiry, wants former players to have their say
Hayden argued that Cricket Australia should take ownership of the process and consider an independent assessment to establish whether further investigation is warranted."Whether it's with Cricket Australia or an independent assessment process, I think we need to ask specific questions, and we need to identify if there are grounds for further inquiry, and then proceed with a clear scope and a fair process for everyone involved.
There has to be some ownership over the process. Reconciliation is never going to be there for as long as there are question marks over integrity and trust," he said.The 54-year-old also emphasised that the process should not be restricted to current players, adding that those who were part of the 2018 South Africa tour and have since retired should also be given an opportunity to speak in an official capacity.He specifically mentioned
David Warner
and Usman Khawaja, along with other former players who have recently spoken about the controversy."It's unimaginable to think that the game can't actually get itself into a position where it at least understands a little bit further around the seriousness of this matter, and then come up with some sort of process that entitles not only the current players, but also the players that were involved in that series, who have now subsequently retired, David Warner and Usman Khawaja, to have their say in an official capacity, and the other three that have come out in support of it as well.
I think as long as that gate remains open, there will be a distrust issue," Hayden added.
What are the fresh Sandpapergate allegations?
The debate has resurfaced following recent comments from Bancroft and Khawaja, who have questioned whether knowledge of the ball-tampering plan was limited to the three players who were initially punished.During the third Test against South Africa in Cape Town in March 2018, Bancroft was caught on television cameras using sandpaper to alter the condition of the ball.
The incident triggered one of the biggest crises in Australian cricket and resulted in suspensions for Bancroft, then captain Steve Smith and vice-captain David Warner.In a recent column for The West Australian, Bancroft reportedly detailed conversations with members of the Australian bowling group about generating reverse swing. His account included discussions involving Pat Cummins and suggested that awareness of the plan may have extended beyond the three players who were sanctioned.Bancroft also claimed that his actions had been encouraged and celebrated within the team, adding another dimension to the long-running controversy.Khawaja has similarly raised questions about how much the wider Australian dressing room knew about the incident. Cummins, however, has strongly rejected the allegations, describing them as "utter nonsense".
Hayden questions Cricket Australia's stance on the controversy
Hayden also questioned Cricket Australia's response to the latest revelations, arguing that the governing body must address the lingering doubts if it wants to restore public confidence.He acknowledged that the International Cricket Council (ICC) had strengthened its regulations following the incident, including expanding its rules and empowering on-field umpires to deal with ball tampering. However, he believes the broader questions surrounding the Australian team's conduct still need to be addressed."Until there is some further position on this from the authority, and that's Cricket Australia in this case, because the ICC have had their say.
They've gone, 'Right, our rules have now expanded. We've got new policies. We've got empowerment of our umpires.' That's a really good thing that's come out of this, because we don't want to see unnecessary tampering of the ball. But Cricket Australia have taken a very definite position on this, and nothing is going to change public opinion," Hayden said.
Drawing attention to the importance of a cricket ball to fast bowlers, Hayden questioned the suggestion that members of the bowling group could have been unaware of any plans to alter its condition."If you talk to a first-grade cricketer who's a fast bowler, and you tell him that he doesn't know what ball he's got in their hand, just like you heard Irfan say before, they will say, 'Mate, you are kidding. That'd be like someone tampering with my bat. And I know exactly every centimetre of that bat. It's just undeniable that there is a lot more smoke to come out of this fire," he added.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.