Coles appeals ACCC decision blocking Kalgoorlie supermarket
As the crows flies, Australia's largest outback city is 2,290km from Melbourne and 2,618km from Canberra.
But lawyers and bureaucrats on the other side of the country are having a significant say in how Kalgoorlie-Boulder's residents do their weekly grocery shopping.
The Australian Competition Tribunal this week wrapped eight days of hearings in Melbourne's Federal Court, centred on whether Coles should be permitted to open a new supermarket in the historic gold mining city.
To say some of the 30,000-strong population are annoyed at the prospect would be an understatement.
Doug Daws has lived in Kalgoorlie-Boulder his entire life. (ABC Goldfields: Jarrod Lucas)
Kalgoorlie-Boulder's former Deputy Mayor Doug Daws is among them.
"If you want to spend money in Kalgoorlie and create a new supermarket for the people here you have my support," he said.
"Fundamentally, it's appalling that a group of faceless, anonymous people on the other side of Australia get involved in free enterprise here."
Landmark legal challenge
In July, the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) exercised new powers to stop Coles from building a new supermarket and liquor store in the city, located about 600km east of Perth.
Among other factors in its decision, the watchdog cited the potential for Coles's expansion to knock out smaller independent competitors already operating in Kalgoorlie-Boulder.
Coles immediately appealed, in what looms as a test case for Australia's new merger laws.
There are six supermarkets in Kalgoorlie-Boulder, including an existing Coles in the CBD. (ABC News)
In one respect, the case was a David versus Goliath battle.
On one side was Coles, with 860 supermarkets nationwide, fighting to establish a second store in Kalgoorlie-Boulder.
The closest competitor, O'Connor Fresh IGA, is about 2km from the proposed new development and argued there is a "commercially real possibility" it would go out of business.
The closest competitor to the proposed Coles development is the O'Connor Fresh IGA. (ABC Goldfields: Jarrod Lucas)
Competitor flags market exit
ACCC lawyer Declan Roche SC insisted any Coles expansion represented a "substantial lessening of competition" across Kalgoorlie-Boulder.
He said the consumer watchdog assessed competition would be significantly impacted if O'Connor Fresh IGA exited the market, given its operating hours are not regulated like Coles and benefit local shift workers.
"The ACCC's view was it offers consumers a differentiated product in terms of range and service … and a measure of its effectiveness as a competitor is the proportion of Kalgoorlie grocery spend it attracts," Mr Roche told the tribunal.
"Coles' own business case … without getting into the confidential figures … identifies a proportion of Coles' business from the new supermarket will come from the business that's currently being done by O'Connor Fresh IGA."
The O'Connor Fresh IGA is the closest competitor to the site of the proposed Coles supermarket. (ABC Goldfields: Jarrod Lucas)
With six existing supermarkets, Mr Roche described Kalgoorlie-Boulder as a "concentrated market" and backing the ACCC's position was the Kalgoorlie-Boulder Chamber of Commerce and Industry.
"The submission of the chamber of commerce is the expansion is neither necessary nor justified, wouldn't provide any meaningful increase in consumer choice and would over-saturate the market," he said.
O'Connor Fresh IGA's counsel Robert Yezerski SC told the tribunal the market had been impacted by last year's arrival of Tony Galati's Spudshed franchise in a "very material" way, which triggered a "competitive response" from national chains.
"We believe Coles takes more power we because it becomes less constrained by its competitors," he said.
WA businessman Tony Galati at the opening of Kalgoorlie-Boulder's Spudshed supermarket. (ABC Goldfields: Macey Turner)
Future investment uncertain
But the supermarket giant argued the watchdog's intervention would have a "chilling effect" on investment in Kalgoorlie-Boulder.
The warning would be ominous for the City of Kalgoorlie-Boulder, which launched a nationwide marketing blitz in 2021 as part of its ambition to grow the population to 40,000 by the end of the decade.
"Any investor keen to expand its services in a market must weigh up the risk of an incumbent persuading the regulator, that its viability would be threatened if expansion were to occur," Coles's lawyer John Sheahan KC said.
"In many, perhaps most cases, the investor will be unable to make a confident or useful assessment of that risk.
"Given the transaction costs associated … that uncertainty will plausibly and likely have a chilling effect on proposed investments."
An aerial view of the Kalgoorlie CBD. (ABC Goldfields: Jarrod Lucas)
Coles previously operated two stores in Kalgoorlie-Boulder from 1986 to 2021.
Mr Sheahan argued consumers would get the benefits of Coles's national and state-based pricing structure, saying the proposed supermarket was "likely to intensify rather than diminish rivals' incentives to invest in dimensions of competition".
He noted Kalgoorlie-Boulder's growing population of fly-in, fly-out workers as a sign of increasing demand, while pointing to 10 regional locations across Australia with a comparable population.
"All have more supermarkets than Kalgoorlie, and nine of those towns have at least two Woolworths or two Coles," he said.
Case poses 'difficult dilemma'
The hearing delved deep into locals' purchasing habits, including Coles selling more dog food at its Kalgoorlie store than others across the country, while O'Connor Fresh IGA's biggest sellers included barbecue chickens and other takeaway offerings.
Mr Sheahan said Coles's biggest national competitor, Woolworths, is "unlikely to take the opening of a new Coles store lying down" and would likely pursue further investment or additional expansion.
It was also suggested another rival chain, Aldi, was weighing up entering the market.
The proposed site of the Coles supermarket in Somerville is currently bushland, which is surrounded by an industrial area, FIFO camp and childcare centre. (ABC Goldfields: Jarrod Lucas)
"All the consumers in Kalgoorlie are benefited by a new store," Mr Sheahan said.
"It is an odd reaction by the commission [ACCC] to say, 'Fine, just not too close to this store [O'Connor Fresh IGA], because it might make them uncomfortable.'"
Federal Court Justice Michael O'Bryan, the president of the tribunal's three-member panel, said the case posed a "difficult dilemma".
The property developer, M/Group, behind the proposed Amara Estate near Kalgoorlie-Boulder Airport also plans to lease land to Coles for a new supermarket development. (ABC Goldfields: Jarrod Lucas)
"Some consumers may prefer the new supermarket because of location or lower prices or other features," Justice O'Bryan said.
"How do we judge that against the secondary consequences which may appear to be a reduction in competition?"
The tribunal has reserved its decision, and is required to make a final determination within 90 days.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.