Deputy speaker draws flak for debating while chairing sitting

Dewan Rakyat deputy speaker Ramli Nor drew protests from several MPs today after vacating the speaker’s chair to take part in a debate as an MP while continuing to preside over proceedings.
The move prompted Ronald Kiandee (PN-Beluran) and Ngeh Koo Ham (PH-Beruas) to question whether Ramli could act as both speaker and a participant in the parliamentary debate.
Ramli, the Cameron Highlands MP, said he had reviewed Parliament’s Standing Orders and found no provision barring him from speaking from his MP desk while continuing to chair the proceedings.
He invited “Cameron Highlands” to begin the debate, before clarifying that he was speaking in his capacity as the constituency’s MP.
Kiandee objected, saying the speaker’s chair should not be left vacant during a sitting and that someone should be appointed to temporarily preside over proceedings.
“There must be somebody there. If the speaker is not there, he can appoint anyone in the house temporarily to chair proceedings while you are debating,” he said.
“I do not question your right to debate as an MP. But somebody has to be there. The vacant speaker’s chair is something that should not have happened.”
Ramli, of Umno, insisted that his interpretation of the Standing Orders allowed him to proceed, arguing that he had merely changed seats and had not relinquished his responsibilities as chairman.
“I am standing here today as Cameron Highlands MP and, at the same time, I am also chairing the proceedings,” he said.
He added that the Standing Orders do not expressly prohibit a deputy speaker from speaking in the Dewan Rakyat while continuing to preside over proceedings.
“Standing Order 99 gives the speaker or deputy speaker the final say in interpreting the Standing Orders, while Standing Order 99A states that failure to comply with the rules will not invalidate the proceedings or their decisions,” he said.
Ramli then told MPs who disagreed with his interpretation to file a motion to have the matter reviewed.
Ngeh voiced disappointment, saying the incident could undermine Parliament’s dignity and reputation.
He argued that every parliamentary sitting must have a presiding officer to ensure that parliamentary rules are followed, asking who would determine whether Ramli was complying with the rules while he was simultaneously debating.
“I want to register my disappointment and objection so that Parliament does not become a laughing stock, not only in Malaysia but throughout the world,” he said, calling for the episode to be expunged from the Hansard.
Ramli rejected the objections, maintaining that his interpretation was final unless challenged through the proper parliamentary procedure.
Dr Zaliha Mustafa (PH-Sekijang) later described the incident as setting a precedent, saying clearer guidelines are needed to address similar situations in the future.
Subscribe to our newsletter and get news delivered to your mailbox.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.