CNN Türkİstanbul’da lodos; bazı vapur seferleri iptal edildiDaily MaverickOLD ROADS AGAIN: Melba-toast memories and boerie rolls served on Italian blue Spode (Part One)Bollywood HungamaMohitt Maalik to play antagonist opposite Tiger Shroff in spiritual action film VajrInquirerBacoor City eyes penalties for emergency hotline prank callersPunchVIDEO: FIFA president arrives in Delta for Warri stadium inspectionThe Jerusalem PostIraqi forces to deploy in Kataib Hezbollah stronghold under deal to ease militia tensionsInquirer EntertainmentMiss Universe 2025 Fatima Bosch praises PH’s Bea Millan-WindorskiThe South AfricanFive things South Africans must do as flash flood alerts loomZDF heuteAktuelle Pressemitteilungen des ZDFIl Fatto QuotidianoÈ morto il cavallo che ha vissuto per 20 anni da solo in un borgo “Potevamo solo alleviargli il dolore alle gambe. Ci ha fatto capire che non ce la faceva più”The Sydney Morning HeraldAFL draft LIVE updates: Overjoyed picks give interviews from school graduations as second round kicks into gearSportstarCyclone Akvan impact — Sethu FC vs Gokulam Kerala IWL 2026-27 clash cancelled due to torrential rain
The Daily Newsstand · Free, Always
Friday, November 20, 2026

Prosec asks if VP’s tree-planting was tied to Cale88 requirement

Translate
Prosec asks if VP’s tree-planting was tied to Cale88 requirement
Trade Undersecretary for Industry Development and Promotions Ceferino Rodolfo

MANILA, Philippines — Did Vice President Sara Duterte’s tree-planting activities have anything to do with a requirement imposed on Cale88 Foods Corporation, the banana chip company linked to her husband, Manases Carpio?

This was the question raised by a prosecution lawyer during Friday’s impeachment trial, as the defense presented Trade Undersecretary Ceferino Rodolfo as a witness.

Prosecution counsel Erwin Matib asked Rodolfo whether he knew if Duterte’s tree-planting activities were connected to a Board of Investments (BOI) requirement for enterprises to plant at least 100 forest trees to qualify for incentives.

Article continues after this advertisement

READ: Defense witness confirms Cale88 named after Carpio, Lebosada

FEATURED STORIES

NEWSINFO

NEWSINFO

NEWSINFO

Rodolfo said he did not know.

“Sir alam niyo po ba na mahilig magtanim ng mga puno si Vice President Sara Duterte?” Matib asked.

(Sir would you know that Vice President Sara Duterte likes planting trees?)

“Hindi ko po alam (I don’t know),” Rodolfo replied.

Article continues after this advertisement

Before Matib could proceed, defense counsel Justin Nicol Gular objected, saying he did not see the relevance of the question.

Matib said he had a point to make and asked Senate Impeachment Court Presiding Officer Francis Escudero to put him on a “short leash.”

Article continues after this advertisement

Escudero then allowed the question.

READ: LIVE UPDATES: Sara Duterte impeachment trial | Nov. 20, 2026

“Thank you your Honor.  So, tama po ba na itong pagtatanim ng mga puno ni Vice President Sara Duterte ay connected sa pag-comply ng Cale88 Foods sa tree-planting activities na requirement ng Board of Investments?” Matib asked.

(Thank you, your Honor.  So, is it correct that the reason why Vice President Sara Duterte planted trees is because it is connected to Cale88’s compliance with the requirement from the Board of Investments?)

“In fact ang requirement po ng Board of Investments ay magtanim dapat ang mga enterprises ng at least 100 forest trees, may gano’ng requirement tama po ba?” he added.

(In fact the requirement of the Board of Investments is that enterprises must plant at least 100 forest trees, there is such a requirement, right?)

Gular made another objection, describing the question as misleading, malicious and callous.

“Objection your Honor, misleading, there is no prior testimony coming from the witness wherein he testified that the vice president participated in the compliance requirement of tree planting,” Gular said.

“The insinuation being made by the prosecution, that the pictures being shown or that was displayed of the vice president planting trees had any relation to Cale88 Foods Corporation’s registration is misleading, malicious, and callous, your Honor,” he added.

Matib then changed his question, asking instead if Cale88 complied with tree-planting activities.  Rodolfo said he would have to check, as he has no specific record of the possible compliance.

“I’ll have to check po do’n sa specific terms and conditions kung nakalagay po ‘yong sa tree-planting, pero sa pagkaka-alam ko po, kasama po ito sa mga nire-require ng BOI.  Pero may time period po for them to, sa pagkaka-alala ko po, may time period for them to also comply,” Rodolfo said.

(I’ll have to check the specific terms and conditions if tree-planting is included, but as far as I know, it is part of the requirements from the BOI.  But this has a time period for them to comply, as far as I can remember.)

“So personally hindi niyo po masabi kung nakapag-comply itong Cale88 do’n sa required tree-planting of at least 100 forest trees?” Matib asked.

(So personally you cannot say if Cale88 was able to comply with the required tree-planting of at least 100 forest trees?)

“Personally po wala pero pwede ko pong i-check kung nag-submit po sila ng notarized na statement na nag-comply po sila sa compliance po namin,” Rodolfo replied again.

(Personally I have no record but I can check if they submitted a notarized statement stating that they complied with our requirements.)

Duterte’s numerous tree-planting activities have been brought up several times by the prosecution during the impeachment trial.

Last August, when the prosecution presented evidence for Article I, which concerned allegations of misuse of confidential funds (CF), a Commission on Audit witness said tree-planting was among the activities cited by the Office of the Vice President to justify its confidential expenses.

According to COA auditor Xylene Mae del Campo, tree-planting and other activities, such as Christmas parties, were not among the allowable uses of confidential funds under Joint Circular No. 2015-01, which sets guidelines on the disbursement, utilization and audit of these funds.

READ: OVP listed tree planting, Christmas party as secret expenses – auditor

Then on August 24, the prosecution was able to obtain information from Duterte’s former special disbursing officer Gina Acosta that the vice president was able to safely conduct tree-planting activities even without CFs.

READ: Prosec: Sara Duterte safely joined tree-planting activity sans secret funds

The prosecution panel has also criticized the defense’s line of questioning against Rodolfo, saying it focused on Cale88’s business registration rather than its allegedly undeclared income.

In a press briefing on Friday, public prosecutor Manila Rep. Joel Chua and prosecution spokesperson Lanao del Sur Rep. Zia Alonto Adiong both highlighted that Cale88’s registration with the Department of Trade and Industry was never questioned.

The lawmakers said more pressing issues raised during the impeachment proceedings, as well as those brought up by former Sen. Antonio Trillanes IV, should have been addressed.

Trillanes had flagged several alleged irregularities in Cale88’s operations. The company reportedly claimed to be a large-scale banana chip manufacturer despite having low electricity costs, small paid-up capital, zero trade receivables and payables, and no rank-and-file employees.

READ: Trillanes links P319M China funds to firm of Sara Duterte’s husband

Your subscription could not be saved. Please try again.

Your subscription has been successful.

But the more significant concern according to Trillanes is CALE88 receiving P319 million in cash remittances from China. /dp

View the original on Inquirer →

KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.