PunchS’West APC youths name advisory council chairThe Jerusalem PostPolice recover antique Torah scroll case stolen from Jerusalem synagogue over 20 years ago한겨레‘수능 7등급’ 감스트 “AI 안경 쓰니 수학 5개 틀려”InquirerQC orders midnight closure of bars, karaoke venues for Nov. 15 to 21ZDF heuteAktuelle Pressemitteilungen des ZDFDaily MaverickRocket from Boeing-Lockheed firm fails mid-flight, destroys payload of Amazon satellitesStraits Times SportF1 must push harder, move faster to open up motorsport careers, says HamiltonMalay MailMusk, tech leaders join 158,000 calling for Jensen Huang’s return; 7,500 are Nvidia staffThe Sydney Morning HeraldBeau Lamarre-Condon trial live updates: Alleged double murderer, NSW Police officer’s re-examination beginsLenta.ruРаскрыто наполнение будущего пакета антироссийских санкций ЕСLa TerceraTras el descenso a Segunda División: vandalizan la Fortaleza Rojinegra, el complejo deportivo de RangersNew Straits TimesF1 must push harder, move faster to open up motorsport careers
The Daily Newsstand · Free, Always
Monday, November 16, 2026

She's the fraudster whose blue eyes mesmerised rich and powerful men. But was Elizabeth Holmes an idealistic genius or just a sociopath?

Translate

It is the film that critics are heaping with the highest praise: 'ingenious', 'stupefying', 'gloriously destabilising', 'more than fascinating', an 'unalloyed masterpiece'. Five stars aren't enough!

There is talk of it winning the Best Picture Oscar, of audiences in the US so mesmerised that they remain glued to their seat for all 174 minutes, forgetting earthly concerns like popping to the loo.

The epic in question? A documentary about convicted Silicon Valley fraudster Elizabeth Holmes called You Can See Everything.

Now the buzz has leapt over the Atlantic ahead of its release here on Friday. Demand for tickets is 'bonkers', according to Picturehouse Cinemas.

Above London's Piccadilly Circus a giant billboard projects an extreme close–up of Holmes's wide eyes, 20ft–high peepers gazing eerily over shoppers below.

If the eyes are the window of the soul, what lies behind Holmes's unsettling stare? This is the question that drives the film.

Is she a sociopathic narcissist? An idealistic genius who over–reached? A misunderstood eccentric? As one of the documentary makers puts it, she's either 'fully sincere' or 'the most manipulative person who ever lived'. In this ambiguity lies the deliciousness.

Holmes is a spectacularly fascinating character, who seems to have come out of the womb with a business plan and a Rolodex of people to pump for cash.

If the eyes are the window of the soul, what lies behind Holmes's unsettling stare? This is the question that drives the film

Nathan Fielder, left, and Elizabeth Holmes are pictured in a scene from 'You Can See Everything'

Her big idea: a machine that could use a single drop of blood to screen for hundreds of health markers, from vitamin levels to thyroid function. Holmes modestly declared the machine 'the most important thing humanity has ever built', claiming it would transform healthcare and save millions of lives.

Once the Holmes blinkers had been set in the direction of global domination, nothing would get in her way. A degree in chemical engineering at Stanford University was ditched so she could start a company, Theranos. In the early days she slept four hours a night, popping chocolate–covered coffee beans to power her through the 20 waking hours.

The only problem: her gadget didn't work. During demonstrations the thing clanked and failed to perform. Bits fell off. It was like someone passing off a GCSE science experiment as a time machine.

Nevertheless, Holmes proceeded to act as though it was the greatest invention since the wheel. How? Some have suggested an extreme cognitive bias known as the Dunning–Kruger effect, a mindset which causes some people to overestimate their competence drastically. Don't have the skills to achieve greatness? So what! Fake it 'til you make it.

Fake it is exactly what she did. Fake Pfizer logos were put on lab reports to give them credibility. Fake blood results were sent to regulators. Fake projections said the start–up would make $100million (£76million) in a year, when the real figure was closer to $100,000 (£76,000). Holmes even said that the machine was being used in combat zones in the Middle East... lies upon lies.

Perhaps her epic ambition was written in her genetics. Her great–great–great–grandfather built Fleischmann's Yeast, making theirs one of the richest families in the US at the turn of the century. Her great–great–grandfather founded Cincinnati General Hospital.

'I grew up with these stories about greatness,' she has said – and her parents encouraged her to think big. At one family dinner her father flew a paper aeroplane towards her, scribbled with the message 'PhD'.

Here lies an intriguing theme in the tale of Elizabeth Holmes: her power to beguile and bewitch the men around her

'No, dad,' replied Elizabeth, 'I want to make money.'

Any member of staff at Theranos who raised concerns about her dud machine was sacked in brutal fashion. 'What matters is the company,' barked Holmes to employees, maniacal as a cult leader. An investment pile of $1.6billion (£1.2billion) was built on a tissue of deceit; the most audacious fraud since the Eiffel Tower was 'sold' to a gullible scrap metal merchant. In this case, the gullible parties tended to be male investors of older years.

And here lies an intriguing theme in the tale of Elizabeth Holmes: her power to beguile and bewitch the men around her.

Former US Secretary of State George Shultz was one, joining the Theranos board and developing a strong attachment to its founder. He called her every day, praising her as 'brilliant'.

When his own grandson – who had been working at Theranos – wanted to blow the whistle on the fraud, Shultz tried to silence him, fiercely defending Holmes.

Shultz's biographer goes so far as to suggest 'he fell in love with Elizabeth Holmes... he was infatuated with her and she understood that and played on it in a calculating way'.

Many other powerful men fell for her charms too – and gushed about them. Another US Secretary of State, Henry Kissinger, marvelled at her 'ethereal quality'.

Though Holmes is pretty enough, she is not a bombshell. In homage to her idol Steve Jobs, she dressed every day in black polo–neck and trousers, blonde hair swept back

Stanford professor Channing Robertson described her as 'different' to any other student he had taught.

James Mattis, a retired four–star Marine general, thought her a 'revolutionary'. Media magnate Rupert Murdoch, who invested $125million (£94.5million) into Theranos, emailed after their first meeting saying he 'enjoyed every minute' of it.

In the definitive account of the fraud, Bad Blood, author John Carreyrou describes how she 'wrapped people around her finger and persuaded them to do her bidding'. One by one, they 'fell under her spell'.

How did she beguile them? Though Holmes is pretty enough, she is not a bombshell. In homage to her idol Steve Jobs, she dressed every day in black polo–neck and trousers, blonde hair swept back. Sometimes there would be a slick of red lipstick, but her appeal wasn't that of the conventional sex kitten.

Holmes's magnetism came from something less obvious. Skilfully, she mixed a cocktail that cannot fail to intoxicate the male of the species: confidence and vulnerability.

On the one hand, she was a freakishly self–assured ball–breaker in black who could stun hardened investors with her confidence. On the other, she knew how to inspire a protective instinct in the men she courted. They didn't just back Holmes as a good investment; they put an arm around her, invited her to family brunches, looked after her, fretted about her working in a dangerous part of town.

She was expert at the protegee role, seducing powerful men by deferring to them and giving them her undiluted attention.

You Can See Everything, directed by Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim, was unveiled at the Telluride Film Festival's Sunday TBA

Above all, Holmes was utterly bewitching because of a quality you might call charismatic intensity – often expressed through her wide, unblinking stare.

In Bad Blood it is striking how often those around her mention her intense way of looking at people. A journalist who came to speak to her 'felt himself drawn in by the young woman sitting across from him who was staring at him intently without blinking'.

An old school friend felt 'she had this intense way of looking at you while she spoke that made you believe in her and want to follow her'.

When the chief financial officer at Theranos entered her office 'he was immediately reminded of her charisma... the way she trained her big blue eyes on you without blinking made you feel like the centre of the world. It was almost hypnotic.'

The same hypnotic stare is on frequent display in You Can See Everything.

After being convicted on four counts of fraud in 2022, Holmes was sentenced to 11 years in prison. Knowing how trashed her reputation had become, the disgraced entrepreneur made the extraordinary decision to invite two filmmakers to live with her family for over a month between her conviction and the beginning of her custodial sentence. (At the time her lawyers had lodged an ultimately unsuccessful appeal and she was living at home on bail until it could be heard.)

The filmmakers could 'see everything' and help reframe Holmes in the public eye. One of them, Nathan Fielder, is a US comedian who has a style reminiscent of Louis Theroux; a wry, awkward on–screen presence who is expert at encouraging his subjects to relax and let their guard down.

But as Fielder gets to know Holmes, it is he, not she, who lets their guard down.

One minute she is showing flashes of the bleach–blonde tyrant of Theranos; the next she's crying or cuddling her three–month–old baby daughter or son

The gazes between them are lingering, the chemistry palpable. In one hold–your–breath exchange, she stares at him in silence, a half–smile on her face, something indefinable in her eyes.

We see him sucked in, hypnotised by her intensity. This is all the more extraordinary because, unlike all those investors seduced by Holmes, Fielder knew the bad stuff: how she bullied employees, sacked dozens of them, lied and lied again.

He knew that those lies could have killed, because she was using sick people as guinea pigs for her faulty blood–testing machines.

And yet, over the course of the film, it is strongly suggested that Fielder has fallen for Elizabeth's charms too.

As he admitted recently: 'She was so different than I thought she would be. She was disarming in real life.'

Just like the investors she bewitched, Fielder seems hooked by the Holmes cocktail of confidence and vulnerability.

One minute she is showing flashes of the bleach–blonde tyrant of Theranos; the next she's crying or cuddling her three–month–old baby daughter or son, then nearly two, looking like any other frizzy–haired mum you might see wandering at Walmart.

Fielder reflects: 'In my life, I've never been so confused by a person.'

What complicates things further is that when it comes to toxic relationships, it seems Holmes is not the only one pulling the strings. In You Can See Everything we expect the villain to be Holmes, but a greater one appears in the form of her own partner. 

Billy Evans – scion of a hugely wealthy family – is shifty and manipulative and apparently unaware of how awfully he comes across.

He controls his partner in myriad ways, from scolding Elizabeth about the way she is scrambling eggs to taking over her social media account, becoming her power of attorney and gloating that he can 'literally do anything'.

This isn't even Elizabeth Holmes's first controlling relationship. While building Theranos, she had a long love affair with Sunny Balwani, a tech executive 20 years her senior.

During her court case she alleged that Balwani would repeatedly criticise her, scolding that she 'came across as a little girl'. On the stand she tearfully recounted a pattern of abuse, physical and psychological.

Now, it seems, she has become ensnared with another controlling man. Even after her imprisonment, Evans has sought to monetise his association with her, in ways I will not reveal for fear of spoiling surprises in the film. What can be revealed is that he is a wrong 'un.

This is yet another riddle running through You Can See Everything: is Holmes such a master at pulling the strings of the documentary makers and viewers that she has managed to frame her husband as the real villain, thus inducing sympathy for herself? Or is she another woman who is being controlled by an unpleasant man? Victim or manipulator? Vulnerable or calculating?

Nathan Fielder rejects the idea that she has to be one thing or the other: 'Different things can be true about Elizabeth Holmes at the same time,' he says.

She's an enigma, a shape–shifter, a riddle. Loathe or pity her, she's mesmerising to watch – even if you can't, actually, see everything.

View the original on Daily Mail →

KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.