Forget Peaky Blinders, HBO's-56 Episode Thriller Masterpiece Is The Better Show

Sean is a senior writer for ScreenRant and has been writing about new TV releases since December 2023. He has received multiple advance screenings of popular shows and ideated his own coverage read by hundreds of thousands of readers.
Sean is a self-published author of a Western novel. Sean has also written award-winning opinion pieces related to local politics while getting his Bachelor's degree in journalism.
Though Peaky Blinders is often and rightfully called one of the greatest gangster dramas of all time, another gangster show from HBO with 56 episodes is even better. Peaky Blinders is frequently mentioned in the same breath as some of the greatest gangster shows of all time, like The Sopranos. It's easy to see why; Peaky Blinders is filled to the brim with stars like Cillian Murphy, it features some of the smartest and most suspenseful writing on television, and it was an international mega-hit that even got its own sequel movie earlier this year.
There's absolutely no denying that Peaky Blinders is one of the best gangster shows and crime dramas ever made. Every season of Peaky Blinders is a hit with new and intense stories, gripping characters, and bombshell moments. As great as Peaky Blinders is, however, there's another period gangster show that has it beat: HBO's Boardwalk Empire, starring Steve Buscemi.
Boardwalk Empire follows Nucky Thompson (Buscemi), the county treasurer for Atlantic City during the early days of Prohibition in 1920. Despite his official office, Nucky runs Atlantic City like a mafia and has an extensive side business of bootlegging alcohol into the city. As Nucky tries to expand and maintain his criminal empire, he meets historical figures from all walks of life. It should be immediately evident how Boardwalk Empire is similar to Peaky Blinders, but it's also better than its successor.
Boardwalk Empire Is A Better Period Gangster Drama Than Peaky Blinders
There aren't many gangster shows that are also period dramas out there, but Boardwalk Empire is the best of them all, including Peaky Blinders. Peaky Blinders has very few problems, but it does have a handful. The seasons of Peaky Blinders could be rather inconsistent, with later seasons not quite reaching the highs of, say, season 4, for example. The show also lost a bit of magic when Tommy started focusing more on going legit and getting out of the gangster business.
Boardwalk Empire, on the other hand, doesn't have that inconsistency. For all five of its seasons, the series perfectly balanced the tension between Nucky's official duties and his work as a bootlegger. It also never lost its magic even as the pressure ramped up and Nucky's plans got bigger, unlike Peaky Blinders. From start to finish, Boardwalk Empire was never anything but an expertly crafted crime thriller with a laser-focused plot.
The world of Boardwalk Empire also manages to feel significantly larger than Peaky Blinders'. Boardwalk Empire had time to focus on other gangster outfits in cities like New York and Chicago, it spent much more time looking at the legal opposition to Nucky's bootlegging empire, and it could explore the everyday life of people living in the 1920s. Essentially, Boardwalk Empire did everything Peaky Blinders did, plus a bit extra.
Boardwalk Empire Is Essentially The American Version Of Peaky Blinders
Boardwalk Empire isn't just similar to Peaky Blinders in terms of quality, they're also remarkably similar shows in general. In many ways, Boardwalk Empire almost feels like the American version of Peaky Blinders. Both are period dramas that are very loosely based on real history and start within years of one another. Both Tommy Shelby and Nucky Thompson are charismatic, womanizing gangsters with political aspirations and incredibly complex morals. They're even both chased by brilliantly written lawmen who act as villains.
There are really only a handful of major differences between Boardwalk Empire and Peaky Blinders, setting aside the change in setting. Peaky Blinders is more focused on the family dynamics of the Shelby's and on Tommy's mental status, for example. Additionally, the timeline of Peaky Blinders spreads out far more than Boardwalk Empire's, as it goes from 1919 all the way to 1940.
Aside from those differences, however, Peaky Blinders and Boardwalk Empire scratch the exact same itch. They both feature whip-smart writing, a deep-dive into the history of organized crime, and a story that's filled with backstabbing, twists and turns, and suspense that's sure to keep you on the edge of your seat. In short, if you liked Peaky Blinders at all, you're going to love Boardwalk Empire.
- Release Date
- 2010 - 2014-00-00
- Showrunner
- Terence Winter
- Directors
- Timothy Van Patten, Allen Coulter
- Writers
- Terence Winter, Nelson Johnson
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.