ISL 2026-27: Controversial refereeing brings VAR back into discussion after Punjab’s draw with Chennaiyin


The Indian Super League match between Punjab FC and Chennaiyin FC saw several controversial calls, including the equaliser and a yellow card. | Photo Credit: ISL Media
The Indian Super League match between Punjab FC and Chennaiyin FC saw several controversial calls, including the equaliser and a yellow card. | Photo Credit: ISL Media
Controversial refereeing during the 2026-27 Indian Super League match between Chennaiyin FC and Punjab FC brought the spotlight back to the level of officiating in the league and whether the league needs to introduce the Video Assistant Referee (VAR).
The teams shared the spoils after a 1-1 draw at the Jawaharlal Nehru Stadium in Chennai on Saturday. After a Nikhil Prabhu own goal gave the host side an early lead, Cameroonian forward Raphael Messi Bouli equalised.
But video replay showed a few Punjab players, including Messi Bouli himself, in a possible offside position before the equaliser. The on-ground linesman, however, didn’t flag it.
“For me, the equaliser is a big question. You may see it again and have a look. It’s a clear offside by a metre. I don’t know who to blame, but you cannot miss this at this level. But these things happen all the time. We accept it, and now we can’t do anything,” Chennaiyin FC head coach Clifford Miranda said after the match.
Punjab’s counterpart, Pavlos Dermitzakis, too, went on a passionate rant about refereeing decisions on certain occasions that had gone against his team.
“In the first few games that we had, the referees were very good. Even without the assistance of technology and VAR, they have been perfect. For those games, I want to congratulate them,” the Greek coach began.
“But today, I felt they were not fair to us on three occasions,” he added.
ALSO READ | ISL 2026-27: Messi Bouli salvages draw for Punjab FC against Chennaiyin FC
One of the instances was a yellow card shown to Messi Bouli during a duel for the ball against defender Emmanuel Imanishimwe. It was Messi Bouli’s fourth yellow card of the season, making him unavailable for selection for Punjab’s next match against NorthEast United FC.
“We need to be shown more respect. We are a team which produces players for the national team and those who will be the future.
“Not playing on our own home ground doesn’t make us weak. We are a big club, and they have to treat us like this. We are a team which suffers every week, travels every week. We are not asking for something more, just 50-50,” Dermitzakis concluded.
Meanwhile, when Miranda was asked whether ISL should introduce VAR, he said that it wasn’t a decision for him to make.
“It is for the league to decide. Whatever help is required must be given. Even at the highest level, like the Premier League, referees need help. I can speak from my standpoint, where I felt it [Punjab’s goal] was clear offside, but again, we are humans.”
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.