Josh Allen's MVP Case Faces An Unexpected Roadblock As Ryan Clark Questions What Makes Him Award-Worthy

Ryan Clark snubs Josh Allen from his top three MVP candidates© Getty via AFP
Ryan Clark left Josh Allen out of his top three NFL MVP candidates on Monday, and Bills fans noticed right away. The former ESPN analyst named Joe Burrow, Brock Purdy and Trevor Lawrence on X instead. That came a day after Buffalo beat the Jets 31-12 to improve to 8-1. Allen won the award in 2024. Clark's biggest objection is how Allen's touchdowns get counted, since he says eight of them came on quarterback sneaks. He believes those scores do not carry the same weight as what his three picks are producing this season.
Ryan Clark explains why Josh Allen's MVP case falls short
“Josh Allen is NOT a top 3 MVP candidate!” Clark wrote on X. He then named Burrow, Purdy and Lawrence as his three and added, “Love Josh, but we can't confuse who he IS with how he's PLAYING!” In other words, Clark is judging this season's play, not Allen's name value.
The race is crowded.
PFN's Nov. 10 panel of MVP predictions included Allen among four legitimate candidates with Burrow, Purdy and Jordan Love, and Ian Cummings favored Burrow in a tight race with Purdy. The records show why the field is bunched up. Burrow's Bengals and Lawrence's Jaguars are both 7-2, while Allen's Bills and Purdy's 49ers share an 8-1 mark. Allen has 24 touchdowns, 13 passing and 11 rushing. Purdy has 20 touchdown passes and Lawrence has 21. Allen sits seventh on PFN's QB Impact Metric.
Purdy matches Buffalo's record with more passing touchdowns than Allen, and that is the sharpest contrast in Clark's case.
Sunday's game gives both sides an argument
Clark saw the replies coming. “And enough with the total TD graphics! We KNOW he has 8 QB sneak TDs. They count, and they take toughness & skill, but they aren't equivalent to what Joe, Brock & Trevor are doing!” He closed with “All TDs count. They don't all tell the same MVP story!”
He is not waving off the sneaks. He is asking what they say about a season.
Sunday gave both camps something to use. Allen threw for 196 yards and one touchdown, ran for two more and tossed an interception. He gained only five yards on the ground. James Cook carried the run game with 157 yards, including a 74-yard score, in the 31-12 win.
Supporters can fairly say a dependable goal-line weapon has real value, because defenses know Allen might keep it. Clark's post suggests a one-yard finish is not the same as the drive that got Buffalo there.
Allen gets his answers soon. Miami is next. The Chiefs, Patriots, Packers, Bears and Broncos are also still ahead. Six games will say more than any graphic.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.