Man orders silver coins online, gets rakhis instead, consumer panel awards Rs 20,000

A Delhi consumer commission has directed an e-commerce platform to pay Rs 20,000 compensation to a customer who ordered four silver coins online but allegedly received two packets of rakhis instead.
President Monika Srivastava and members Rajender Dhar and Ritu Garodia observed that the platform should have provided a replacement for the product originally ordered by the complainant, rather than merely refunding the amount.
“We find OP guilty of deficiency in service and also unfair trade practice and direct OP-1 to pay Rs 20,000 as compensation for mental harassment and physical inconveniences,” the commission said.
The complainant had placed an online order on November 10, 2023, for four 50-gram silver coins of 999 purity at an offer price of Rs 5,996. He alleged that when the parcel was delivered two days later, he opened it in the presence of the delivery person and found two packets of rakhis instead of the silver coins. The delivery person allegedly refused to take back the shipment or provide a replacement and asked him to contact customer support.
He subsequently raised a complaint with the platform. Although the company acknowledged the issue, it refunded Rs 5,996 on November 26, 2023.
The complainant approached the consumer commission, alleging that the refund deprived him of the opportunity to purchase the same quantity of silver at the original offer price, as the product’s listed price had increased.
The seller and its proprietor, however, argued that the customer had already received a full refund while retaining the delivered goods. They also questioned the absence of photographic or video evidence proving delivery of wrong product.
Story continues below this ad
The commission noted that the complainant had submitted photographs showing the delivery packaging and two packets of rakhis, along with the invoice and customer-care correspondence. It also noted that the e-commerce company did not appear before the commission despite being served notice and was proceeded against ex parte.
Referring to the consumer protection (e-commerce) rules, the commission observed that e-commerce entities were liable for unfair trade practices and sellers were required to fulfil their obligations regarding the delivery of goods and services as committed.
“It is also observed that the complainant had never requested OP-1 for a refund. Even then, OP-1 refunded an amount of Rs 5,996 to the complainant. OP-1 should have provided a replacement of the product originally ordered by the complainant, rather than merely refunding the amount paid by him,” the commission said.
It therefore held the e-commerce platform guilty of deficiency in service and unfair trade practice and directed it to pay Rs 20,000 as compensation for mental harassment and physical inconveniences.
Story continues below this ad
Takeaway
E-commerce platforms cannot escape liability when an incorrect product is delivered. They are responsible for ensuring that customers receive the goods they ordered, and failure to provide the promised product or an appropriate replacement can amount to deficiency in service.
Don’t miss out on these stories:
Railway ‘fails to extend’ season ticket despite train disruption, Haryana man wins Rs 5,000
Paid Rs 1.3 lakh for son’s speech therapy but ‘got no results’, father wins Rs 2 lakh payout
Charged Rs 125 ‘express fare’ on passenger train, man wins Rs 5,300 from railways
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.