Does Elon Musk ‘owe’ South Africa anything?

President Cyril Ramaphosa’s claim that Elon Musk’s humble beginnings are attributed to his South African education, and that the world’s richest man should “give back” to his country, has been met with angry reactions on social media.
The president was speaking during a work trip to the US, where he was invited to speak at Semafor’s World Change discussion this week
Musk – who was born in Pretoria – left home just before his 18th birthday to study in Canada, his mother Maye’s birthplace. He later resettled in the US.
Apart from being a South African, he also holds both Canadian and US citizenship, the latter obtained through naturalisation in 2002.
CYRIL RAMAPHOSA SUGGESTS ELON MUSK’S SUCCESS IS A CREDIT TO SA
Speaking to ABC News host Jonathan Karl, President Ramaphosa recalled meeting Elon Musk for the first time in late 2024. He claimed that he was keen for the world’s richest man to create investment opportunities.
He shared: “I’ve always been awed by his brilliance. But also, I‘d like to chat to him about remembering his country
Ramaphosa added: “Even as one is a citizen of another country, you should still be loyal to your own country”.
The president claimed that Musk – who has accused South Africa of enforcing “super-racist laws” over his failed Starlink bid – had received a better education than black people during Apartheid. He attributed this to Musk’s success.
He continued: “The education that he would have received, a much better education than the Apartheid government [spent on mine]. So if one does not understand that, they will never be able to understand precisely what needs to be done to remedy the harm that was done.
“What you have become today is by dint of your own origins. Where you were initially educated, where you began dabbling in these things… it’s because of the knowledge and education that was made available to him
“This endowment that he now has was formed in South Africa, and he should be one of those that say, ‘I would like to contribute to the development of South Africa and give back to this country that made me who I am today’”.
— Semafor (@semafor) November 16, 2026"I have met Elon Musk in the past, and I've been awed by his brilliance. But I'd also like to chat to him about remembering his country," South African President Cyril Ramaphosa tells @jonkarl.
"What you've become today is by dint of your own origins … It is because of the… pic.twitter.com/YJpqozgjQR
‘HE DOESN’T OWE YOU ANYTHING’
On the X app, which Elon Musk owns, a clip of Ramaphosa implying that the former president should not only be loyal but also contribute to his country left many users outraged by the president’s “entitlement”.
Here are a few responses…
@dickyd64: “Now he’s trying to take credit for@elonmusk success! What arrogance!”
@greybtc: “Claiming to have made Elon Musk is quite a reach 💀”
@MyT_Words: “Right; Elon’s brilliant mind and relentless curiosity and pursuit of truth and understanding and all the time he spent educating himself with anything available at all that he could get his hands on and years of work and angst and struggle and inventiveness had nothing at all to do with it”
@Pirate747John: “Elon doesn’t need your approval or owe you anything”
After leaving South Africa at the age of 17, Elon Musk briefly stayed in Canada – his mother Maye Musk’s place of birth – before settling down in the US.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.