Jimmy, Kunle, Rotimi: Three pastors at the centre of Fountain of Life’s succession crisis

Three pastors now stand at different points in the leadership crisis rocking The Fountain of Life Church.
Jimmy Odukoya occupies the office of senior pastor and insists his appointment remains valid. Kunle Areogun appears in a purported recording as the late founder’s preferred successor. Rotimi Okpaise, who announced Jimmy’s appointment in 2023, has now been named interim spiritual and administrative leader by the trustees seeking Jimmy’s removal.
The conflicting roles reflect the questions at the heart of the dispute: who has the authority to lead the church, which group represents its legitimate Board of Trustees, and whether the late Taiwo Odukoya’s purported recorded instruction can overturn the succession process conducted after his death.
Jimmy Odukoya: The disputed officeholder
Jimmy transitioned from Nollywood to church leadership in September 2023 when he assumed the position of senior pastor at The Fountain of Life Church after his father’s death.
Before embracing the pulpit, he had built an acting career. He appeared in several productions, including “I Am Nazzy”, “Mambam’s Diamond”, “Crazy Grannies”, “The Wait”, “Cooked Up Love”, “The Bosslady”, “Faded Lines”, among others.
He also featured in the Hollywood production “The Woman King.” Jimmy is the late cleric’s first son with his first wife, Bimbo Odukoya.
Announcing his appointment to the congregation, Mr Okpaise disclosed that the Board of Trustees (BoT) unanimously chose Jimmy to lead the church as senior pastor and chairperson of the board.
He also said the board scheduled his installation for 30 September 2023. Before his appointment, Jimmy married Kemi Odukoya in 2013. The couple welcomed two children before their marriage ended.
Since taking charge of the church, Jimmy has combined pastoral leadership with regular preaching, addressing issues such as faith, spiritual identity, personal growth and fresh beginnings.
He has also used digital platforms, including YouTube and SoundCloud, to share his messages. At church gatherings and other public engagements, he has repeatedly urged people to let go of past hurts and disappointments and embrace the possibilities ahead.
On 1 November, he introduced Mo Jasyme as his new wife before the congregation. The founder of Citadel Global Community Church, Tunde Bakare, blessed the marriage and prayed for God’s continued guidance over their home.
Mr Bakare also asked God to strengthen their union and make their household a hub for kingdom activities.
However, the pastor’s position at the church came under scrutiny on 17 November when the Board of Trustees announced his removal with immediate effect.
The board attributed its decision to a review of a previously undisclosed video reportedly containing succession instructions from the church’s late founder.
Jimmy’s sister, Tolu Odukoya-Ijogun, confirmed the statement’s authenticity to PREMIUM TIMES but declined to comment on its contents.
The announcement triggered a dispute, with Jimmy and the church rejecting the board’s decision hours after its release. The church maintained that Jimmy remained its senior pastor and chairman of the Board of Trustees, raising questions about which group of trustees had the authority to oversee its affairs.
Amid the controversy, the 39-year-old has yet to comment publicly on the alleged video in which his father reportedly identified Mr Areogun as his successor.
Kunle Areogun: The purportedly chosen successor
Until the video emerged presenting him as the purported successor, Mr Arogun largely stayed out of the public spotlight.
However, records published on Fountain of Life Church’s website show that Mr Arogun had served in the ministry for several years. He also preached at the church in 2017, 2018 and subsequent years. One of his sermons, titled “God of the Unusual”, explored the role of faith in helping Christians overcome difficult circumstances.
A 2021 memorial publication dedicated to Nomthi, the late wife of Taiwo Odukoya, also acknowledged Mr Arogun’s position in the ministry. The publication identified him as one of Fountain of Life Church’s pastors alongside prominent members, including Jimmy Odukoya, Tolu Odukoya-Ijogun, Ibukun Awosika and Rotimi Okpaise.
Subsequent church records indicate that Mr Arogun maintained an active preaching schedule in the years that followed.
At the church’s first Sunday service in January 2022, he delivered a sermon on unity and spiritual growth. He also addressed the congregation during the church’s Mother’s Day service in May of the same year, drawing lessons from Mary, the mother of Jesus, and highlighting the values of trustworthiness, obedience and faith.
Mr Arogun, 62, combines a career in engineering and corporate management with Christian ministry.
He has worked in the oil and gas and maritime sectors while serving as a pastor at Fountain of Life Church, whose headquarters is in Ilupeju, Lagos.
He currently serves as managing director of Bourbon Interoil Nigeria Limited, an offshore marine services company operating in Nigeria’s oil and gas industry. His professional experience covers chemical engineering, commercial management, business development and offshore marine operations.
Mr Arogun studied Chemical Engineering at the Obafemi Awolowo University, Ile-Ife, between 1982 and 1987, earning a bachelor’s degree.
His relationship with the late Mr Odukoya dates back to their professional engagements in the oil industry. The two men became friends before Mr Odukoya left the sector to devote himself to full-time ministry.
Their careers also intersected professionally. In a regulatory announcement published in July 2007, Afren listed both men among the board and management team of Excel Exploration and Production.
Rotimi Okpaise: From announcing Jimmy to interim leader
Mr Okpaise’s involvement in the dispute goes beyond his current position as interim pastor.
He has served the Fountain of Life Church for several years and frequently ministered during its services. After Taiwo’s death, he addressed the congregation, calling on members to preserve the church’s unity and ensure its continued progress.
He also played a crucial role in the leadership transition, announcing Jimmy’s appointment in September 2023.
However, after the church’s trustees removed Jimmy, they appointed Mr Okpaise as interim pastor to oversee the ministry.
Outside the church, Mr Okpaise has accumulated more than three decades of experience in actuarial services, insurance and consultancy.
His professional profile on the CrusaderSterling Pensions website shows that he retired from Ernst & Young, where he worked as a partner and led the firm’s insurance sector and actuarial services practice across West Africa.
He previously provided statutory actuarial services to several prominent insurance companies in the region. He also served as reporting actuary to four Contributory Pension Fund Administrators (CPFAs), as well as the pension schemes of the Nigerian National Petroleum Company (NNPC) and the National Pension Commission (PenCom).
His professional credentials include Fellowship of the Institute of Actuaries in the UK and Associate membership of the Society of Actuaries in the US.
Academically, Mr Okpaise studied Statistics at the University of Ibadan (UI), where he earned recognition as a University Scholar. He later attended the Lagos Business School’s Chief Executive Programme.
His LinkedIn profile lists him as Executive Chairman of Zamara Consulting Actuaries Nigeria and an independent director of a health maintenance organisation and a pension fund administrator.
Before retiring from EY, he served as managing partner of H R Nigeria, an actuarial consultancy that later merged with the firm.
Mr Okpaise has also expressed an interest in improving insurance penetration across West Africa. His professional biography describes insurance as an important social tool that remains largely unfamiliar to the region’s population.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.
