The Muppet Christmas Carol Has One Huge Advantage Over Johnny Depp's Ebenezer
Katrina joined ScreenRant as a news writer in 2024, covering box office, expert interviews, exclusives, and new releases. Her work has appeared in CBR, All About Jazz, Rising Artists, and numerous other publications. She has an MFA in Creative Writing and has published more than 20 books. She currently writes for ScreenRant’s movie features team.
Sign in to your ScreenRant account
Charles Dickens' classic tale, A Christmas Carol, has been adapted for various media countless times over the years. IMDb lists at least 273 versions of it. From George C. Scott to Jim Carrey and Sir Patrick Stewart, many famous actors have played the role of Ebenezer Scrooge. Among countless versions, The Muppet Christmas Carol is regarded as one of the best adaptations of Dickens' tale.
Coming to theaters on November 13, Johnny Depp is bringing a new rendition of Scrooge to the big screen in a Ti West-directed gothic horror reimagining of Dickens' tale titled Ebenezer this year.
Ahead of the movie's release, Ebenezer's official trailer has given potential viewers a look at Depp's titular character as well as the film's tone. While it promises humor and laughter against a gothic atmosphere, The Muppets' Christmas classic has one thing West's new movie doesn't have.
The Muppet Christmas Carol Perfectly Balances Dickens' Darkness With Humor And Heart
A Christmas Carol tells a chilling story about Ebenezer Scrooge, who, before the visits of the three spirits make him a changed man, is cruel to his workers and indifferent to others' sufferings.
Known as a man who only cares about his own material wealth, Scrooge, at the beginning of the story, isn't a likable character, but with lovable muppets and heartwarming songs, The Muppet Christmas Carol manages to infuse the story with warmth and humor that balances Scrooge's bitterness and slowly dissolves his coldness.
Question 1 of 3
Not only do The Muppets make the tale more accessible for younger viewers, but they also make Scrooge's change inevitable. After all, no man can stay unmoved watching Tiny Tim get sick. In The Muppet Christmas Carol, Scrooge doesn't just see the consequences and possible future of his past actions. His change has everything to do with being touched by everyone else's Christmas spirit and rediscovering the compassion within himself.
The Muppets are perfect for their supporting roles. The Great Gonzo makes a great Charles Dickens as he narrates the story alongside his sidekick, Rizzo the Rat. Moreover, The Muppet Christmas Carol preserves much of Dickens' original dialogue and is hailed as a faithful adaptation.
Johnny Depp's Ebenezer Faces An Impossible Task Matching The Muppets' Timeless Christmas Classic
Michael Caine's Scrooge is widely considered one of the best performances of the character on screen, which makes it a hard task for any actor to match.
Caine played his role straight without treating The Muppets as puppets. He also leaned into Scrooge's more vulnerable side in his performance and made his character more relatable to viewers by showing them that even a person with a tough exterior like Scrooge can be tender and vulnerable inside.
The Muppets, on the other hand, are the perfect crew to spread Christmas joy. The chemistry is nearly impossible to recreate on screen. The contrast between Caine and The Muppets is what also makes The Muppet Christmas Carol a timeless classic.
Scratch & Peek
Identify the cover art while scratching off as little foil as possible.
Johnny Depp has made a name for himself by playing odd characters. He brings a blend of humor and quirkiness to nearly every character he plays. Ebenezer's official trailer sees him take a similar approach to Scrooge. His version of the character acts cartoonish at times and seems slightly emotionally detached in comparison to Caine.
However, the first reactions to Ti West's gothic adaptation suggest that the trailer may have disproportionately showcased Depp's humorous side. Critics who were invited to see the advance screening of the new movie have reported being impressed by how layered Depp's performance turned out to be. Some also believed that Ebenezer brings more sincerity than most adaptations.
While it seems impossible for Ebenezer to recreate the magic in The Muppet Christmas Carol, the movie might be a worthy contender.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.