Maharashtra consumer panel orders insurer to pay Rs 87.33 lakh for fire claim
![]()
Abhishek Dhanresha, owner of Mateshri Textiles, faced an insurance claim repudiation from United India Insurance after a factory fire (AI image)
MUMBAI: Abhishek Dhanresha was the proprietor of Mateshri Textiles which manufactured towels and napkins at Solapur.The unit was insured by United India Insurance under three policies - one for the factory building, the second for plant and machinery, and the third for the stock of finished and semi-finished goods, and raw materials.The total coverage under all the three policies amounted to Rs.91,50,000/. Prior to issuing the policies, the insurer had conducted a thorough inspection of the factory premises along with photographic documentation.On July 21, 2017 an electrical short circuit caused an accidental fire in the factory premises. This was immediately communicated to the police, fire department, electrical inspector, and the insurer.
Later, a comprehensive claim for Rs.87,33,324/ was lodged.The insurer appointed a surveyor to assess the loss. Over a year later, the insurer sent a letter dated July 16, 2018 intimating that the claim was repudiated on the ground that there was illegal construction and unauthorized electric connection on the ground and second floors.
Besides, the absence of fire extinguishing appliances was construed as negligence and a breach of the terms of the policy.
The insured filed a complaint before the Maharashtra State Commission challenging the repudiation.The State Commission observed that the crux of the dispute was the unauthorized construction, unauthorized electricity connection, and absence of fire-fighting appliances.However, it noted that the insurer had had inspected the premises and then issued the policy with open eyes without raising any objection in respect of the alleged lapses and breaches.
Hence the Commission concluded that the insurer could not be allowed to subsequently raise objections to avoid settlement of the claim and defeat the objective of taking insurance coverage.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.