7 Psychological Thrillers To Watch After Verity

Published Oct 5, 2026, 12:12 PM EDT

Senior Music Editor at Screen Rant, Sarah's love of sound and story drive the beat. A globetrotting brand whisperer and award-winning journalist, she’s built cross-cultural narratives around the world—but music has always been her true north. She launched DJ Mag North America, successfully introducing the iconic UK brand to the U.S. market. Previously, she carved a space for EDM inside the pages of VIBE, blending electronic and hip-hop culture long before it was trendy.
 

Summary

• Verity mixes seduction, shifting loyalties, and unreliable narration that fuels post-movie debate.
• If you liked Verity’s tone, pair it with twisty domestic thrillers or films built on deceptive perspectives.
• Recommended matches: Gone Girl, A Simple Favor, The Gift, Side Effects, Shutter Island, The Handmaiden, Black Swan.

Verity arrived in theaters with plenty working in its favor: a massively popular Colleen Hoover novel, Anne Hathaway and Dakota Johnson facing off onscreen, and the kind of premise that practically demands viewers spend the drive home arguing about what they just watched.

The movie also topped the domestic box office in its opening weekend with $32.6 million, suggesting plenty of people are now looking for another thriller capable of scratching the same itch. Directed by Michael Showalter, Verity follows struggling writer Lowen Ashleigh (Johnson), who is hired to finish the book series of bestselling author Verity Crawford (Hathaway) after Verity is left incapacitated. Lowen moves into the Crawford home, where she discovers a manuscript containing revelations that make it increasingly difficult to determine where fiction ends and truth begins. Josh Hartnett completes the triangle as Verity's husband, Jeremy.

The best follow-up movies might not necessarily copy that setup. However, they do need the same feeling: shifting loyalties, dangerous attraction, and the suspicion that somebody has been controlling the story all along. From modern domestic thrillers to a few particularly nasty exercises in unreliable narration, these seven psychological thrillers pair extremely well with Verity.

Gone Girl

There is a reason Gone Girl remains the unavoidable comparison whenever a glossy new psychological thriller involves marriage, deception, and a woman who may be several moves ahead of everyone around her. David Fincher's 2014 adaptation of Gillian Flynn's novel begins with the disappearance of Amy Dunne (Rosamund Pike), leaving husband Nick (Ben Affleck) to face growing public suspicion as uncomfortable details about their marriage emerge.

A decade later, the movie's ability to constantly shift the audience's allegiance remains lethal. Pike's Amy is one of the great modern thriller creations, while Fincher keeps the entire story cold, controlled, and viciously funny. Gone Girl even became a major Netflix hit again in 2026, proving its particular brand of relationship warfare has lost very little potency.

A Simple Favor

If the pulpy side of Verity is what worked for you, A Simple Favor makes a particularly good second half of the double feature. Anna Kendrick plays Stephanie, an eager mommy vlogger who becomes fascinated with the effortlessly glamorous Emily Nelson (Blake Lively). When Emily suddenly disappears after asking Stephanie to pick up her son, curiosity turns into amateur detective work.

Paul Feig understands that a movie this twisty should be allowed to have some fun with itself. Martini glasses, immaculate suits, and dark comedy sit comfortably beside murder, betrayal, and increasingly improbable revelations. Anyone searching for more movies in the Gone Girl vein should start here, particularly if Verity's mixture of seduction and suspicion was more appealing than its darkest material.

The Gift

Image via MovieStillsDB

Joel Edgerton's The Gift begins with a seemingly minor intrusion. Married couple Simon (Jason Bateman) and Robyn (Rebecca Hall) encounter Gordo (Edgerton), an old acquaintance of Simon's who starts leaving gifts at their home. His friendliness becomes uncomfortable, and the more Robyn learns about her husband's history with Gordo, the less certain she becomes about the man she married.

Like Verity, the movie gets considerable mileage from deciding whose version of events deserves to be trusted. Bateman is especially effective playing against his comedic persona, gradually revealing edges that change the audience's understanding of the central conflict. The movie's final stretch leaves plenty deliberately unresolved, which is one reason The Gift's alternate ending would have created such a different impression.

Side Effects

Steven Soderbergh's Side Effects is best experienced knowing as little as possible. Rooney Mara stars as Emily Taylor, whose husband Martin (Channing Tatum) has recently been released from prison. After Emily begins struggling with depression, psychiatrist Jonathan Banks (Jude Law) prescribes her a new medication. A shocking incident follows, seemingly turning the movie into a drama about mental health, responsibility, and the pharmaceutical industry.

Then Soderbergh starts moving the furniture around. Side Effects gradually becomes something far slipperier, with apparent victims and villains changing places as hidden motives emerge. Mara's performance is key: she can appear fragile in one moment and unreadable the next. For Verity viewers who most enjoyed wondering who was manipulating whom, this may be the sharpest recommendation on the list.

Shutter Island

Martin Scorsese takes unreliable perspective to an entirely different level with Shutter Island. Leonardo DiCaprio plays U.S. Marshal Teddy Daniels, who arrives at an isolated psychiatric hospital in 1954 to investigate the disappearance of a patient. A violent storm traps him on the island, while evasive doctors and increasingly disturbing discoveries convince Teddy that something far larger is being concealed.

The pleasure comes from realizing that nearly every detail deserves another look. DiCaprio gives the movie enough emotional intensity to keep its central mystery grounded even as Teddy's certainty begins to fracture. Like Verity, Shutter Island leaves audiences reconsidering earlier scenes once more information is revealed, and its ending continues to inspire competing interpretations years later.

The Handmaiden

Park Chan-wook's The Handmaiden is the most elaborate movie on this list, but its mixture of sex, manipulation, and competing versions of the truth makes it an excellent companion to Verity. Set in Korea during Japanese colonial rule, the film follows Sook-hee (Kim Tae-ri), a pickpocket hired to become the maid of wealthy heiress Lady Hideko (Kim Min-hee).

The job is part of a scheme to convince Hideko to marry a con man who intends to steal her fortune, but knowing the plan hardly prepares viewers for where Park takes the story. Perspective shifts reveal information that completely alters scenes already witnessed, turning apparent certainties into carefully constructed deceptions. Few psychological thrillers are better at demonstrating how dramatically a story changes depending on who gets to tell it.

Question 1 of 3

Black Swan

Black Swan approaches psychological uncertainty from inside its protagonist's mind. Natalie Portman stars as Nina Sayers, a technically brilliant ballerina whose pursuit of perfection intensifies after she wins the lead in a production of Swan Lake. As pressure mounts, Nina becomes increasingly threatened by fellow dancer Lily (Mila Kunis), while her ability to distinguish genuine events from hallucination deteriorates.

Darren Aronofsky makes that uncertainty physically uncomfortable, forcing viewers to experience Nina's unraveling alongside her rather than safely observing it. Portman won an Oscar for the performance, and the film still generates debate over precisely what happens during its final act. Our breakdown of the Black Swan ending shows how much ambiguity Aronofsky packs into what initially looks like a straightforward story about artistic obsession.

• 

  Nina Sayers / The Swan Queen

• 

  Mila Kunis

  Lily / The Black Swan