InquirerNBI: Ashes given to pet owners negative for animal remainsDaily MaverickWHAT WE’RE WATCHING: VisionQuest — Marvel’s latest miniseries has big ideas, but not enough human feelingThe Jerusalem PostIsraeli joint mission trains Ghanaian students to build custom rehab gear for disabled youthPunch‘Bamayi’ chant sparks violence as suspected thugs attack APC convoy in Gombe한겨레김건희, 도이치 유죄 확정에 “죽어도 이해 못 해…정치권 영향 받아”Straits Times SportCadillac says stability and progress key after tough F1 debutCNN Türk20 KASIM İL İL HAVA DURUMU: Bugün havalar nasıl olacak? İstanbul, Ankara, İzmir'de yağmur var mı yok mu?ZDF heuteEntdecken Sie das ZDF-NachrichtenstudioSözcüAltın tepetaklak oldu: Gram dibi gördüThe Sydney Morning HeraldBeau Lamarre-Condon live updates: Crown prosecutor continues closing address after alleging cold-blooded murderRMF24Trump odniósł się do wpisu Tuska. Mówił też o „małych rakietach” w PolsceDaily Mail'We made it': Daughter of Joanne Young - whose husband drugged and raped her then invited five men to sexually assault her - speaks out on how proud she is of her 'incredibly strong' mother
The Daily Newsstand · Free, Always
Friday, November 20, 2026

VP team’s videos, witness questioned on relevance

Translate

MANILA, Philippines — The use of video clips of deceased personalities as part of the strategy to defend Vice President Sara Duterte did not sit well with some senator-judges, while the qualifications of the witness presented by her legal team also came under heavy scrutiny.

One senator-judge told Duterte’s lawyers to just “let the dead rest,” referring to the video of the late Sen. Miriam Defensor-Santiago criticizing prosecutors during the 2012 impeachment trial of the late Chief Justice Renato Corona for withdrawing five of eight articles of impeachment.

The defense also faced scrutiny over the credentials and testimony of lawyer and accountant Rainer dela Fuente, a former Anti-Money Laundering Council (AMLC) investigator.

Article continues after this advertisement

READ: Defense witness says 2-week report hard, as AMLC had no staff before

FEATURED STORIES

NEWSINFO

NEWSINFO

NEWSINFO

Dela Fuente admitted he had not examined the prosecution’s financial report or the underlying records. He conceded, however, that transactions of a company linked to Duterte’s husband carried “red flags.”

‘Let the dead rest’

Senator-judge Erwin Tulfo questioned the relevance of showing footage from a different case involving a different set of senators, which the court’s presiding officer allowed to be played during Thursday’s hearing.

“We’re like watching a movie. Let the dead rest. That is a different case, this is a different case,” Tulfo said.

Senator-judge Panfilo “Ping” Lacson also questioned the significance of Defensor-Santiago’s opinion in the earlier trial.

Article continues after this advertisement

He said he could not see its relevance to the current proceedings.

READ: VP Duterte camp’s witness says Cale88 transactions have ‘red flags’

Article continues after this advertisement

Defense counsel Mark Vinluan then showed a clip of Corona crying persecution when he also faced an impeachment trial in 2012. 

Corona described the treatment he and his family allegedly suffered during investigations into his wealth. He claimed they had been harassed by government agencies.

House prosecutor and Akbayan Rep. Chel Diokno objected, calling the footage an appeal to emotion and arguing that Corona’s statements were irrelevant and could not be tested through cross-examination.

“I do not see the relevance of the statements made by the Chief Justice Corona about his alleged persecution, except that it is an appeal to emotion that I believe has no place in this impeachment trial,” Diokno said.

Misleading

“Whatever question is asked, it would be immaterial, it would be irrelevant because we could not even cross-examine the late Chief Justice Corona on his statements. And it would be misleading because there is no such evidence of persecution in this case before the court,” he added.

Senator-judge Raffy Tulfo reminded the defense that Corona had been convicted after his impeachment trial over his statement of assets, liabilities and net worth (SALN) disclosures.

“Thank you to the defense for showing a video of former Chief Justice Corona, the late CJ Corona. But let me remind you, CJ Corona was impeached and convicted because he lied under oath in his SALN, right?” Tulfo said.

“That’s well taken, thank you,” Vinluan replied.

Presiding officer Francis Escudero allowed the clip to be played but warned the defense that it was doing so “at their peril,” given the outcome of Corona’s impeachment.

“Again, we’ll allow it, and as pointed out by Senator-judge Raffy, at their peril as well because we know what happened with respect to that case, the testimony being shown notwithstanding,” Escudero said.

The defense also presented a clip of former President Rodrigo Duterte saying he opposed an impeachment complaint against then Vice President Leni Robredo and would not allow it to happen.

Senator-judge Risa Hontiveros raised concerns over the use of all three videos, noting that Defensor-Santiago and Corona had died and Duterte was not in the country. None could be questioned by the senator-judges.

“This situation is not fair. It is not fair, either to the three people whose videos were shown, and it is not fair for this Senate impeachment court,” Hontiveros said.

Defensor-Santiago died of cancer in September 2016 while Corona succumbed to cardiac arrest five months earlier.

Desperate, unethical

In a posttrial press briefing, prosecution spokesperson and Lanao del Sur Rep. Zia Alonto Adiong described the presentation as desperate.

He questioned why the defense was invoking people who could no longer be summoned or cross-examined instead of presenting evidence to refute the allegations.

He also called the move unethical, saying the clips concerned Corona’s impeachment and had no bearing on Duterte’s case.

During the trial, the video controversy came as senator-judges challenged the qualifications and credibility of Dela Fuente, whom the defense presented to counter Article 2 of the impeachment complaint.

The article accuses Duterte of amassing P817 million in unexplained wealth, failing to fully disclose her assets and liabilities in her SALNs, and retaining business interests while serving as Vice President.

Senator-judge Raffy Tulfo questioned whether Dela Fuente was qualified to comment on matters extending beyond his expertise as an antimoney laundering practitioner.

“Is he a super witness, omni witness? What kind of witness is the defense presenting? He’s meddling even [with the statements of] amici curiae, Supreme Court… Ombudsman… DOJ… Who is he? Who is this guy?” Tulfo asked.

Senator-judge Joel Villanueva said Dela Fuente could offer an expert opinion within his field but should not declare AMLC findings wrong or invalid, leaving the court to determine the weight of the evidence.

Dela Fuente admitted he had not seen the documents underlying the report prepared by prosecution witness and financial forensic analyst Alexander Cabrera, whom Vinluan repeatedly described as a “so-called expert.”

Senator-judge Bam Aquino asked whether Dela Fuente had received AMLC records, bank statements, insurance placements and general information sheets of Duterte’s companies. The witness repeatedly answered, “None.”

Vinluan confirmed that the defense had not given him Cabrera’s report. Dela Fuente also told Hontiveros that he had not read the full report.

“If he is to refute the report, then he should have seen the report, should have read the report,” Villanueva said. He warned that the testimony would be useless if the witness could not answer questions about it.

Senator-judge Erwin Tulfo said Dela Fuente’s testimony was theoretical because he had not examined the underlying covered and suspicious transaction reports.

“If he didn’t see the documents, STRs (Suspicious Transaction Reports), CTRs (Covered Transaction Reports), what good is it? What kind of testimony will he have? It’s all just theory in his eyes, in his beliefs,” Tulfo said.

“The witnesses that you’re presenting here these past few days are weak. Get somebody who can really stand up, who can really answer questions from the senator-judges,” he added.

Red flags

During Hontiveros’ questioning about Cale88 Foods Corp., a company linked to Duterte’s husband, lawyer Manases Carpio, Dela Fuente admitted “red flags” that should be scrutinized.

Your subscription could not be saved. Please try again.

Your subscription has been successful.

Hontiveros cited AMLC records showing P776.64 million in bank inflows, compared with P208.49 million in sales declared to the Bureau of Internal Revenue. She also noted that the company had only two employees and received P319.33 million in remittances from mainland China and Hong Kong. —With reports from Maila Ager, John Eric Mendoza and Isabelle Pechay

View the original on Inquirer →

KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.