PunchUS accuses Minnesota lawmaker-elect’s wife of illegal entryCNN TürkHava Durumu (20-11-2026)InquirerVP trial Day 45: Defense to present DTI, FDA, Citem witnesses on Cale88한겨레난계 박연 고장 영동 국악박물관 ‘무료’Inquirer EntertainmentNCDA urges disability sensitivity in media after alleged mockery of PWDs in ‘PBB’ZDF heuteEntdecken Sie das ZDF-NachrichtenstudioStraits Times SportPakistan beat Sri Lanka by 8 wickets to claim seriesSportstarIndia vs New Zealand, 1st Test Day 2: Jaiswal-Rahul opening act leaves Wellington showdown in the balanceGIGAZINEメモリ圧縮を使えばCPUの処理能力を少し犠牲にするだけでメモリ使用量を大幅に削減できるBBC BusinessSocial poker with £5 stake is booming, says dealerSoompiSeo Hyun Jin Begins To Suspect Even Those Closest To Her In “The Perfect Lie”Khaosod EnglishThailand, China push rail links to Malaysia and Singapore following Anutin-Xi talks
The Daily Newsstand · Free, Always
Friday, November 20, 2026

[Editorial] Supreme Court bends over backward to spare ex-PM Han

Translate

Han Duck-soo, the former prime minister of South Korea, arrives at the Seoul Central District Court in the city’s Seocho District for the Jan. 21, 2026, verdict hearing in his trial for engaging in essential activities in service of an insurrection for his role in the declaration of martial law by former President Yoon Suk-yeol. (Choi Hyeon-su/Hankyoreh)

Han Duck-soo, the former prime minister of South Korea, arrives at the Seoul Central District Court in the city’s Seocho District for the Jan. 21, 2026, verdict hearing in his trial for engaging in essential activities in service of an insurrection for his role in the declaration of martial law by former President Yoon Suk-yeol. (Choi Hyeon-su/Hankyoreh)

South Korea’s Supreme Court has thrown out the central charge against former Prime Minister Han Duck-soo, who received heavy prison sentences at both his trial and appeal for his part in the 2024 insurrection.

Han had recommended that Yoon Suk-yeol convene a Cabinet meeting before declaring martial law, which gave the declaration a veneer of legality. In ruling that this was not a crime, the Supreme Court is letting Han off with a slap on the wrist. 

Han will likely receive a much lighter sentence when the case is retried at the lower court. 

On Thursday, a full bench of the Supreme Court, presided over by Chief Justice Jo Hee-de, overturned the appellate ruling that handed Han 15 years in prison and sent the case back to the Seoul High Court. 

The nine-justice majority, which included Jo, found it “difficult to conclude” that Han had intended to subvert the constitutional order when he recommended the Cabinet meeting.

Han’s proposal to convene a Cabinet meeting constitutes the core charge for which both the first and second courts imposed severe sentences on the former prime minister, with the first court handing Han 23 years of imprisonment. 

The majority upheld only the lesser charges: pressuring Cabinet members for their signatures and discussing the implementation of power and water cuts to news outlets. 

Han did not simply propose that a Cabinet meeting be held — he also meticulously ensured a quorum by specifically selecting Cabinet members who could be summoned quickly. 

The trial and appeals courts both found that this was an act that gave an unconstitutional and illegal martial law declaration the appearance of having been deliberated by the Cabinet.

However, the Supreme Court viewed the act as a “legitimate official act requesting compliance with the procedures stipulated by the Constitution and the Martial Law Act.” The court focused on the formality of the Cabinet meeting, failing to correctly assess what the meeting was for and how it was convened. 

The dissenting of Justices Oh Kyeong-mi, Shin Suk-heui and Kim Seong-soo offer a more accurate assessment of the situation. In a self-coup, they wrote, acts of insurrection aimed at subverting the constitutional order take the form of normal, official acts of the state. For that reason, the fact that someone “followed the procedures set out by law” cannot be what separates lawful performance of duty from taking part in an insurrection.

The dissenters are right. Han had been well aware of the illegality of the martial law declaration, as he had received relevant documents, including the martial law decree, in advance. If his proposal to hold a perfunctory Cabinet meeting is not considered to have played a crucial role in the insurrection, what is?

The majority argued that finding intent to subvert the constitutional order too readily would set a wrong precedent, essentially telling people not to propose Cabinet deliberations in the future. That argument is pure sophistry. 

 In fact, it could send a different message to public officials: as long as you can uphold the pretense of legitimacy, you can avoid liability for participating in an insurrection. 

The fact that the majority cited the Constitutional Court’s decision to dismiss impeachment charges against Han as grounds for an acquittal is nothing short of preposterous. 

The Constitutional Court’s ruling was issued in March 2025, before the special counsel probe into the insurrection began. The special counsel probe submitted CCTV footage from the presidential office that showed Han’s actions before and after the Cabinet meeting, among other things, as evidence. The first and second instance courts accepted this as incriminating evidence. 

Unless the justices had made up their minds to go easy on Han, it is hard to see how they could have reached this verdict.

View the original on 한겨레 →

KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.