UK needs real China expertise, not more hawks and ideologues

If the British government wants to make an enemy of China, one sure way is to sideline the real experts – those who reject binary sound bites in favour of deeper analysis. That is the warning from the sinologist Kerry Brown, and it has sparked a debate in the Financial Times letters pages.
The trigger was a report by Lucy Fisher and Peter Foster, “Exodus of China experts raises red flags in Whitehall”, which Brown said gave him a sense of deja vu. A former Foreign and Commonwealth Office official, he now directs the Lau China Institute at King’s College London.
The neutrality and legitimacy of his institute have been questioned by UK-China Transparency, an NGO whose patrons include China hawks such as Baroness Annabel Goldie, a former minister of state for defence and current shadow defence minister, and Alicia Kearns, a Conservative member of parliament who once expressed concern Beijing was trying to harm her and her family.
The Financial Times reported that the Foreign Office has this year organised about a dozen full-day training sessions for diplomats and civil servants run by UK-China Transparency. I think that rather proves Brown’s point.
In his letter of November 13, “Security services have chilling effect on UK China watchers”, Brown argued that coverage had been coy about one major reason officials and academics may feel unsupported: the intervention of the British security services in matters involving China. He pointed to MI5’s “Espionage Alert” and its “blood-curdling” media coverage. Diplomats who have served in China, he said, are largely barred from returning because their lived experience and grasp of nuance are treated as failings.
Britain, Brown noted, has plenty of good sinologists. None dismisses the challenges China poses, but they resist binary narratives which assume from the outset that China is an obvious and systemic threat.
1:10
Chinese embassy in Britain slams conviction of 2 men linked to Hong Kong trade office
On artificial intelligence, climate change and much else, he pointed out, Britain is probably closer to Beijing than to Washington. What Britain needs, he concluded, is not more capacity or an army of hawkish lobby groups seeking validation rather than answers, but real knowledge.
Not everyone agreed. Lord Peter Ricketts, head of the Diplomatic Service from 2006 to 2010, wrote back and countered that Brown’s claim was hard to square with the careers of the Foreign Office’s top China specialists. Sir Peter Wilson, the ambassador to China, speaks fluent Mandarin and has served there three times, as have his predecessor, Dame Caroline Wilson, and Brian Davidson, consul general in Hong Kong. None, Ricketts wrote, can fairly be accused of failing to understand China’s complexity.
Rebecca Nadin, director of global risks and resilience at ODI Global, shifted the focus. The Financial Times was right, she wrote, to sound the alarm in its November 9 report, “UK faces China expertise crunch after exodus of senior diplomats”. Asking them to reapply for their own jobs is no way to keep them, and a £5 million (US$6.5 million) budget will not replace them, she said.

The bigger problem, in Nadin’s view, is how little their advice was used. Successive governments were well briefed on what Beijing wants and where British leverage lies, but none decided how to use it. What is missing is not documents but a strategy and the courage to set one out. The 2023 Integrated Review Refresh called China an “epoch-defining” challenge and that last year’s National Security Strategy called it a “geostrategic” one but neither said what Britain wants from China or what it will concede to get it. The China audit David Lammy commissioned as foreign secretary, completed in June 2025, has never been published in full, Nadin pointed out.
She cited China’s planned embassy at Royal Mint Court, beside the Tower of London, noting that officials had said Beijing had made a visit by Keir Starmer, then prime minister, conditional on planning approval. It was granted on January 20; he arrived in Beijing eight days later.
Ten months on, ministers have not said what, if anything, Britain gained – including for its own embassy in Beijing. When Andy Burnham sets out his China policy, Nadin argued, he should first state what national security means for the British public in dealing with Beijing and what Britain will demand in return for concessions. Without a strategy, she warned, new expertise will be wasted like the old.
Xi Jinping urges stable partnership in talks with UK leader
Nadin’s case is hard to dispute, but one detail in the Financial Times’ reporting supports Brown’s concern. In September 2024, I wrote about a UK-China Transparency report on the Lau China Institute. It stressed that 99.9 per cent of the institute’s funding came from a single Hong Kong donor, Lau Ming-wai, who had given at least £11 million, and claimed some of his advisory roles tied him to the Communist Party’s United Front.
The report omitted more relevant facts. Lau earned his law degree and PhD at King’s College and his master’s at the London School of Economics; his thesis on trusts was published by Oxford University Press. A former graduate giving generously to his alma mater is hardly sinister. The report also listed Brown’s articles in China Daily and the Beijing Review, implying a link between his views and his institute’s funding.
The Transparency group’s director, Sam Dunning, a self-styled investigative researcher, specialises in exposing China. Its current and former advisers have included Simon Cheng Man-kit, a former British consulate employee detained on the mainland in 2019 on a charge of soliciting prostitution and now wanted under Hong Kong’s national security law; David Tobin of the University of Sheffield, who argues that Beijing’s treatment of the Uygurs amounts to genocide; and Howard Zhang, a former head of the BBC Chinese Service and fierce critic of Beijing.
If such a group is now training British diplomats, Brown’s warning deserves serious attention. Britain does not lack China expertise. What it risks losing is the political will and wisdom to use it.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.