Milburn report is ‘staggeringly ambitious’ – Burnham now faces a race against time

Alan Milburn’s report into the youth unemployment crisis is “staggeringly ambitious”, but timing is now absolutely key for Burnham if he wants to avoid an MP rebellion, an ex-No 10 adviser has warned.
Mr Milburn’s report into NEETs (‘Not in Education, Employment, or Training’) says a “complete system reset” is needed to cut the proportion 16-24 year-olds who are Neet from 13 per cent to five per cent within a decade.
To do so, Mr Milburn proposes lowering National Insurance rates for young workers, changing the school curriculum to focus on work skills rather than the university route, doubling the number of apprenticeships, and overhauling mental health services so young people can access support without a diagnosis.
On the latest episode of In The Room, former special adviser Cleo Watson said that the consensus among Westminster insiders is that the report is very impressive – but incredibly aspirational.
“I spoke to an ex-Tory adviser and someone who used to work for the Department for Work and Pensions, and they were absolutely staggered by how ambitious the report is. There are problems that Milburn is tackling here that they’d longed to have a crack at when they were in government, but for whatever reason, couldn’t.”
Her co-host Helen MacNamara, former deputy cabinet secretary, finds it hard to see a world where the report isn’t implemented. Not only is Milburn’s work comprehensive and detailed – the pre-briefings, overall handling, and lack of any other announcements all tip to Downing Street approval, she said.
Another reason for her optimism is James Purnell, Mr Burnham’s current chief of staff. As secretary of state at the DWP, he was a “radical reformer”, and started Universal Credit. “It’s hard to imagine James isn’t sympathetic to Milburn,” Helen said. “That should tell you something about how much goodwill there will be behind it.”
But if Mr Burnham wants to avoid the type of MP rebellion which Sir Keir Starmer faced when he tried to reform welfare, time is of the essence, Helen said. The more time MPs go without clear leadership, the more doubt and confusion can fester. And the report also demands new definitions.
Mr Milburn proposes that under-25s should not be able to access universal credit for health reasons, except in cases of profound disability. “You can bet your bottom dollar there will be lots of parents writing in to MPs today saying: define profound. What does this mean for their child who has, in their view, profound ADHD?’” Cleo said.
“That definition is going to be really, really difficult. This former DWP staffer was saying, these are the kind of arguments they hated to get into. That’ll be the bit that Andy Burnham will find most uncomfortable.”
Listen to the full episode of In The Room on Apple Podcasts and Spotify, or watch on YouTube.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.