Fire Country Is Doomed Thanks To Its Biggest CBS Risk Yet
Antonella Gugliersi (she/them) has been a feature writer for Screen Rant since 2021. While studying for her bachelor’s in Economics & Management, they started writing about movies and TV shows for Turin-based The Unconventional Mag. After a brief internship at TPI, she decided she wanted to pursue journalism and graduated with a degree in International Journalism from Brunel University.
Fire Country’s success might be in danger, and its looming threat is deeply connected to another CBS TV series. Led by Max Thieriot in the role of Bode Leone, Fire Country had an outstanding debut in the 2022-2023 TV cycle. Its hair-raising action perfectly complemented the family drama, and the themes of redemption and being of service to the community couldn’t be separated from the firefighting drama thanks to Fire Country’s focus on the inmate firefighting program at Three Rock, which set it apart from other first-responder dramas in the most definite way possible.
Fire Country’s incredible success quickly brought forth talks of several spin-offs, including Sheriff Country, which became a reality and debuted on CBS during the 2025-2026 TV season by preceding the firefighting drama in its regular Friday scheduling. Fire Country being renewed for a fifth season makes it hard to believe that it could potentially face cancellation. Still, there are indications that it isn’t as successful as it was during its first three seasons, as evidenced by its shorter run in season 5, behind-the-scenes changes that included a new showrunner, and Fire Country season 4’s falling ratings.
What is ironic is that the threat to Fire Country is made unmissable by Sheriff Country’s massively successful first season. Indeed, despite sharing creators and setting, the Fire Country spin-off consistently outperformed its parent series’ season 4, and this is only confirmed by Sheriff Country becoming the number 3 most-watched series on Paramount+ in the world according to data from September 14, 2026. However, it’s not just Fire Country’s numbers that foretell its tricky future.
Sheriff Country Season 1's Cases & Family Drama Kept Viewer Attention & Interest High
Although not the only warning, it’s significant that Sheriff Country’s ratings surpassed Fire Country’s throughout the 2025-2026 TV cycle. Except for six episodes when the separation between the firefighting drama and the crime drama’s ratings was minimal, one million or more viewers tuned in to watch Sheriff Country compared to Fire Country, episode by episode. This was already an impressive feat, considering Fire Country’s popularity through the years, but it’s even more so because Sheriff Country is its spin-off and it was in its maiden season.
The numbers prove that Sheriff Country was able to keep the viewers glued to their screens and interested in tuning in again week after week to know how Mickey’s story proceeded, and it’s easy to understand why, thinking back to everything that happened in Sheriff Country season 1.
Even without thinking about the shock value of certain developments, of which there were many, including Skye being accused of murder, Wes robbing the sheriff’s office, Mickey’s mother being revealed as alive, and Mickey having to arrest her own father, Sheriff Country season 1 was indubitably well-crafted. All its characters went on their individual journeys throughout the season, with their choices making sense because Sheriff Country had spent time showing what drove its characters, in a way that made the resolutions to their story arcs rewarding, because very little felt out of character or unexplained.
Another feature that made Sheriff Country stand out was its cases. No matter how low or high stakes they were, they overlapped one way or another with the personal lives of Sheriff Country’s central characters. Cassidy’s search for the truth surrounding her sister’s disappearance was emblematic in that sense, as it linked a current investigation with one of her worst memories, leading to solving multiple murders, catching a serial killer in Edgewater, and finding some closure about what happened to Zoey.
Fire Country Season 4's Personal & Professional Storylines Were Wholly Disconnected
In contrast, its parent series felt consistently out of place. Fire Country season 4’s premiere explaining Vince and Gabriela’s exits didn’t make things easy for the first-responder drama, as Fire Country had to simultaneously deal with major character exits and a calamitous disaster in the small town of Edgewater. However, Fire Country struggled even after the immediate aftermath of the Zabel Ridge fire. Trying to come to terms with the tragedy led Bode to briefly become a role model for Tyler, only for their involvement to lead to yet another disagreement with Sharon and a new love interest.
Fire Country season 4 seemed keen to rehash previous storylines, and this went beyond Bode and Sharon. Eve tried to patch things up with Francine despite season 3 having already established their limits. Similarly, Jake and Violet’s relationship faced insurmountable obstacles once again. While focusing on its characters’ personal stories along with the daring rescues that their job required, Fire Country season 4 did little to enmesh the two aspects. Yet, Fire Country at its best used to let its characters’ emotional baggage influence a rescue call, and because of that, the stakes were higher.
Instead, Fire Country season 4 unexpectedly felt flat. It should be implausible after the biggest tragedy in the franchise, and yet, the stakes of each call Station 42 found itself in seemed low, in the sense that it could be expected that not only would the rescue end well, but it would also have no lasting repercussions on the firefighting drama’s protagonists. This inability to renew itself doesn’t bode well for Fire Country’s future, especially so after two major character exits gave it the chance to shake things up.
Fire Country Season 5's Shorter Run Proves It's In Danger (But It Can Also Be A Blessing)
While Sheriff Country season 2’s episode count remains largely unchanged, Fire Country season 5 will only have 13 episodes. It’s an unmistakable downgrade, even more so considering that the only other Fire Country season to have such a short run was the second, and that was due to the 2023 strikes.
However, even if Fire Country’s shorter run hints at its being in danger, not all is lost. Its recurrent problems have a chance to be tackled, after all, by Fire Country’s creative team led by a new showrunner, following the departure of Tia Napolitano at the end of season 4. While her exit was framed as a consequence of Napolitano taking the opportunity to focus on something new, thus having no explicit connection to Fire Country’s problems, it can still lead to a new perspective shaking things up for the firefighting drama.
Albeit different, Fire Country season 5’s 13-episode run can still help the show overcome the issues that plague it. Indeed, a shorter timeframe can refocus the first-responder drama on the storylines it really wants to tell. This can in turn bring Fire Country back to its former glory, one where rescues and its characters’ personal lives are so intertwined to the point of raising the stakes for both.
Enjoy ScreenRant's primetime coverage? Click below to sign up for my weekly Network TV newsletter (make sure to check "Network TV" in your preferences) and get the inside scoop from actors and showrunners on your favorite series.
-
Fire Country follows Bode Donovan, a young convict seeking redemption by joining a firefighting program in his Northern California hometown. Working alongside elite firefighters, Donovan and fellow inmates strive to control massive wildfires in the region while navigating personal challenges and community dynamics. -
Sheriff Country is a television series that follows the daily life and duties of law enforcement officials in a rural American county. The show documents the challenges and triumphs of the local sheriff's department as they tackle crime, maintain order, and serve their community.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.