BUSINESS INSIGHTS: The accidental landlord dilemma

Picture this. You buy a flat in Durban, get transferred to Joburg two years later, meet someone in the city, move in with them, decide to put the Durban flat on the market and watch two sales fall through. Someone eventually says the obvious: why don’t you just rent it out?
Congratulations. You’re now a landlord.
Not because you spent months researching rental yields or deliberately building an investment property portfolio, but because your circumstances changed and offloading in a buyer’s market no longer made the most financial sense.
And while the above relocation in a “down” market scenario is more common than most people realise, there are plenty of ways to become an “accidental landlord.” Divorce, inheritance, moving in with a partner, or simply deciding to buy another home before you’ve managed to sell the first can all leave you with a property you no longer need, or want, to live in.
In many of these cases, renting the property out can absolutely make the most financial sense. But an attitude of “I’ll just get a tenant” is neither strategic nor sustainable.
Rent doesn’t equal automatic profit
Contrary to popular belief, if someone wants to rent your property for R20,000 a month, you are not making R20,000 a month.
Rates, levies, insurance, letting and management fees, maintenance and repairs all come off that figure. You also need to budget for the property sitting empty between tenants and the inevitable expense that arrives at the least convenient time.
And then there is tax. Rental income needs to be declared to South African Revenue Services (SARS), although certain expenses incurred in earning that income may be deductible.
My point isn’t that being a landlord isn’t profitable. It has been a hugely successful wealth-building strategy for many. But that profit isn’t a given. You need to calculate the actual return after costs rather than simply looking at the advertised rental price and convincing yourself the tenant is paying your bond.
You’ve also accidentally started a small business
What this requires in practice is something many first-time landlords underestimate. Once somebody is paying to live in your property, you have responsibilities to them – responsibilities that could cost you a lot in legal fees should you fail to meet them.
First and foremost, you need a proper, lawyer-vetted lease. Deposits must be handled correctly. Incoming and outgoing inspections matter. Maintenance requests cannot simply sit unanswered because you are busy.
And if a tenant stops paying, changing the locks and putting their belongings on the pavement is a fast way to rack up those aforementioned legal fees. Even entering your own property requires reasonable notice once somebody else is renting it.
While these are necessary warnings, my intention is not to scare away would-be landlords. I’m simply trying to kill the fantasy that rental income is passive from day one.
Distance changes the calculation
As I said at the start, many accidental landlords become landlords because of relocation – a factor that adds another layer of complexity.
A burst geyser is an irritation if you live ten minutes away from your rental property. But if you’re sitting in Joburg and it happens in Durban, it becomes a much bigger problem, especially if you’ve decided to save money by not using a local property management company.
A good management partner may come with a fee, but so does trying to coordinate contractors, inspections, late payments and tenant queries from another province or country.
Would you buy this property as an investment today?
This is probably the most useful question an accidental landlord can ask themselves. Forget for a moment that you already own it – if you viewed the property today, at its current market value, with its realistic rental income and running costs, would you choose to buy it as an investment?
If the answer is no, why choose to keep it, regardless of the state of the market?
Look at how much equity is tied up in the property, what return that equity is actually producing and what else you could do with the money if you sold. On the flip side, a low-maintenance property in an area with strong rental demand and reasonable running costs may be well worth keeping.
But keeping it because selling feels like a hassle is not the same thing as deciding it is a good investment. Becoming a landlord by accident is easy. Staying one should be a deliberate decision.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.