Neagley Review: Prime Video's First Reacher Spinoff Perfects Its Winning Formula

Published Sep 15, 2026, 9:00 AM EDT

Ana Dumaraog is a Writer and Editor at Screen Rant, where she expertly covers Network TV offerings, among other things

She has spearheaded the effort to make the site an authority on broadcast shows, initially starting with The Big Bang Theory franchise, NCIS, and One Chicago before taking on the specialization in general.

Ana has also covered a wide-spread of topics in the past — from franchises like, the MCU and Star Wars, to classic TV favorites, such as Frasier and MASH.

Ana brings clarity and enthusiasm to every story she tackles—whether reporting on new releases or offering deep dives into fan-favorite franchises. Her coverage translates complex entertainment developments into engaging, audience-focused content.

The Reacher franchise is officially established, with Neagley improving on Alan Ritchson's popular series' formula. After its successful debut in 2022, Prime Video didn't waste time taking advantage of the action-adventure's popularity, bringing it back pretty much every year since. This has allowed Reacher to maintain its relevance amid a flurry of new things to watch on TV, although it's worth noting that it has also, impressively, maintained the same storytelling quality, more or less. In 2026, however, Prime Video is taking a bigger leap by kickstarting a franchise with the debut of its very first spinoff — Neagley.

Overlapping with the release of Reacher season 4 finale on September 16, 2026, is the roll-out of Neagley. Instead of doing a weekly format, Prime Video is dropping all eight episodes of the offshoot for the perfect binge-watch. The streamer sent an advance copy of Neagley season 1, and I'm pleased to share that it defies expectations by keeping the level of quality that its parent series has had throughout its run. Admittedly, there were concerns about the project when it was first announced.

While Maria Sten's Frances has been a staple of the Reacher series, which means that people already have investment in her character, building a show with her at the center and not Ritchson's Jack came with its own set of risks. In Neagley, the format also changes significantly. Since Frances is not a drifter like her former 110th Special Investigations Unit's teammate, her show is rooted deeply in Chicago, with the relationship with her father and her childhood at the center of its story. That said, there's still so much more to enjoy in Neagley beyond its titular character and her story.

Neagley Shines With Its Ensemble Cast

Prime Video maintains the action-mystery thriller that Reacher is known for with Neagley, and even improves on some of the weaker points of its parent series. Because the spinoff's story takes place in Frances' hometown, its inaugural case has personal ties to him — an effective way to give the show emotional weight, especially as it develops her story separate from what has been established for Reacher. As a PI in Chicago, and similar to Jack, she likes working on her own, and considering her success rate and approach to conflict, this makes sense. However, Prime Video surrounds her with a solid ensemble that, dare I say, is better than anything that Reacher has had in its last four seasons.

Unlike Reacher, which is purely inspired by Lee Child's famed books, co-creators Nick Santora and Nicholas Wooton have more creative freedom to craft Neagley's story, as it's an entirely fresh narrative. Aside from Frances, the rest of the show is built to serve the narrative that Prime Video wants to tell. Neagley season 1 introduces three new allies to Sten's character — Greyston Holt as Detective Hudson Riley, Jasper Jones as Keno, and Adeline Rudolph as Renee Birdwhistle. Impressively, all of them have their unique skills and appeals, so while they prove to be useful to Frances, the series also starts establishing their character, planting personal plot seeds that could anchor potential future seasons.

One thing that Neagley undoubtedly does better than Reacher, at least in season 1, is its villains. The project's inaugural case starts with a personal tragedy for Frances. From there, Santora and Wooton develop a complex web of criminal activity that weaves multiple industries — each of them with their own villainous representative that makes the investigative aspect of Neagley more engaging. While the show's antagonists are all united by their greed, their secondary motivations differ, allowing for various perspectives and proving that to pull off something criminally large-scale, multiple branches of society should be complicit. Amid all the horrifying acts in Neagley, what happens in Echo Canyon Farm's separate operations hits closer to home, simply because of how manipulative it is.

Neagley Has A Chance To Surpass Reacher

By michaella92 MovieStillsDB.com

Admittedly, Neagley's action scenes aren't as fun or brutal as Reacher's. That makes sense, considering that Sten's character can't rely on her physique the way Jack does due to his size. Aside from that, Ritchson's hero is also more fun on his own, given his snappy and sarcastic nature, while Frances is more serious and brooding. That said, these aspects work so well with Neagley's storytelling approach. While Jack has been and will be the center of Reacher, making it the perfect case for an anthology narrative, its spinoff's serialized storytelling paves the way to be more of an ensemble piece with Frances in the middle. Her quieter and harder persona is softened by her scrappy team.

Neagley 1 does a great job utilizing Jack — just enough to establish that the fresh offering exists in the same universe, but not too much that he overtakes the entire plot

By breaking off from Reacher's anthology format and taking on more serialized storytelling, Neagley will have the opportunity to tackle longer arcs beyond season 1. Not that Ritchson's Prime Video series is losing appeal, but deviating from its approach and carving its own path helps the spinoff establish an identity separate from its parent series. Neagley 1 does a great job utilizing Jack — just enough to establish that the fresh offering exists in the same universe, but not too much that he overtakes the entire plot, which is something that he can do. Prime Video efficiently explains Jack's involvement and absence throughout the events of Neagley, and is something that the burgeoning franchise can rely on moving forward as the streamer continues Jack and France's individual and collective stories.

The format switch also gives those who prefer extended narratives an option to get into the budding world. In the world where shows on streaming are getting shorter seasons and runs in general, there's something comforting about following a narrative that plays out for multiple years, allowing people to get fully invested in characters and events. Serialization opens doors for narratives that Reacher can't otherwise do, such as a proper slow-burn romance or a bigger conspiracy that plays throughout multiple seasons. If executed right, Neagley has a good chance of reaching the same popularity as the flagship, if not more.

Neagley

8/10

• 

  Greyston Holt

  Detective Hudson Riley

• 

  Maria Sten

  Frances Neagley