[Interview] Midterm rout opens door to ending Trumpism, but MAGA base is here to stay

People wait in line to cast their ballots at an early voting polling location inside the Curtis D. Menard Memorial Sports Center in Wasilla, Alaska, on Nov. 1, 2026. (AP/Yonhap)
The US midterm elections earlier this month went down as a “blue tsunami” in which Democrats took control of both the House and the Senate and even captured Senate seats in traditional Republican strongholds such as Texas, Mississippi and South Carolina. The results marked a sharp rebuke from voters to the “Make America Great Again,” or MAGA, movement, which had charged ahead largely unchecked since President Donald Trump’s return to power.
Whether the elections mark a lasting shift in American politics or a short-lived backlash is an open question. Theda Skocpol, the Victor S. Thomas Professor of Government and Sociology at Harvard University, has spent decades tracking the grassroots conservative Tea Party movement, political shifts among the Rust Belt working class and the radicalization of the Republican Party. In a piece published by Talking Points Memo on Nov. 7, she called the results “a landmark in US political history.”
Asked in a phone interview with the Hankyoreh on Friday whether the election could be the beginning of the end of Trumpism, Skocpol said, “It can be.”
“It probably creates the best possible opening for that you can imagine,” she said.
But she cautioned against premature optimism. “It takes three elections to kill off a major force that controls one of the [two] major US parties. They have to lose three times,” she said.
Trumpism may falter, but its popular base remains
To understand the Trump phenomenon, Skocpol said, one must distinguish Trumpism from MAGA as a mass movement.
“Trumpism is a synthesis of patrimonial corruption,” she said. “[Trump] has always had the tendency to want things to revolve around him and to be able to use public resources to just hand out favors and punishments, and he’s really taken that to the most obvious extremes in the second Trump administration, and I don’t think all of his popular supporters are on board with that.”
That helps explain why some Trump supporters stayed home or abandoned the Republican Party this time around, she said.
MAGA, on the other hand, “is probably the name for the most popular part of [Trumpism],” Skocpol said, and as a grassroots political movement, it will not disappear overnight.
Drawing on her earlier research on the Tea Party, Skocpol described the radicalization of the American right as the fusion of two forces: a top-down push by the wealthy — originally organized through the Koch network, the conservative political funding operation built by billionaire brothers Charles and David Koch, and now driven by a handful of multibillionaires such as Elon Musk — and a bottom-up popular nationalism fueled by economic grievances and anger over immigration and racial and generational changes in America.
“Trump was very important in knitting them together into something we could call a movement, giving them a national focus, a unity focus, and that’s what’s come apart,” she said.
But the popular anger behind the movement is “not going away,” Skocpol said. She predicted that Vice President JD Vance, Secretary of State Marco Rubio, conservative commentator Tucker Carlson and others would compete “to pick up and redefine and re-energize, particularly the popular components of Republican radicalism.”
Skocpol dismissed the idea that the Republican Party could return to its pre-Trump self.
“The one who wants to take it back to where it was before Trump is Pence, and by the way, where it was before Trump was sort of a Tea Party party already,” she said, referring to former Vice President Mike Pence. “Pence himself was a creature of the Koch network and the Christian right, and he was halfway to Trumpism even before he became Trump’s vice president.”
Explaining why it takes three defeats to sideline a dominant political force, Skocpol said, “A lot of people don’t want to get the message.”
She noted that Trump will still wield enormous influence heading into the 2028 presidential election, as virtually every state-level Republican Party has been taken over by his loyalists.
“Whoever wins the nomination in the Republican Party for the presidential election is going to have to balance satisfying Donald Trump and his core enthusiasts with moving away from them,” she said. “It’s going to be virtually impossible to do.”

Theda Skocpol, an American political scientist and Victor S. Thomas Professor of Government and Sociology at Harvard University. (courtesy Skocpol)
Beyond identity politics: Cost of living, corruption and war
Skocpol attributed the Democrats’ landslide to two factors: a message with broad appeal and a shift in how candidates campaigned.
In her Talking Points Memo piece, she described the race as a diversity election in which Democrats from the widest range of backgrounds won without putting race, gender or class at the forefront. Candidates who called themselves progressives and even socialists, as well as moderates running in conservative parts of the country, all focused on concerns voters shared: rising living costs, corruption, the Iran war and harsh immigration crackdowns.
“I think that in a way the election overcame those factional differences,” she said of the divide between the party’s progressive and centrist wings.
Skocpol also noted that Democratic candidates this time broke away from the TV ads and last-minute volunteers the party had relied on for the past 50 years, instead traveling around their districts and states to meet voters face-to-face.
In “Rust Belt Union Blues,” which she co-wrote with Lainey Newman, Skocpol identified the decline of unions and local communities as a key reason working-class voters drifted away from the Democrats. Skocpol says the new campaign style could start to make up for that loss.
“The steel industry isn’t coming back,” she said. “A lot of the labor unions and groups of the past are not going to suddenly bloom again, but the style of politics that [involves] going out and talking to voters all over your district or state, that could come back, and I think it is coming back.”
She pointed to Democratic candidates in Kansas and Texas who visited conservative rural counties and churches where they had no hope of winning. “That style of politics was there in the first Obama election in 2008 too,” she said.
Keeping in touch with local networks — informal gatherings, remaining unions, women’s groups and church groups — “could make up for some of the kinds of lost local community ties that we talked about in ‘Rust Belt Union Blues,’” she said.
“State governments control a lot of things”
Skocpol stressed that the shift in power at the state level matters even more than control of Congress.
Democrats now hold 30 of the country’s 50 governorships. In state legislative races, they flipped 12 chambers in nine states, gaining full control of the governor’s office and both legislative chambers in key swing states including Arizona, Michigan, Nevada, Pennsylvania and Wisconsin, and breaking the Republican lock on state government in GOP strongholds such as Texas and Georgia.
“I’m not certain that the Democratic Party, as a party apparatus or sort of consultants, will understand” the importance of these wins, she said. “If you look back over the last 50 years, Republicans understood that you had to have solid foundations from school boards to state legislatures and then to Congress.”
However nationalized American politics may have become, especially in the media, winning still depends on fielding candidates who are in sync with their districts and states, she said.
“The Democrats, for the first time, had somebody running everywhere this time,” she said. “Well, if you’re not running, you can’t win.”
Unlike Congress, where legislation can be blocked by a presidential veto, state governments can deliver visible results right away, such as regulatory reforms “that make more housing possible” and investment in public education, Skocpol said.
In Congress, she said, Democrats should stop pushing sprawling bills nobody understands and instead pass broadly popular measures one at a time — a stock trading ban for lawmakers, reversing Medicaid cuts and restoring Obamacare subsidies, and reining in tariffs — forcing Trump to either sign or veto them.
“People have got to understand that the Democrats are doing all they possibly can on core popular concerns,” she said.
Looking past Trump, Skocpol sees the next major fault line in US politics as one pitting ordinary Americans against corrupt ultra-wealthy and Big Tech elites.
“If you look across American history, there’s never been clear class politics in the European sense,” she said, noting that neither party is organized along class lines. “We do have periods of time where there’s a great deal of anger and concern about a small number of wealthy people who are trying to buy political power. And boy, these folks are trying to do exactly that.”
“There’s really a ready-made set of villains here,” she said, pointing to Big Tech and artificial intelligence billionaires who wield their fortunes for political influence.
Citing economist Paul Krugman’s argument that pouring so much investment into an unproven set of technologies is starving other sectors, Skocpol said that “as long as Trump is there, you’re not going to get any consistent regulation. You’ll get him making deals one at a time with these guys.”
“The Democrats have got to come up with a way of talking about regulating and spreading the wealth from those new investments and maybe survive the possibility that there could be a bubble and an economic downturn out of all of this,” she said. “That’s just uncharted waters.”
Americans said no to demonizing immigrants
Skocpol said the election reaffirmed the resilience of American democracy.
“I don’t think American democracy, in the sense of the potential that American citizens could say enough is enough, ever went away,” she said. “Americans are ornery people. They’re capable of organizing themselves, and ultimately, they don’t like to be lied to and pushed around.”
The most meaningful change, she said, was voters’ rejection of politics hostile to immigrants and minorities. “The one thing that I think permanently happened here is that Americans say no, we’re not going to go the route of demonizing people just because they come from an immigrant background, and that’s a reassertion of what makes America great,” she said, adding that she was expressing a personal view.
She cited the victory of Abdul El-Sayed in Michigan, who will become the first Muslim elected to the US Senate. Voters refused to go along with the attacks on his religious identity, she said.
“The campaign against him was, pure and simple, saying that Muslim Americans can’t be real Americans, and people aren’t buying that,” Skocpol said.
But democratic resilience does not automatically translate into political stability, she warned, given voters’ deep frustration with the system and their volatility.
“The American electorate has got a lot of people, particularly younger people and white working-class people, but to some degree also Latinos and Blacks, who are just dissatisfied. They think the system isn’t working for them,” she said. “They can easily take elections as a chance to throw the bums out or send them a message.”
As recently as the 1990s, a solid core of incumbents could count on reelection no matter what, she noted. “What was interesting about this election is how many incumbents lost.”
She also pointed to the country’s low turnout compared to other democracies, as well as the role of young people who turned out in unusually large numbers this time.
“Given that there’s the possibility of people turning around and showing frustration in the other direction if things don’t change quickly enough, we just can’t be certain that a kind of polarized instability isn’t going to set in or deepen,” she said.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.