A Talent for Murder review: Helen Mirren plays Patricia Highsmith with cantankerous aplomb

A fictionalised version of American author Patricia Highsmith, played with cantankerous aplomb by Helen Mirren, is at the centre of this compelling drama that's a love letter to literature and how storytelling can infuse our lives.
What better character to explore the fluidity of identity than Highsmith's most famous creation, Tom Ripley? Alden Ehrenreich (Weapons) plays publishing worker and Highsmith super-fan Edward Ridgeway who travels to her home in Switzerland to convince the reclusive and misanthropic writer to pen one final Ripley novel.
We first meet Highsmith fixing Edward with a contemptuous black-eyed stare, she has no desire to serve the publishing house and doesn't trust Edward but allows him to stay for the night after he brings her a Parisian dagger to add to her weapons wall, and eats food she teases is laced with arsenic from her poison pantry.
Mirren's Highsmith is a creature of chaos, but she agrees to work with Edward in return for his commitment to help her devise an elaborate story of murder and deception. Edward imagines himself the lead, playing out a romantic fantasy with a young woman he met on the train (Slow Horses' Olivia Cooke). There's something of the Miss Havisham about the author – is she corrupting the young man, or is tapping into his inner Ripley to be the making of him?
Want to see this content?
This page contains content provided by Google reCAPTCHA. We ask for your permission before anything is loaded, as Google reCAPTCHA may use cookies and other technologies. To view this content, choose 'Accept and continue' to allow Google reCAPTCHA and its required purposes.
The story-within-the-story is steeped in sex and violence against gorgeous European backdrops of Zurich and Rome. The reality is a little more gentle, virtually a two hander which sees Highsmith at the end of her life (the film is set in 1995, Highsmith died in February of that year), bitter, manipulative and difficult to be around, finding if not comfort, then at least sport from spending time with her Ripley proxy.
Based on the play Switzerland by Joanna Murray-Smith who has adapted her work for the screen here, it's necessarily talkie and somewhat theatrical, though in the hands of Control director Anton Corbijn, with the charm of Ehrenreich and the intensity of Mirren, it's a seductive, if slow, watch.
Mirren says she took the role in part because the script was a real page-turner, and you can see what she means. Highsmith's amoral genius, who doesn't believe in evil and occupies the metaphorical space (as well as the literal one) of Switzerland is a meaty role to get your teeth into.
Cooke is good too but since the 'real life' Clementine (as opposed to her avatar within Highsmith and Ridgeway's tale) isn’t actually in it a great deal, she doesn’t have much space to develop.
There's a lot to like here, leaving viewers with plenty to talk about afterwards. If anything though, A Talent For Murder suffers slightly from not actually being a Ripley film. It is a slightly unfair criticism, perhaps, but there is simply no peril here. It lacks the tension of Matt Damon's rather tragic turn as the cornered young Tom in Anthony Minghella’s sun-soaked Talented Mr. Ripley, as well as Andrew Scott's dark and stormy performance in Netflix's eponymous series.
The mystery at the centre (not real) is generic for Highsmith, who broke out with her clever, twisty novel Strangers on a Train, and while we root for Edward, there's no danger of him almost getting caught. Edward is from a poor background and says he is an orphan but Jay Gatsby he is not. Instead this is a very human film about a young man learning to take risks and better enjoy his life in the shadow of someone who increasingly ceased to enjoy hers.
A Talent for Murder is released in UK cinemas on Friday 20 November 2026.
Check out more of our Film coverage or visit our TV Guide and Streaming Guide to find out what's on. For more TV recommendations and reviews, listen to The Radio Times Podcast.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.