From pyjama parades to blind biscuit taste tests: how we made our ultimate festive gift guide

If you struggle with the idea of Christmas creep – when the festive season appears to start earlier every year – spare a thought for the team here at Filter HQ. We’ve been in Christmas mode since we packed away last year’s decorations, testing hundreds of presents for our magnum opus: the big 2026 Christmas gift guide.
All 369 (we did say it was big) gifts on this year’s list were put through their paces by a crack team of testers covering all ages and tastes. Fashion writer and stylist Sam Deaman – who tested men’s accessories and nightwear – says his partner got fed up with him parading “yet another” pair of pyjamas around their bedroom each night: “It was like Stars in Their Eyes for Christmas gifts,” he says. “‘Tonight, Matthew, I’m going to be … Ebenezer Scrooge!’”

Office biscuit consumption increased when Filter researcher Lily Smith set up a blind taste test in the Guardian kitchen. “Fortnum & Mason’s spiced Christmas Merrilossus biscuits were the favourite overall, with Island Bakery’s lemon melts a close second – we’ve included both in the guide as they have different flavour profiles,” she says.
Guardian columnist and chocolate expert Annalisa Barbieri, who took one for the team by testing chocolates, noticed Christmas-themed boxes were often the most disappointing. “They are frequently style over substance – they look great but tend to taste crap,” she says.
Other gifts we tested that didn’t make the cut included a “detox” bath salt that made the water look like brown soup, a camping light that lost power after just a few hours, and a pretty yoga kit with badly designed balance blocks. After testing, all gifts that couldn’t be returned (and hadn’t been eaten) were donated to charity.
Present and correct

For the teens and tweens sections, writer Rhiannon Evans went straight to the source to ask kids in these age groups about gifts they’ve loved. “So many chose books – there are some amazing YA series out there now,” she says. “I also underestimated how many kids, mainly tweens, still really like Lego. It was a bit of a reminder that while they’re probably begging for the latest £95 hoodie, that won’t be the present they end up truly loving.”
For those who see loafing around on Christmas Day as a waste of a Strava PB, writer and lifelong runner Laura Potter’s pick of outdoorsy gifts includes running socks that didn’t budge after miles of pounding pavements and a water bottle that can be opened one-handed on long cycle rides. “The best thing to do if you’re buying for someone who loves to be outdoors is to look for a relevant treat: indulgent bath products for after a muddy hike, clothing or accessories that feel extra comfortable in all weathers, an ‘experience’ that fits with their activity of choice, or, if all else fails, a voucher for their favourite outdoorsy brand,” she says.
You’ll find some big-ticket items in the gift guide, but most are under £100. As Guardian fashion editor and gift guide contributor Jess Cartner-Morley puts it: “Those lists where ‘stocking fillers’ start at £100 drive me bananas. Who are these people? One full stocking would bankrupt you.” Speaking of stocking fillers, our resolutely tat-free selection includes some jumbo hair clips chosen by beauty columnist Sali Hughes, an espresso martini cracker and a very handy pair of Niwaki fridge magnet scissors. Because sometimes “small and useful” can trump big or gimmicky: “Gifts can be all shapes and sizes. They don’t have to be showy,” adds Jess. “A nice thing that will happily live in a drawer feels thoughtful: hence, socks.” Happy shopping.

Christmas shopping can be tough, but the Filter is here to help. We’ve been testing Christmas presents all year to help you find thoughtful, creative and genuinely brilliant gifts for everyone on your list. Browse our other gift guides for hundreds more tried-and-tested ideas, from the best gifts for mums and dads to teens and tweens.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.