[Interview] Huang’s resignation could slow AI progress in both US and China, former Commerce official says
Jensen Huang’s resignation as CEO of Nvidia amid scandal could end up slowing the development of artificial intelligence in both the US and China, according to a US expert. With Huang’s departure in disgrace fueling calls in Washington for tighter chip export controls on China, the former official said the MATCH Act, a bill that targets China’s ability to make its own advanced chips, could become a major variable in US-China relations.
“I think one of the things that people might not immediately pick up on is that this is going to result in probably some kind of mutual slowdown for the US and for China when you think in the slightly longer medium to long term,” Michael Deng, a geoeconomics technology analyst at Bloomberg Economics, told the Hankyoreh in a video interview on Thursday, shortly after Huang stepped down.
Deng previously worked as a policy adviser at the Commerce Department’s CHIPS Program Office under the Biden administration. He was also detailed to the department’s Bureau of Industry and Security (BIS), where he handled export controls.
Huang resigned on Thursday following reports of a relationship with Alice Huang, a former executive at Singapore-based cloud computing company Megaspeed whom US authorities suspect of being a Chinese spy. Megaspeed is suspected of funneling Nvidia chips into China.
US loses its master coordinator, China its champion in Washington
Deng said the biggest blow to the US would be the void Huang leaves behind.
“[Huang] has been central to Nvidia, and in particular in making sure that Nvidia continues to push the frontier and ensure that the US has this giant compute and hardware lead,” Deng said. “He’s been so effective at coordinating every aspect of his business across the chips, to the supply chain, to the development aspect.”
“It’s likely that in the short term, Nvidia might be OK. But in the long term, you could see a scenario in which there are serious questions, [such as] can Nvidia continue to execute at the same pace?” he added.
For China, Deng said, the damage would come from shifts in US policy. Huang had pushed hard for more chip exports to China, arguing that continuing to sell China advanced American chips would keep it dependent on US technology.
“With the loss of him, right at this critical moment when there’s so many policies being discussed in Congress and even in [the] Commerce [Department], you could easily see that impacting Chinese progress,” Deng said. Huang’s exit has already strengthened bipartisan calls in Congress to further restrict China’s access to advanced chips.
Deng named the MATCH Act as the measure Beijing would take most seriously. Republican Rep. Michael Baumgartner of Washington introduced the Multilateral Alignment of Technology Controls on Hardware (MATCH) Act in April. The bill would limit China’s ability to produce advanced chips on its own by controlling the supply and maintenance of chipmaking equipment. So far, it has cleared only the House Foreign Affairs Committee.
The act’s centerpiece is a requirement that major equipment-producing countries such as the Netherlands and Japan bring their export controls up to US levels. It would also restrict exports and servicing of key tools China cannot easily make itself, such as deep ultraviolet (DUV) immersion lithography machines. Equipment supply, maintenance and technical support for China’s major chip fabs would face tighter rules as well.
Congress is also advancing two other bills. The AI Overwatch Act would keep restrictions on exports of the most advanced AI chips to China in place and expand congressional oversight. The Chip Security Act would use technical measures such as location verification to stop chips from being smuggled out.
Deng said China has four ways to get AI computing power: legal chip imports, smuggling, domestic production, and remote access through overseas data centers. The export control measures under discussion target all four, he said, but the MATCH Act’s limits on domestic production could hurt China the most.
Blacklisting Megaspeed directly “may be a more measured step,” Deng said. Such a move “doesn’t really harm China’s advantage much at all” and could be seen as “a symbolic one.”
“The other three are short-term pain, but the MATCH Act, which limits their own production capability and their ability to become independent, is, I think, something they would take even more seriously,” he said.
Fragile US-China truce over tech and rare earths leaves Korean chipmakers facing an either-or choice
Deng warned that if stringent bills like the MATCH Act make it through Congress, they could upset the shaky “strategic equilibrium” Washington and Beijing have kept up over the past year. The two sides have held to a trade truce based on an unspoken understanding.
“The US has tech leverage that it will not use. China has rare earth leverage that it will not use,” Deng said.
“China is not going to care if it’s President Trump or Congress that’s implementing the policy. All they’re going to see is that the US side is now implementing tech controls again, and they may feel the need to retaliate,” he said.
The US-China truce ends in January, the same month Democrats, fresh off their midterm win, start exercising their power in the new Congress. From that point, Deng said, keeping the relationship stable “is going to get progressively harder.”
Deng also pointed to efforts in Congress to keep the MATCH Act and other export control bills in the final version of the National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA). The bills are currently included in amendments to the Senate’s version. The NDAA authorizes US defense policy and spending levels, and the president cannot veto individual provisions in it. The president “would have to veto this entire must-pass legislation,” Deng said. Because lawmakers are putting the export control bills in the defense bill, he added, “it’ll be harder for him to veto.”
The scandal has also raised questions about who in the Trump administration is responsible for how chip export controls have been enforced. Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick is expected to become a main target of congressional investigations. Other agencies had pushed to sanction Megaspeed, while Lutnick reportedly held back.
In a TV interview on Friday, Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent said the Treasury, State and Defense departments and the Office of the US Trade Representative had backed adding Megaspeed to the export blacklist for months, but that “Commerce has the pen.”
“[Lutnick] seems to be right now one of the only remaining advocates for Nvidia’s view on chip exports, [. . .] and so at the very least, that’s now out of step with basically much of the rest of the government,” Deng said. “Once Democrats start investigating, Secretary Lutnick is absolutely going to be one of the primary targets because it’s just so easy to see his action as being out of sync with the rest of the administration.”
Deng also noted that BIS, the agency that actually enforces export controls, has been unusually quiet. It has not added any companies to its blacklist in more than a year. “We’re in this really intensive period of US-China tech competition, but [. . .] one of the agencies most responsible for implementing policy regarding that [. . .] has largely been inactive,” he said.
Pointing to reports that “many, many personnel have left BIS,” Deng said there is “definitely an issue with technical and policy expertise,” which may have weakened the agency’s capacity to enforce the rules.
Political considerations matter even more, he said. Now that Washington has opened the door to negotiating over its export controls, Deng said, there are “serious political considerations about if BIS does something, how will China retaliate in a way that they didn’t have to even two, three years ago.”
Axios reported, based on a review of the Federal Register, that the Commerce Department has not added a single company to its Entity List in more than a year.
Deng said the Nvidia scandal is also bringing together Democratic lawmakers who have disagreed over export controls on China. The scandal involves allegations of corruption, which was a central issue in the midterms. As a result, Democrats who are divided on China policy are uniting around fighting corruption.
“The Democrats, for example, actually are not unified on China; they’re not all fully anti-China or hawkish. There are some Democrats, for example, that are more dovish or they want to do away with the House China Committee entirely,” Deng said. “But what this does is it unifies the Democrats because you have a big corruption issue that unifies this with the big China hawk people.”
As US export controls tighten again, Deng expects South Korean chipmakers such as Samsung Electronics and SK Hynix to face an even harder dilemma.
“[Korean firms are] major investors and suppliers to the US AI ecosystem, but [they] still have significant production presence and fabs in China, which [they] also have to get export control licenses from the US to continue operating,” Deng said. “It’s a quite tricky position to be in.”
In August last year, the US Commerce Department revoked the validated end-user status it had given Samsung Electronics’ and SK Hynix’s plants in China. Since the start of this year, both companies have needed separate permits to bring US export-controlled chipmaking equipment into those plants. Washington granted annual licenses for the equipment the companies needed this year. But if the rules get tighter, maintaining the Chinese plants and replacing their equipment could become more difficult.
“They would like to keep China as a market as much as possible, but when you start making decisions between the US or China, there’s going to be situations where you will have to choose,” Deng said. “Obviously, the US AI ecosystem and supply chain is much more important to Korea right now than China is.”
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.