The Jerusalem PostTrump, Xi, Putin meet at APEC in summit that could reshape global balance of power - analysisDaily MaverickBig Oil is weaponising the law, and it’s critical that Africa fights backInquirerIligan students stage walkout vs. Pax Silica, Trump visitZDF heuteEntdecken Sie das ZDF-NachrichtenstudioGlobal NewsAnne Hathaway welcomes 3rd baby with husband Adam Shulman: reportsRFI 中文COP31: 公正转型应该是什么?Il Fatto QuotidianoAl voto emendamento di FdI per i libri scolastici in digitale scontati del 50%. Editori sulle barricate, famiglie dubbiose e le opposizioni sono contrarie7sur7“Gendarmerie 2.0”: Francken et Quintin “pratiquement d’accord” sur le principeالشرقكشف أثري جديد يضم مئات التوابيت وألسنة ذهبية في مصرPremium TimesCoroner’s inquest into Adichie’s son’s death resumes, family, hospitals agree on case scheduleCBS NewsIran ramps up attacks on Gulf countries after U.S. strikesColliderNetflix’s 'The Gilded Age' Replacement Officially Ends on Top
The Daily Newsstand · Free, Always
Wednesday, November 18, 2026

How fallen giants and their fans bounce back from scandal -- and relegation

Translate
  • Tom HamiltonNov 18, 2026, 08:00 AM ET

    Close

      • Joined ESPN in 2011
      • Covered two Olympics, a pair of Rugby World Cups and two British & Irish Lions tours
      • Previously rugby editor, and became senior writer in 2018

What does it feel like to realize the club you love is stuck in a doom spiral of its own making?

Whether due to cheating, financial mismanagement or general ineptitude, some of Europe's greatest teams have suffered the ignominy of relegation by means of punishment -- and their supporters have watched it unfold. From Juventus and Fiorentina in Italy to Rangers in Scotland, fans have seen offices stripped bare and managers and players scrambling for places on the first boats off the sinking ship.

But a footballing crisis offers the chance for heroes to drag their team out of the deep while suits swap seats in the board rooms. And amid schadenfreude, anger and denial, supporters of flawed giants find united through their morbid, self-deprecating humor and fortitude in their situation.

As Manchester City's fans await the results of their appeal and the level of punishment for their 114 breaches of the Premier League's financial rules, they might find some small comfort in seeing how others have bounced back from the depths of despair ... or renewed dread at the tribulations that could lie ahead.

Fleeing for greener pastures

By the time manager Fabio Capello had sprinted to Real Madrid in 2006, taking stars Emerson and Fabio Cannavaro with him, Juventus' offices had already been ransacked.

The "Calciopoli" scandal started as a doping investigation into Juventus, but instead found evidence of attempted match-fixing by executives who manipulated referees and their bosses -- a scandal that also implicated Fiorentina, AC Milan, Reggina and Lazio. Papers, contracts and hard drives were seized by the Guardia di Finanza (Financial Police) on May 18, 2006.

The original swath of punishments was handed out just six days after Italy won the 2006 World Cup. Juventus were hammered the hardest; they were kicked down to Serie B and stripped of their 2005 and 2006 league titles, triggering a flurry of expedited exit strategies.

"This world had been turned upside down," Ibrahimovic wrote in his 2011 autobiography. "It wasn't possible to take it all in. We'd won two titles in a row -- were we going to lose everything? One after one the players got away ... every one of us who were left called our agents: 'Sell us, sell us.'

"Uncertainty and desperation hung in the air ... No way was I going to sacrifice a year in the second division. My best years were in danger of being wasted; I told [agent Mino Raiola], 'Do whatever it takes, just get me out of here.'"

Ibrahimovic watched teammates Lilian Thuram and Gianluca Zambrotta join Barcelona, while Patrick Vieira headed to Internazionale. Didier Deschamps took charge, though he couldn't persuade Ibrahimovic to stay. Ibrahimovic said he'd train but wouldn't play in matches, leading to the striker refusing to get on the bus for a preseason game -- instead, he hid in his room and played video games, eventually joining Vieira at Inter.

"In the years following the scandal, any player who had left Juventus and came back to play would get booed. The fans felt betrayed," Lorenzo Bettoni, Football Italia editor, told ESPN. "Even today, if they come back to the Allianz Stadium, they'll still get booed."

Gianluigi Buffon, Alessandro del Piero, Pavel Nedved and David Trézéguet remained and guided Juventus through Serie B. "We chose to stay together to honour a shirt, a club, a fanbase," Buffon wrote in a column for La Stampa in 2017. "We lost everything to gain things which aren't measurable and can't be bartered: respect, affection."

AC Milan's players feared relegation, too. "The whole thing was an absolute shambles," Andrea Pirlo wrote in "I Think Therefore I Play." "One thing I was sure of, though: I would never drop down to Serie B. And if I had to leave, I wouldn't feel like a traitor. You always want to be ambitious and play for a noble cause. There was no way I was going to pay for other people's sins, if that's what they turned out to be." Ultimately, Milan received a hefty points deduction but remained in Serie A.

Choosing to stay

While some players seek the nearest exit option, others choose to stay. Their club's careworn fans hold them close as symbols of hope and rare loyalty.

When Fiorentina were declared bankrupt due to unpaid debts and wages and dissolved in summer 2002, the club restarted in the fourth tier as a brand-new entity. Italy international Angelo Di Livio, then 36, refused to flee and joined the phoenix club Associazione Calcio Fiorentina e Florentia Viola. On June 18, 2002, Di Livio was a second-half substitute as Italy were knocked out of the World Cup by South Korea. Three months later, he started for the reformed Fiorentina team as they drew 1-1 at Sangiovannese in the fourth tier of Italian football.

"My other teammates left, but I stayed in [Florence] for a few days to reflect with my family," Di Livio said in an interview with La Nazione. "Then I called [sporting director] Giovanni Galli and said, 'If you want, count on me. I'm staying.'

"I owed it to the Viola fans. In this city there has always been a true, authentic passion. And there was a great desire for rebirth." His 2003 memoir -- part of a great swath of Fiorentina-related literature -- was called "Io resto qui" ("I'm staying here").

"It was a horrible time for Fiorentina fans," Lorenzo Lepore, Fiorentina fan and owner of SV Media, told ESPN. "The club is part of daily life in Florence. It was very hard for Fiorentina fans to accept -- the club hadn't cheated, instead it was the owners who let us down." For Fiorentina, gone were the trips to AC Milan and Inter Milan as they rebuilt, instead they planned for car rides to Aglianese and Poggibonsi.

The scene that greeted players and management on their first days back in as Fiorentia Viola was grim. "I arrived on August 13, but there was nothing," then-manager Pietro Vierchowod said in a 2017 interview. "With sporting director Giovanni Galli, I went to a shop to get balls and shirts, and at the first training sessions I only had five Primavera players. I was the one who recommended [Cristian] Riganò. In the meantime, five or six players arrived at a time, almost all of them not suited to our needs. Once they showed me a videotape of a German who was supposed to come on trial: on the pitch I discovered that it wasn't the one I had seen."

Meanwhile, those who hugged both the glory days and doldrums eras maintained on-field standards. "I told them, 'Guys, we're not here to do a trip, we have to win," Di Livio said. "And I too had to adapt to playing on certain fields."

Rangers players who were there at their lowest ebb know full well the challenges posed by uneven grounds and new surroundings. In February 2012, the Scottish giants were placed into administration over a £9 million unpaid tax bill, and once the full scale of their debts was exposed, the club was voted out of the Scottish Professional Football League. It was taken in by the Scottish Football League and placed in the fourth tier. Some players, such as Steven Naismith and Steven Whittaker, opted not to transfer their contracts to the new holding company responsible for the club and left on free transfers. A few players stayed.

"I'll never forget those first few mornings going to training and seeing the boys disappear one by one," Lee McCulloch said in 2013. "It was heartbreaking -- the strangest experience I've known in my five years at the club.

"I was in contact with most of the boys as we were bouncing things off each other. I know most of them didn't want to leave, but for various reasons they had to move on. I would have preferred the lads to have stayed with Rangers and made the same decision as myself. But I respected and understood where they were coming from. All they were guilty of was looking out for their families and their careers."

On July 29, 2012, Rangers played their first game back in the Ramsdens Cup -- the equivalent of the English Football League Trophy -- at Brechin. After 36 minutes, the match was paused while supporters shook the match ball down from being stuck on a hedge. The club's fans sang "F--- you Celtic, you'll never win this cup." Meanwhile, back in Glasgow, Celtic had their feet up after playing Inter Milan in a preseason friendly the day before.

'We play to feel a sense of belonging'

From the wreck of broken institutions, phoenix clubs can rise (like Panteras Negras FC -- made up of Boavista supporters in Portugal) or teams can regroup and claw their way back up the tree. But the path back to the top is not always straightforward, even for famous institutions.

Rangers won promotion at the end of that season and by 2016-17, they were back in the top flight. But the club has never quite been the same since.

"In the fourth division, it was mad seeing them play in front of 50,000 or so at Ibrox, setting new attendance records," Andy Newport, sportswriter for the Daily Record, told ESPN. "When they got back into the Premiership, there should have been a realization that they had to take things carefully, rather than try and hit a home run off the first ball. They won the league in 2021, but even then [manager] Steven Gerrard was saying postmatch we need to fix the roof while the sun is shining. Every time something goes wrong, there's another reset, another knee-jerk reaction.

"... Since 2012, there's been poor decision-making every turn of the way, slowing down their progress. But under the current American ownership and Derek McInnes, the fans now have proper hope they've figured it out."

French giants Marseille were relegated in 1994 for match-fixing, a year after winning the European Cup. Tony Cascarino, the former Republic of Ireland striker, signed for Marseille after their relegation, charged with getting them back to the French top flight. He remembered walking into the club offices to sign his contract and passing Rudi Voller heading the other way. Voller was leaving the club to sign for Bayer Leverkusen, unwilling to play in Ligue 2. "I feel Marseille have still not recovered from their demotion, and it happened 32 years ago," Cascarino wrote in his column for The Times.

"Before winning the European Cup in 1993, Marseille had won four league titles in a row and had great players such as Chris Waddle, Marcel Desailly and Enzo Francescoli; since then they have won only one, and achieved nothing of note in the Champions League. For them to have won only one French championship this century tells you how damaging that forced relegation in 1993 was."

But out of adversity, heroes emerge. "That season I rediscovered the genuine values ​​of local football," Di Livio said of life in Italy's fourth tier. It was a self-affirming experience for him, as he felt respect from opposition players and managers, while they were fully aware opponents treated matches against his side like they were facing Real Madrid. By 2004, just two years after its dissolution, Di Livio's club had successfully changed its name back to ACF Fiorentina and was back in Serie A.

"What he did was exceptional, like nothing else. The memory of our time relegated will always be there," Lepore says. "We lost players like Adriano, Nuno Gomez and others, and we needed our heroes: like Di Livio and Christian Riganò who scored 30 goals for us that season. He's loved, too."

Even those mired in controversy and disgrace can have their moment of sporting exorcism. When Juventus won the 2012 Serie A title, they partied on the pitch wearing T-shirts with the number 30 written on it -- a tally of trophies including the 2005 and 2006 titles that had been taken away and reallocated. They bathed in their status as chief antagonists.

"The whole Calciopoli thing lent a hand to the Juventus team of that time," Pirlo said. "But to my dying day I'll remain convinced they would have won the same number of trophies relying on their own means, without any kind of external assistance. And that's why I wore a T-shirt with the slogan '30 [titles] won on the pitch' after we clinched the league in Trieste. I came from a world that went to war with Juventus over what happened but, for me, a title that's taken away and then not assigned or handed to another team remains an honor you've won."

Through it all, supporters value loyalty above all else. They remember the badge-kissing and herald those who stay true to the partnership they committed to -- or hold to account those who seek a new admirer. "In football, you can send a message to the outside with loyalty," Buffon told L'Equipe in 2018. "To say to the fans: 'In difficult moments, I'll be there.'

"We play for fame, money, trophies and a lot of things, but we also play to feel a sense of belonging."

View the original on ESPN →

KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.