HBO’s Most Controversial Ending Is Still Better Than ‘Game of Thrones’

Shawn Van Horn is a Senior Author for Collider. He's watched way too many slasher movies over the decades, which makes him an aficionado on all things Halloween and Friday the 13th. Don't ask him to choose between Michael Myers and Jason Voorhees because he can't do it. He grew up in the 90s, when Seinfeld, Everybody Loves Raymond, and TGIF were his life, and still watches them religiously to this day. Larry David is his spirit animal. His love for entertainment spreads to the written word as well. He has written two novels and is neck deep in the querying trenches. He is also a short story maker upper and poet with a dozen publishing credits to his name. He lives in small town Ohio, where he likes to watch professional wrestling and movies.
Sign in to your Collider account
Creating a classic TV series that stays at the top in quality season after season is a challenge. What seems to be even more difficult to pull off is the series finale. How does something so good, which means so much to its audience, craft a goodbye that fans enjoy? Sometimes a show is able to pull it off. Breaking Bad and Six Feet Under are two examples of last episode perfection. Then there are the ones that drop the ball. Seinfeld and Dexter continue to be mocked decades after their last episodes.
What they went through is nothing compared to the grief that Game of Thrones and The Sopranos received. These HBO series were the peak of television and pop culture during their run, only to crash in the final episode. Game of Thrones deserves the criticism, but it's a different story for The Sopranos. It's actually one of the best finales in TV history.
'Game of Thrones' Disrespected Its Audience by Trying To Do Too Much
For eight seasons, Game of Thrones was the epitome of the water cooler show. Week after week, it had everyone talking on social media or at work the next day about the latest shocking twist. If you're a fan, there's a chance you remember where you were when the Red Wedding happened, or when Jon Snow (Kit Harington) came back from the dead. As long as it lasted, Game of Thrones had an end goal. This wasn't Lost, which seemed to just keep going with no true plan. For Game of Thrones, it all came down to who would be sitting on the Iron Throne when all was said and done.
COLLIDERInteractive
War Council
Westeros/Quizzes/Your House
Collider QuizWhich Game of Thrones
House Are You?8 Questions · 5 Great HousesFive great houses. Five completely different answers to the same question: how do you hold power in a world that will take it from you the moment you stop paying attention? Eight questions will determine where your loyalties, and your nature, truly lie.The Five Houses
Stark
Lannister
Targaryen
Baratheon
Tyrell
Council 01 / 080% Sworn
Question 01HONOR
01Someone powerful is acting dishonorably and everyone knows it. What do you do?In Westeros, the answer to this question has ended more than one great house.
Pick one, then Next
Council 02 / 0812% Sworn
Question 02STRENGTH
02What is the source of your power?Every house endures because of something. What is it for yours?
Pick one, then Next
Council 03 / 0825% Sworn
Question 03LOYALTY
03Who do you truly fight for?Strip away the banners and the words. The honest answer tells you everything.
Pick one, then Next
Council 04 / 0838% Sworn
Question 04RIVALS
04How do you deal with your rivals?A house's method reveals its character as clearly as its words ever could.
Pick one, then Next
Council 05 / 0850% Sworn
Question 05RULE
05What kind of ruler do you believe in?Westeros is full of answers to this question. Most of them end badly.
Pick one, then Next
Council 06 / 0862% Sworn
Question 06LOSS
06You suffer a devastating loss. How does your house respond?How a house handles defeat tells you more about it than how it handles victory.
Pick one, then Next
Council 07 / 0875% Sworn
Question 07WORDS
07Which of these truths about Westeros do you most believe?Every house has a philosophy. This is yours.
Pick one, then Next
Council 08 / 0888% Sworn
Question 08THE THRONE
08The Iron Throne is within reach. What do you do?The answer reveals not just your ambition but your character.
Pick one, then Next
The Maester Has SpokenYour House Is
Your answers point to the great house whose words, values, and way of surviving in Westeros match your own. Bend the knee, or don't. That's very much up to you.
The NorthHouse Stark“Winter Is Coming”Seat of WinterfellYou took the long view before anyone asked you to.
Winter Is Coming, and you have always known it. You prepare not out of fear but out of duty, because the people who depend on you deserve someone who takes the long view.Why You Belong Here
- You lead with honor even when it costs you, because you understand that a reputation built on integrity is the only one worth having.
- Your loyalty to family and people runs deep, not as sentiment but as a code that doesn't bend when things get difficult.
- The North endures because Starks endure, not by being the cleverest players in the game, but by being the kind of people others are willing to follow into the cold.
- You are that kind of person. The pack survives. The lone wolf does not. You already know which one you are.
The Long ViewThe PackWinterfell
The WesterlandsHouse Lannister“Hear Me Roar”Seat of Casterly RockYou read the room before you walk into it.
You understand the game: its rules, its exceptions, and exactly when the rules become the exception. You play it without illusions and without apology.Why You Belong Here
- You are sharper than most people realize, and you have learned to use that gap to your advantage.
- A Lannister always pays their debts, and you always keep your word, because your word is an instrument of power, and instruments must be kept in working order.
- You love your family with a ferocity that sometimes blinds you, and you know it, and you do it anyway.
- The lion doesn't concern itself with the opinion of sheep. Neither, in the end, do you.
Plays The GamePays DebtsCasterly Rock
The Iron ThroneHouse Targaryen“Fire and Blood”Seat of DragonstoneYou were never going to settle for the world as handed to you.
You carry a sense of destiny that is difficult to explain and impossible to ignore, the feeling that you are not simply participating in the world but meant to reshape it.Why You Belong Here
- You are capable of extraordinary things, and you know it, and that knowledge is both your greatest strength and your most dangerous quality.
- The Targaryen words are not just words to you. They are a philosophy about what change requires and what it costs.
- The Targaryens at their best were transformative rulers who broke chains and defied the limits of what anyone thought possible.
- At your best, so are you. The dragon has three heads. You are one of them.
DestinyTransformativeDragonstone
The StormlandsHouse Baratheon“Ours Is the Fury”Seat of Storm's EndYou arrive in a room and the room knows it.
You are a force: direct, powerful, and difficult to ignore when you enter a room or a disagreement. You do not negotiate with challenges. You meet them.Why You Belong Here
- Ours is the fury, and yours is a kind of intensity that commands attention, respect, and occasionally caution from those who underestimate what's behind it.
- You value strength and straight dealing. You'd rather know where you stand than navigate a web of courtly whispers.
- The Baratheons built their house on the back of one of the greatest military victories in Westerosi history, and then struggled with what came after.
- The lesson of your house is that winning is not the end of the story. Governing is. You are learning that too.
DirectStraight DealingStorm's End
The ReachHouse Tyrell“Growing Strong”Seat of HighgardenPower arrives with flowers and good wine.
You understand that power does not always announce itself, that sometimes it arrives with flowers, good wine, and a smile that doesn't quite reach the eyes.Why You Belong Here
- Growing Strong is your house's motto, and you live it: patiently, strategically, always investing in the relationships and resources that will matter most when it counts.
- You are charming by choice and calculating by nature, a combination that makes you one of the most effective players in any room you enter.
- The Tyrells fed King's Landing and shaped its politics without ever sitting on the Iron Throne, and they were arguably more powerful for it.
- You know that the person who controls the food controls the kingdom. And you always know where the food is.
PatientCharmingHighgarden
Where Your Loyalty Lies
1· · ·0%
2· · ·0%
3· · ·0%
Copied
A Collider InteractiveCOLLIDERMore quizzes at collider.com
The series finale of Game of Thrones failed spectacularly. It was starting to fall apart before this, with a rushed season turning Daenerys Targaryen (Emilia Clark) bad out of nowhere in a move that didn't feel earned. Her death in the last episode was cheapened by the writing, which had betrayed her. Then came the moment everyone was waiting for. At the very end, it was Bran Stark (Isaac Hempstead Wright) who ended up sitting on the Iron Throne. Fans saw it as a huge letdown, a move done to be unpredictable rather than making any sense.
Even outside of those two big plot points, Game of Thrones tore down its characters. There was the undoing of Jaime Lannister’s (Nikolaj Coster-Waldau) path to redemption by letting him die with Cersei Lannister (Lena Headey), making Tyrion Lannister (Peter Dinklage) look dumb when he had always been two steps ahead, and sending Jon Snow, the hero of the story, into exile. Throwing so much into one episode of Game of Thrones led to nonsensical chaos and went against what we had been shown.
'The Sopranos' Finale Is Looked at Differently Today
The Game of Thrones series finale has nothing on the hate The Sopranos got when it went off the air in June 2007. Most of the episode works well enough, with Phil Leotardo (Frank Vincent) taken out, and the Soprano family looking like they're all going to make it out of this and live to see another day. However, just like Game of Thrones had a big question shadowing its run, so did The Sopranos. From day one, fans wondered if Tony Soprano (James Gandolfini) would die. Breaking Bad, which had a similar premise, was so successful with viewers by showing Walter White's (Bryan Cranston) actions costing him his life. Certainly, the same fate had to await a mob boss with so many enemies.
The final scene of The Sopranos is full of tension despite so little happening. The setting of Tony sitting in a diner, waiting for his family to join him, is intense because of how mundane it is. For this to be how it ends meant something shocking was coming. Everything has been leading up to this. The final minutes had the audience hooked. Every single time the diner door opens and another person walks in, we wonder if this is it. Are they here to kill our anti-hero? Then it happens, with nothing happening at all. As the diner door opens one more time and Tony looks up, Journey's "Don't Stop Believin'" stops and the screen goes to black.
Viewers hated the finale with a passion. After six seasons and 86 episodes, was this the best they could do? There were no answers in what felt like a cheap way to avoid having to make a choice about Tony's fate. However, it’s actually a brilliant finale, and one that’s earned. The finale rejected the predictable, either with Tony living or showing him going down in a hail of bullets. That last scene is unnerving, and rather than giving the audience what it wants, David Chase refuses to give any answers. All we get is what Tony is experiencing.
When it cuts to black, is life simply going on, or did Tony just get shot in the back of the head? That's for you to decide, although the latter is hinted at earlier when Bobby Baccalieri (Steve Schirripa) tells Tony that you probably don’t even hear it happen when you're shot dead. The Sopranos could have shown Tony die. But then what? By not giving a definitive resolution, it’s all anyone was talking about the next day, and we’re still talking about it two decades later. The not knowing sticks with us and allows fans to create their own conclusion. Love it or hate it, The Sopranos has one of the most memorable finales of all time, and it does so without rejecting everything that had come before.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.