To shoot or not: rethinking police use of lethal force in a civil society

The Kuala Lumpur police chief’s recent directive for policemen to fire when they encounter threats, including situations where they have doubts or feel threatened, raises an important question about the use of firearms by law enforcement in a civil democratic society.
The statement followed a serious incident in Gombak where a police officer suffered severe injuries in a machete attack.
Understandably, the safety and security of policemen must never be compromised. Officers who put their lives at risk to protect society deserve institutional support, protection and the authority to respond effectively to dangerous situations.
However, the broader question is whether a shoot-first approach is consistent with the principles of democratic policing.
Criminologically, policemen operate in unpredictable and potentially dangerous environments. They are expected to protect the public, prevent crime and enforce the law, sometimes while making split-second decisions. Their right to self-defence must be recognised and the government must provide the appropriate training, equipment and support.
Nevertheless, the authority to use firearms carries exceptional responsibility. In democratic societies, the determining factor should not simply be whether an officer feels threatened, but whether the threat is sufficiently immediate and serious to justify lethal force.
Differences in threats
There is an important distinction between a perceived threat, an actual threat and an imminent threat to life.
An officer’s subjective apprehension cannot, by itself, automatically justify discharging a firearm. The nature of the threat, the individual’s conduct, available alternatives and immediate danger to others must be objectively assessed.
International standards, particularly the United Nations Basic Principles on the Use of Force and Firearms by Law Enforcement Officials, emphasise necessity, proportionality and restraint.
Firearms should be used only in exceptional circumstances, particularly where there is an imminent threat of death or serious injury and less extreme measures are insufficient. The preservation of human life must remain paramount.
A policy that encourages officers to shoot whenever they experience uncertainty or apprehension could have unintended consequences. It may increase unnecessary fatalities, undermine public confidence and expose officers and the police institution to legal or disciplinary scrutiny.
Excessive or disproportionate force can weaken police legitimacy, public cooperation and effective crime prevention.
Equipping our police force
This does not mean expecting officers to hesitate when confronted with an immediate and potentially fatal attack. They must instead be equipped to make lawful and proportionate decisions under pressure.
Police services in established democratic societies generally emphasise structured use-of-force frameworks that incorporate de-escalation, conflict management, communication and alternatives to lethal force wherever practicable.
For Malaysia, this discussion should encourage greater transparency concerning police standing orders, firearms policies and procedures governing the discharge of weapons.
Public confidence requires firearm incidents to be documented and investigated without fear or favour, with independent scrutiny where death or serious injury occurs.
Accountability, however, must not become a mechanism for discouraging officers from taking necessary action when their lives or the lives of innocent members of the public are in immediate danger.
Police officers and other law enforcement personnel have a legitimate right and responsibility to protect themselves and the public.
When confronted with an imminent and serious threat, particularly an armed attack capable of causing death or grievous injury, they must have the authority and confidence to act decisively, including using lethal force where it is legally justified and necessary.
They should not be expected to expose themselves or innocent people to avoidable danger because of uncertainty about their authority to defend life.
Continuous training in firearms and the use of lethal force is essential. It must not be treated as a one-off exercise during basic training but be ongoing, regularly assessed and updated to reflect changing criminal threats, operational realities, technological developments and international best practices.
The SOPs governing firearms and lethal force must also be reviewed periodically and updated whenever necessary. They should clearly explain the circumstances in which firearms may be used, officers’ responsibilities, reporting requirements and post-incident procedures.
Ambiguous instructions place officers and the public at risk; clear, practical guidance is indispensable.
Ultimately, protecting police officers and protecting the public are not competing objectives. They are complementary responsibilities of a professional law enforcement service. Officers must not be expected to sacrifice their lives unnecessarily, nor should the public face an unrestricted use of lethal force.
The question is therefore not simply whether police should shoot or not. It is whether the circumstances legally, reasonably and objectively justify lethal force.
In a civil democratic society, officers must be decisive when confronting genuine and imminent threats to life, while restraint, professionalism, continuous training and accountability remain integral to the exercise of their authority.
The legitimacy of policing depends not merely on the ability to use force but on knowing when its use is justified and when it is not.
P Sundramoorthy is a criminologist at the Centre for Policy Research at Universiti Sains Malaysia.
The views expressed are those of the writer and do not necessarily reflect those of FMT.
Subscribe to our newsletter and get news delivered to your mailbox.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.