Cultural Arts Night canceled at Hunter College, spurring campus controversy over Hillel inclusion
The Hunter College Undergraduate Student Government (USG) canceled its scheduled Cultural Arts Night event for Monday, triggering campus controversy and competing explanations over the role of Hunter Hillel's participation and the withdrawal of other participating student clubs.
According to a promotional flyer distributed online, the event had been scheduled to take place on Monday organized in collaboration with several campus organizations, including Students for Justice in Palestine, the Peruvian Student Association, the Hunter Chinese Students and Scholars Association, the Taiwanese Student Association, CentroPR, and Rita Levine Rabin Hillel at Hunter College.
In an initial joint Instagram statement on Saturday, USG President Sumaiya Ahmed and Vice President Ahmad Waraich announced the cancellation and apologized for the event, writing, "To be blunt, we failed. The 'Cultural' Arts Night event is cancelled. It should never have moved forward."
Ahmed and Waraich stated in the initial post that "mistakes were made within USG," attributing the event's approval to "multiple lapses in communication and a failure in the chain of command." They added, "To be clear, USG does not endorse this event or this collaboration. We hear what the student body has said, and we have made the decision to cancel the event as it doesn't align with our values or the values of the students we represent as the Hunter Community."
The announcement prompted speculation online, with social media commenters and campus advocacy groups alleging that the event was called off after participating clubs objected to Hillel's inclusion.
In a follow-up official statement on Instagram, the USG sought to clarify its reasoning, noting that "previous statements may have led to confusion and misinterpretations regarding the reasons for cancellation." The student government stated that the event was canceled "due to safety concerns," explaining that as planning progressed, "several participating student organizations withdrew, creating additional difficulties in moving forward with the event as originally envisioned. Conflicting views of participating organizations raised safety concerns for all students."
Hunter College administration issued an official statement on Sunday addressing the speculation and stating that the Division of Student Affairs was working with student leaders to clarify their intentions. The college stated that it understood the student government's goal was to advance inclusive participation, adding, "When it appeared that USG's attempts to put on this event together on a short timeline would not result in an event reflecting those values and purposes, the USG decided to cancel and look for other opportunities to achieve these goals."
No place for antisemitism at Hunter College, Hillel says
Rita Levine Rabin Hillel at Hunter College stated on Instagram that its community had been looking forward to participating and "had no role in the decision to cancel."
"Antisemitism has no place at Hunter College. Jewish students should never be singled out, scapegoated, or made to feel unwelcome because of who they are and the antisemitic response online to the cancellation notice has been egregious and inappropriate," Hillel stated.
Addressing Jewish students directly, Hillel added, "To our Jewish students: You belong here, and we are with you. Our doors are open, and our staff and student leaders are here to talk, offer support, or help you report an incident." Calling on the broader campus to "reject hate in every form and help keep our campus a place where every student can thrive," the group stated, "We are committed to working with the administration and student government in achieving our shared goal of a campus where every culture is celebrated. We look forward to joining USG’s next cultural event."
The Israel on Campus Coalition wrote on X/Twitter that the student government's initial apology saying the event "doesn't align with our values" was unacceptable, stating, "Shutting down an event because a Jewish organization is participating is blatant antisemitism."
UJA-Federation of New York calls Cultural Arts Night cancellation 'deeply troubling'
In a statement posted on X, UJA-Federation of New York wrote, "The cancellation of Cultural Arts Night at Hunter College is deeply troubling, particularly amid concerns that this cancellation is related to objections over Hillel's participation."
UJA-Federation added, "UJA-Federation is working with Hunter College Hillel, JCRC-NY, and other partners to press for answers and accountability. We stand firmly with Hunter’s Jewish students and will continue to advocate on their behalf."
"CUNY must promptly investigate the circumstances surrounding this decision, provide a full accounting of what happened, and ensure that Jewish students and organizations can participate fully and equally in campus life without intimidation or exclusion," UJA-Federation stated.
The USG did not respond to The Jerusalem Post's request for comment by publication time.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.