What do I want from Santa? No more lazy, joyless Christmas lists | Polly Hudson

If the first step is admitting there’s a problem, please consider this an intervention. Many of us need help, and what I’m suggesting is pretty much a cold turkey approach, no pun intended. The Christmas list must be abolished, once and for all.
It’s tricky to remember when it started, but, in my experience at least, this way of festive gifting has ramped up over the past few years, and is now threatening to become the norm. And it makes sense. Modern life is exhausting, and hard, so of course we leap gratefully onboard with anything that promises to make it easier. If a list is sent, or simply a direct link to one product, we can achieve with a few thumb movements from the comfort of the sofa what used to necessitate a journey, a fight through crowds, some searching, some queueing, and then a return journey. Instead, now, a couple of taps and a swipe, job done, lemon squeezy. But we’re not noticing what’s getting lost. On the surface we are all being given exactly what we want, but are we really?
The Christmas list process feels increasingly cold, meaningless and materialistic. If, as present-givers, we used our brains, our hearts, rather than our smartphones, maybe the gifts wouldn’t be perfect, but they’d show we’d made an effort. That we can be bothered. A deeper intention would be communicated: I know you, I get you, I’m paying attention – as opposed to: I have received your email. Meanwhile, if we’re the ones issuing instructions, the prospect of disappointment or duplication is erased, sure, but so, too, is the excitement, the anticipation, the surprise. The Russian roulette element to proceedings. The thrill of the chase.
The adults in the group I spend 25 December with – a treasured assortment of family and friends – always do Secret Santa. It started old-fashionedly, on paper, with a pen, and has become gradually more slick and technological. The person whose nine millionth festive job was wrestling with the complicated equation of who gets who found an app that does that. Brilliant. Then the app updated, to include an option for participants to add the link to a gift within the agreed budget that they’d enjoy. And naturally, if somebody you’re trying to make happy asks you for something, you give it to them.
The Secret Santa handover used to be a funny, somewhat raucous high point of the day, Santa’s representative charged with overseeing proceedings doing so with inimitable flair. The first time the app took over, it felt strangely flat. There was zero drama or intrigue. No one had been permitted to use their imagination, was worried a risk might not pay off, had the chance of pulling a maverick blinder. We needn’t have troubled ourselves with unwrapping the packages, because we all knew what was inside them already. A few years before, somebody gave me something so silly and unexpectedly touching that I laughed until I cried. There is no comparison between the two experiences, and I am factoring in the occasion when I got a stinker I donated to the nearest charity shop as soon as it reopened. Off piste is where the magic happens.
Also, it’s not like the listless have to shoot blindly into the dark. Hints can and undoubtedly will be dropped. From now until 24 December, it is impossible to go for longer than three minutes without being offered the opportunity to read a gift guide. We can ask the giftee’s friends for advice. We could turn to science – for example, the website Pebble, which analyses the psychology of the recipient and suggests ideas (with links!). We might put the recipient’s life under a thought microscope and examine it for gaps, items that would make it nicer, smoother, faster, more comfortable, fun or stylish. There are many other ways to go about this, all of which say much more about the relationship between you than any mindless mouse click ever could.
’Tis the season where you can get away with sappy cliches, like that it’s your presence, not your presents, that actually matters at Christmas, and that when it comes to shopping, it really is the thought that counts. Keep the receipt, though, obviously.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.