Age instead of need drives Alan Milburn’s new reforms. Welcome to the two-tier welfare state | Frances Ryan

Two things can be true at once. The government’s long-awaited plan to fix the youth unemployment crisis is a multibillion-pound generational reform package – and hundreds of thousands of young disabled people will be afraid that they’re about to lose the money they need to live on.
Under Alan Milburn’s proposals – thought to already have the backing of Andy Burnham – young people aged between 18 and 24 would be barred from claiming the two main sickness and disability benefits: the health element of universal credit (UC), for people too ill or disabled to work, and personal independence payments (Pip), which pay for some of the extra costs of disability.
While older unemployed disabled people get a “top-up” payment on UC, those under 25 will be given a new “youth allowance”: that’s just the standard benefit rate of just over £75 a week that healthy jobseekers get, alongside significant one-on-one employment support. Those living independently from their parents will get a higher rate of benefit as they seek work, as well as those whose health means they will never be able to have a job.
Meanwhile, Pip would be replaced for under-25s with a new higher benefit rate called the “additional cost allowance” that will only be paid to a minority with “significant, well-established and ongoing” costs relating to their disability. That means many of the 453,000 young people who are currently claiming Pip would lose their entitlement to a monthly payment entirely. Instead, they will have to apply for money for a named specific purpose, such as travel expenses or a disability aid.
This is in effect the creation of a two-tier welfare state, where the help you receive isn’t determined by your health but the date on your birth certificate. The £3.6bn in cuts would sever the link between need and entitlement that sits at the heart of the safety net – potentially leading to the perverse situation where two people with the same disability get unequal support simply because they’re a different age.
After months of stories inflaming the narrative that feckless youngsters are feigning disability for cash, as a fashion statement or because of “social contagion”, Milburn will have felt under immense pressure to curb the youth benefits bill as a trade-off for his other large-scale spending plans. That pensioners receive roughly 55% of the welfare budget and young people (excluding children) just 2.5% is conveniently ignored.
It’s true that young people today are facing unique circumstances and Milburn sets out a colossal pile of evidence to that end. And yet he fails to justify why under-25s should have a completely different benefits system from other adults, let alone one that involves giving the generation shut out of the housing and labour markets less financial support than their parents and grandparents. Nor is there much explanation as to why Pip – already up for reform in the Timms review, due to report this month – has been lumped in with an unemployment review, considering many young people who rely on it already have jobs.
Even Milburn’s plan to extend child disability living allowance (the children’s version of Pip) from age 16 to 18 – in itself perfectly sensible – is framed as “preparing young people for work”. Not every pound the Treasury spends has to maximise productivity. Sometimes it’s about affording an accessible taxi to get to a friend’s birthday party.
Removing Pip from these young people could have a devastating domino effect – not simply because of how much the money is relied on, but because it is a “gateway” benefit to other key support. When an 18-year-old loses Pip, do the changes mean their parent will also lose carer’s allowance? What about the Motability car they use to drive to their apprenticeship? None of this is covered in the review’s 241 pages and will have to be thrashed out by ministers if the recommendations are accepted.
There is some reason to be relieved. On top of the longterm investment for employment, Milburn has pledged not to “reduce existing financial help before the replacement support and opportunity are in place”, although we must wait to see what that transition would look like in practice. The higher benefit rates will be welcome to those who have long buckled under the costs of their severe disabilities, as will the pledge to deliver it “immediately” by using information the state already holds (say, in the NHS or schools), rather than putting those with lifelong conditions through yet another assessment.
But in Milburn’s own words, there will “intentionally” be a “very high bar” to qualify. That phrase will instil fear in those dreading the thought of not making the grade, not least those with significant disabilities who’ve been promised protection from cuts in the past, only for harsh criteria to judge them as “not disabled enough”.
On paper, it’s smart to fix the system to target monthly support more effectively: one in five of Pip’s current 16- to 24-year-old caseload report little to no additional costs from their disability, as very real but “less expensive” conditions such as ADHD and anxiety increase for this group. But years of faulty benefit assessments mean it will be hard to trust that authorities can accurately work out who needs what.
The concept of young disabled people who don’t qualify for an entitlement having to ask local administrators for “permission” to buy something may appease the right, but it will fill claimants who have to justify every expense with trepidation.
Meanwhile, there is little word on how to make the workplace more accessible. While employers will be incentivised to hire young people, an “opportunity guarantee” will remain hollow without roles suitable for those with significant health conditions. That a key reason young people are unemployed is poor mental health only makes it more obvious that the stress of losing their benefits will hardly make them feel more equipped to seek or stay in work.
“Generational” reform may assuage the Labour backbenchers who have hung on for a year for Milburn’s plans. But it will be little comfort to the young people reading the headlines who are now scared they won’t make the cut to keep the benefits they need to pay the bills. For them, the wait is just beginning.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.