Migrants targeted, charity workers menaced for helping them. Are we that kind of society? | Natasha Walter

There is a small charity that brings its local community together every day in a centre made bright with flowers grown in its own little garden. People, old and young, migrant and citizen, eat meals together made from food that would otherwise go to waste. The children play with donated toys, the grownups learn English together. Last summer, they had an outing to the seaside and posted some of the joyful pictures online.
They won’t do that again.
“A newspaper took photographs from our website,” the charity’s director tells me, “and made a huge deal out of them, making out that it was a scandal that refugees should be allowed to enjoy themselves, implying that the outing was taxpayer-funded.” Now the charity rarely posts photographs of its beneficiaries, and doesn’t share its address online. “It’s dangerous, with the kind of abuse charities are getting.”
This may seem like a trivial incident – a few pictures, some snide comments, inaccurate reporting around a charity’s funding. But it is one example of a much bigger picture: how rising hostility is transforming how charities work.
A report published last week captures the scale of this transformation. In its survey of more than 200 charities, Asylum Matters and Praxis have gathered evidence of workers experiencing direct harassment, including rape and death threats. It quotes workers who have been filmed by intruders in their workplaces, who have been called traitors and parasites. Nearly three-quarters of those surveyed said that they felt less safe delivering their services now than they did three years ago.
I have seen this change up close. Twenty years ago, I co-founded the charity Women for Refugee Women. From the start, we not only worked directly with refugee women, but also, because we wanted to build solidarity and understanding, with the public.
I don’t want to idealise those years. Politicians were ramping up punitive policies and parts of the media were already constantly scapegoating migrants for some of Britain’s problems. But, at the same time, a consensus remained strong that it was good to help vulnerable people, good to bring communities together, good to share, good to welcome others. And so we were able to work openly, building up diverse networks in different communities. We published stories in traditional and social media without fear of abuse, and we held dozens of public events, including street protests and free exhibitions. I cannot remember a single incident of hate that we experienced in the first decade of our work.
One of my former colleagues observed that an incident last year really brought home to her how much things had changed. Marchu Belete, who now works for Migration Exchange, was invited to speak at a community event in a church organised by an anti-racist organisation. “Before the event could begin, a group of men forced their way into the venue, filming and shouting,” Belete told me.
The meeting had to be cancelled and the police were called. “We have to realise,” Belete said, “that what we used to be able to do in terms of inviting everyone to meet and connect is simply no longer possible. That openness has gone.”
Women for Refugee Women still does its valuable work day in and day out, but with new concerns. “We have to think about our safety now,” Andrea Vukovic, the current co-director, told me. That might range from taking staff details off the website all the way to hiring private security for a public event. She was keen to remind me that those who suffer the most are the refugee women themselves. “It’s another thing, alongside the hostile political climate, that makes the women we work with feel unsafe and unwanted,” she said.
The report makes clear that it is not only charities working with migrants that are suffering in this climate, although they are most clearly on the frontline, including the Royal National Lifeboat Institution volunteers who have been menaced by rightwing activists.
And we should also remember that, while the worst abuse comes from people we might see as quite marginal – those nameless individuals who interrupt events or send anonymous threats to charities – the flames of anger are also being fanned by traditional media and by politicians.
after newsletter promotion
For instance, in 2025 the charity City of Sanctuary was targeted for running activities in schools around Valentine’s Day to share welcoming messages about refugees. A furore implying the charity was grooming children to send cards to adult men was partly built by extremists posting online, but also spurred on by the Telegraph, who used the headline: “Schoolchildren as young as five write Valentine’s Day cards to asylum seekers.” And it spread to politicians, including the Tory MP Gavin Williamson, who complained to the Charity Commission. Even though the commission cleared the charity of any wrongdoing, the misinformation resulted in torrents of abuse for its staff and trustees.
Similarly, when Celebrity Traitors ended with the winners donating to refugee charities, some of the nastiest reactions were shared by anonymous accounts on social media. But mainstream media figures such as Julia Hartley-Brewer and MPs such as Esther McVey shared their anger, too. And such support in turn has emboldened the extremists to keep going, with protesters even turning up at Radio 2 to target Romesh Ranganathan at work.
It’s vital that those who want to reclaim the openness that once characterised our society speak out against the descent into such hatred. Because otherwise this new swirling anger will simply be normalised. And those who suffer are all of us. Because all of us now live in communities where people who volunteer to teach English or run food banks have to worry about their safety, where churches are afraid to host meetings against racism for fear of who might turn up, where civic space is shrinking everywhere. In this latest report, one statement by a worker from a refugee charity stood out to me. “We are tired.”
Indeed, it is exhausting to keep going in the face of such hatred. What still astounds me when I talk to the people who are at the sharp end of this every day is how they keep going nonetheless, constantly working to mend the fabric of society, constantly weaving the threads of connection, against those who are so eager to tear us all apart.
-
Natasha Walter is an author and honorary professor at Queen Mary University of London. She is the founder of Women for Refugee Women
-
Do you have an opinion on the issues raised in this article? If you would like to submit a response of up to 300 words by email to be considered for publication in our letters section, please click here.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.