InquirerAeta communities in Bataan reject mining deal in ancestral landDaily MaverickAmazon’s Bezos says he helped pick Pattinson as BondThe Jerusalem PostSa’ar welcomes 250 US leaders for ‘50 States, One Israel’ initiativePunchNo evidence of Sokoto protest plot, DSS tackles Atiku20 MinutenWie weit ist ein Lichttag? Mach das Quiz zum Voyager-1-Rekord!한겨레‘리트 만점자’ 광수단·관악서 등에서 고발 이어져…수능 고득점 수사도 이뤄질 듯ZDF heuteAktuelle Pressemitteilungen des ZDFComplete SportsNNL: ‘It Will Be Disrespectful To Other Teams’ –Amuneke Speaks On Heartland’s NPFL Promotion HopesESPN CricinfoUnchanged England bat; Zampa out with back spasms for AustraliaNew Straits TimesAnwar thanks Trump for recognising Malaysia's role in easing Cambodia-Thailand tensionsLenta.ruГлава РФПИ назвал количество реализованных проектов с партнерами из АТЭСThe Japan TimesDemocracy needs room for religious difference
The Daily Newsstand · Free, Always
Wednesday, November 18, 2026

HELEN WHATELY: It must be painful for Labour to see their big review trash their policies

Translate

Published: | Updated:

Labour wants us to believe their Milburn report is a watershed moment. They claim it’s their big plan to tackle the crisis of one million Neets.

With so many young people stuck at home instead of doing something with their lives, we want Alan Milburn to succeed. And where his report gets it right, the Conservatives will back him to make it happen.

He spelled out some hard truths to the Labour Government – like how their jobs tax and employment red tape have destroyed opportunities for young people. Just as the Tories have been saying all along, Labour has made it too expensive and too risky for businesses to hire them. And they’ve done huge damage to retail and hospitality, the sectors in which many young people get their first job.

Our plan will halve the jobs tax for under-25s and cut business rates for 250,000 high-street shops and hospitality venues. That’s the best way to give young people sat at home the chance to get a job.

Reading between the lines, Milburn agrees. He also says the Government should reduce employer’s National Insurance contributions for under-25s. But there’s a catch. He says ‘when fiscal conditions allow’. Sadly, at this rate, under this Government, that means never.

If Labour were willing to cut welfare spending, they could afford to cut the jobs tax. But with backbench MPs who just want to put up taxes to spend more on benefits, there’s little hope of that.

Alan Milburn says the Government should reduce employer’s National Insurance contributions for under-25s – but only ‘when fiscal conditions allow’

Conservatives know governments don’t create jobs – businesses do, writes Helen Whately

Instead, the Milburn report proposes nearly £6billion more of spending, largely on Government-funded work placements. They boast of business partnerships, without seeing the absurdity of taxing businesses so they have to cut real jobs, only to use those taxes to fund fake Government-subsidised jobs.

Milburn’s plan for the welfare side of the problem makes more sense. He is right to tackle the extraordinary number of young people signed off on sickness and disability benefits. This generation are not sicker than their grandparents were, but too many are parked on handouts.

The Conservatives would stop giving out cash for mild conditions; treatment and support to work is better. You will find this exact policy in Milburn’s recommendations. But that’s where the savings more or less end.

As a result, despite all the fanfare, Milburn’s plan would at best save a mere £200million. In ten years’ time. And no surprises, in the Government’s response in Parliament it welcomed the spending proposals but said not a peep about the savings.

It must be painful for Labour to see their own landmark review trash their economic policies and then recommend the Conservative Party’s plan to reform disability benefits.

But the Prime Minister should listen to the hard truths. Young people need more than a ten-year plan and a place on a government scheme – they deserve a real job and the chance to build a life.

Conservatives know governments don’t create jobs, businesses do. It’s time Labour woke up to this – because no one wants their legacy to be a lost generation.

View the original on Daily Mail →

KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.