Siblings challenge bid to acquire mall shop lot for mere RM9,300

Two siblings who bought a shop lot in the now-abandoned City Parade Commercial Complex in Bukit Mertajam more than 30 years ago are challenging a company’s attempt to acquire their unit for a meagre RM9,300.
Respectable Property Management Sdn Bhd (RPM), which owns the land on which the shopping complex sits, is seeking a High Court order compelling siblings Evelyn and Eric Lee to sell their unit based on a valuation commissioned by the company.
Alternatively, RPM wants the pair to contribute towards a proposed RM68.6 million refurbishment of the complex and lease their unit to the company once the redevelopment is completed.
The dispute forms part of a lawsuit filed by RPM against 92 defendants in January last year.
The Lees are seeking to strike out the suit against them, arguing that RPM has no legal basis to force them to accept either proposal.
Court documents show that the siblings entered into a sale and purchase agreement in December 1995 to acquire Unit 2-21 in the shopping complex for RM231,840.
The seven-storey complex, which includes two basement parking levels, ceased operations some 25 years ago and has remained abandoned ever since.
RPM acquired the property from Danaharta in 2011, subject to the rights of purchasers who had already bought units in the development. However, strata titles were never issued for individual units.
In a letter sent two years ago, RPM offered the siblings RM9,300 for their unit. The offer was based on a valuation conducted by CBRE WTW Valuation & Advisory Sdn Bhd, which factored in the estimated cost of refurbishing the building.
The letter also stated that assessment charges amounting to RM10,200.50 were outstanding to the Seberang Perai City Council (MBSP) as of June 30, 2024.
According to RPM, the building had fallen into severe disrepair, with missing doors and windows, accumulated rubbish and frequent trespassing.
The company said MBSP had issued notices over the property’s condition and warned of possible enforcement action arising from unpaid assessment charges.
RPM further argued that it would be inequitable for the company alone to bear the cost of restoring the complex while unit owners stood to benefit from its redevelopment without contributing financially.
The Lees, however, maintain that RPM cannot compel them to surrender their rights to the unit or require them to fund refurbishment works they never agreed to undertake.
Their lawyers, led by Chong Yew Sheng, also dispute RPM’s reliance on a provision of the National Land Code governing disputes between co-owners of land.
They contend that the provision is inapplicable because RPM is the sole registered landowner, while purchasers hold contractual rights to individual units within the complex.
The siblings further argue that RPM cannot claim contributions for refurbishment works that have not yet been carried out.
The High Court has fixed Dec 2 for a decision on whether RPM’s suit against the two owners should proceed to trial.
Subscribe to our newsletter and get news delivered to your mailbox.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.