US envoy slams New Zealand mayor over ‘unfathomable’ democracy, Beijing remarks

The US ambassador to New Zealand on Wednesday sharply criticised Auckland Mayor Wayne Brown after the mayor said democracy had “had its day” and praised China’s governance and economic model.
Brown, who recently led a business delegation on a multicity tour of China, called democracy an “unfathomable system” and questioned electoral processes across Western countries.
“I don’t know what’s going on in New Zealand,” Brown told local media outlet Stuff, referring to the November 7 general election, which left the country in political limbo with preliminary results too close to call. Coalition talks are expected to begin once final results are released later this month.
“And look at the election in America … [it] produced a sort of non-working government. Europe hasn’t had a good election for years,” he said. “Democracy’s had its day. It’s time for something else, really.”
Asked what alternative system he favoured, Brown said he did not want to get involved in ideological debates.
“What’s working? China’s working – in terms of economic growth and prosperity,” he said. “When I first started going there 25 years ago, people were so poor they didn’t have a bicycle. Then they got bicycles. Now they’ve got electric scooters.”
Brown also praised Beijing’s economic approach, arguing that its model allowed uncompetitive businesses to fail, unlike New Zealand’s.
“We don’t allow people to fail. We prop up Fletcher’s, we prop up all these dogs,” he said, referring to Fletcher Building, New Zealand’s largest listed construction materials firm. In July, the government pledged up to NZ$60 million (US$32.9 million) in funding to keep a cement plant owned by the company open.
Brown’s remarks drew a swift rebuke from US Ambassador Jared Novelly.

“I suppose [the] New Zealand government requires a minimum level of intelligence to receive an intelligence briefing; it’s obvious from his statements the mayor hasn’t made the cut,” Novelly wrote in a social media post. “The United States and New Zealand didn’t build two successful democracies by deciding that giving people a say was too much trouble.”
Novelly likened democracy to Auckland traffic – “messy, slow and frustrating” – before adding: “No one would recommend getting rid of the traffic lights.”
The envoy, who also referred to the 80-year-old mayor as a “boomer”, denied mocking Brown’s age and rejected criticism from some social media users who described his remarks as undiplomatic. “I’m not a diplomat; I come from a business background,” Novelly said.
Novelly suggested Brown had been “captured” by China during his recent visit, which included an address at the Global Mayors Forum in Ningbo. He also demanded an apology from the mayor for calling on New Zealand to sell its seat in the Five Eyes intelligence alliance to Japan – a remark Novelly called “egregious and insulting”.
“I would hope that those who are in the know would pull him aside, kind of quietly, and correct him on what’s really happening and what a Five Eyes partner means,” Novelly said, according to state broadcaster RNZ.
In his interview with Stuff, Brown had questioned the value of the Five Eyes network – which comprises New Zealand, the United States, Britain, Canada and Australia – saying he could not “see anything in it for us”.
“Wellington has veered a bit more towards America, but Auckland, the biggest city, is definitely more pro-China,” Brown said. “With Five Eyes, I have suggested we sell our seat to Japan.”
Brown’s office said the mayor would not comment on Novelly’s remarks on democracy.
The exchange sparked divided reactions online. Some social media users called Brown’s comments on democracy “disqualifying” and an “embarrassment”, with one arguing the mayor was ignoring efforts by the US administration to rebuild domestic industrial capacity.
Others urged the US envoy to leave New Zealand, citing Washington’s historical record of foreign interventions. “Clearly your country has not valued other democracies’ sovereignty, as the US has meddled in other countries’ elections for decades,” one user wrote.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.