PunchNigerian scholar wins research trophy at Manchester UniversityThe Jerusalem PostBritish lord claims Jewish attitudes towards Israel 'undoubtedly' cause of antisemitism - reportCNN TürkPilot Lisans Yönetmeliği'nde değişiklik한겨레정성호 “최민희 징계 안할 순 없지만, 정치력 발휘해야ZDF heuteAktuelle Pressemitteilungen des ZDFSCMP ChinaApec brings world leaders and probably 2 ‘nuclear briefcases’ to Shenzhen매일경제“어제부터 휴대폰 끄고 잠적”…‘리트 만점’ 이진우, 공개검증자리 불참The Sydney Morning HeraldGTA 6 LIVE updates: Consequences for violence, removal of sex workers and stunning gameplay revealed as thirteen-year wait for iconic game ends; reviews say it’s the greatest game ever madeSportstarIndia vs New Zealand, 1st Test Day 1 LIVE score: Play resumes after Lunch; NZ 64/4 (24)ABC NewsCMA Awards 2026: Taylor Swift, Ella Langley, Jessica Chastain and more hit the carpetCBS NewsIran ramps up attacks on Gulf countries after U.S. strikesEl ComercioLima 2027: El pedido urgente del entrenador de la Selección Peruana de Taekwondo Poomsae
The Daily Newsstand · Free, Always
Thursday, November 19, 2026

Why Scarlett Johansson Replaced DC Star In New Crime Thriller Explained By Director

Translate

Matthew Rudoy is one of ScreenRant's Movie & TV News Editors. He covers the latest in movie & TV news, with a focus on major franchises like Star Wars, The Boys, and Game of Thrones, and also writes some features and reviews. He wrote lists for ScreenRant from 2017-2022, became a news writer in 2023, a senior staff writer in 2024, and an editor in 2025. 

Scarlett Johansson's role in the new crime thriller Paper Tiger originally belonged to a DC star.

Directed, written, and produced by James Gray, Paper Tiger sees Johansson playing Hester Pearl, whose husband, Gary Pearl (Adam Driver), and his brother, Irwin Pearl (Miles Teller), get caught up with the Russian mafia. Originally, Gray intended for it to be a follow-up to his 2022 movie Armageddon Time, which is largely based on his own parents and childhood, but the project's focus and casting ended up being significantly altered.

In an interview with IndieWire, Gray explained that Anne Hathaway was originally supposed to reprise her Armageddon Time role of Esther Graff, based on the filmmaker's mother, in what became Paper Tiger. With The Dark Knight Rises star's schedule already booked for Christopher Nolan's The Odyssey, though, Gray decided he didn't want to wait and would change the story from being an Armageddon Time follow-up.

In terms of who would replace Hathaway, he realized that Johansson would be an excellent choice after nearly working with her on a project that never came to fruition, her prominent Hollywood stardom, and being a Jewish New Yorker. He didn't expect her to join the movie, but she quickly agreed to it after being sent the script. Check out Gray's comments below:

You can’t wait a year and a half. And then I started thinking, "Well, maybe this is a blessing in disguise." That the [film] could start to take on a new style, and so then I started to pursue it in a different way. So in the beginning, in its origin stages, it was [a sequel of sorts], but like any movie, it’s like a wild horse that’s going to get away from you.

I had met [Scarlett] years before on a project that never wound up happening, and quite liked her. She’s a total New Yorker through and through. Then when I found out that Annie [Hathaway] was going off to do Chris [Nolan’s] movie [The Odyssey] for a thousand years, she was the first choice because you’re talking about one of the biggest stars in the world, and she’s also a Jewish woman from New York, checks the boxes. When I sent [the script] to her, I sent her a note, "There’s probably no chance in hell you’re going to do this, but I love you, can you read this?" And then she texted me back very, very quickly and was like, "Let’s go."

While Hathaway's character is more open and loving than the family patriarch played by Jeremy Strong in Armageddon Time, Paper Tiger required a different approach, and one that Gray feels Johansson was ultimately better suited to: “It’s a more operatic idea of character than Annie’s was in Armageddon Time. It’s much more a kind of high emotion. And of course, because the situation is much more tragic, and she embraced it completely.”

Another casting choice that came with the crime thriller being revamped is that Strong would no longer play Irving Graff, the husband of Hathaway's character, and who instead became Gary, played by Driver. Irving was based on Gray's real-life father.

Both Johansson and Hathaway have played major superhero universe characters before, with the former as Marvel's Natasha Romanoff/Black Widow in multiple films and the latter as Selina Kyle/Catwoman in DC's The Dark Knight Rises. In Hathaway's case, her role led to Nolan casting her again for Interstellar and The Odyssey, the second of which ended up being the reason that she couldn't be in Gray's Armageddon Time follow-up. Her performance as Penelope in Nolan's epic received considerable praise, and she is expected to receive an Academy Award nomination for it.

The Odyssey went on to gross $1.8 billion worldwide and break numerous box office records, including becoming the highest-grossing R-rated movie and highest-grossing IMAX movie of all time. Paper Tiger's box office is already setting its own records ahead of a wide theatrical release, with a 3-day domestic opening gross of $215,009 across just six theaters. This is a per-screen average of $35,834, far surpassing Gray's previous debut per-screen average record of $27,453 for the 2016 movie The Lost City of Z.

With a "Certified Fresh" 86% Tomatometer score based on 125 reviews, Paper Tiger reviews have generally been positive. ScreenRant's Patrice Witherspoon praised the performances of Driver and Teller, while describing Johansson as "criminally underused," and giving an overall rating of five out of 10 stars.

Paper Tiger is playing in select theaters, followed by a wide release on November 20.

paper-tiger-poster.jpg

Release Date
November 20, 2026

Runtime
115 minutes

Director
James Gray

Writers
James Gray

Producers
Andrea Bucko, Andrea Leone, Anthony Katagas, Carlo Salem, Gary Farkas, James Gray, Leonardo Maria Del Vecchio, Marco Perego, Raffaella Leone, Rodrigo Teixeira

View the original on Screen Rant →

KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.