The One About Matthew Perry and what could have been

The crime
Distribution of ketamine; distribution resulting in death.

The story
Last month’s three-part documentary from Netflix on the meteoric rise and myriad falls of actor Matthew Perry is pretty watchable, because Perry himself of course was and is very watchable. As well, director Mary Robertson (Quiet On Set; The Fall of Diddy) is well-versed in the build of exactly this subgenre, which I guess we could classify as “celebrity culture warping criminal justice.”
Certainly The One About Matthew Perry – corny but unavoidable titling convention aside – is more thoughtful and informed than other docs that hurried to comment on Perry’s untimely death in 2023. It’s more a memoir of grief by non-Friend people who loved him and his work than a true-crime property, and that approach is valuable. Still, I can’t quite recommend The One About.
I talked about this on Extra Hot Great this week, but as you know if you’ve come through Best Evidence before, I don’t like to criticize projects on the basis of what they are not – so it’s unfortunate that that’s an issue with The One About. As I said on EHG,
Perry is one of the most thoroughly documented cultural figures of his generation, which means any materials about him at this late date need to go in very focused on a very contained slice of his life or work: just Friends, just his childhood, just his activism around drug court.
I’d add to that last bit that I’d love to have seen a doc that used Perry’s advocacy around the drug-sentencing issue, and the way responsibility for Perry’s death was apportioned and adjudicated, to talk more broadly about the difficulties of getting celebrities and/or the super-wealthy effective treatment. The One About does mention towards the end the challenge of “environment” – i.e., that people of elevated statuses can and will ensure they don’t have to hear “no” – but a longer-form look at that problem, which is likely responsible for dozens of celebrity deaths (think Elvis Presley), is a project worth tackling.

The One About isn’t obligated to do that, but I got the sense that it aimed for a complete biography of Perry, and as a result, it feels checklist-y at times. I also got the sense Robertson struggled with how to frame Perry’s substance-use struggle in a way that wouldn’t completely block out the sun of everything else in his life and work, and I don’t know that that’s possible in Perry’s case. Interest in that part of it is human, but it does seem like you either have to subtract it entirely or go all in on it – it’s hard to balance as a topic, as it was hard for Perry to balance it in his life, but IMO you need a less conventional narrative attack here.
All of that said, The One About is often moving. Perry sister Mia, now a therapist (in part because she wanted to know better how to help Perry), has a lot of talking-head screentime, and many bittersweetly well-turned things to say about the “job” of trying to love someone when the disease is standing between you. I do think the doc, as I said on EHG, “set out to honor Perry without being either tabloidy or bullshitty about how hard the disease could make it to know him.”
But his memoir already did that work, or tried to, and The One About isn’t un-compelling, but it’s a little too long, uses the same wanly scored eighties photos a few too many times, and doesn’t tell us very much new…it only reminds us again, as these projects sometimes do, that it is still apparently possible to die of a broken heart.
Recommendation: Friends/Perry super-fans, WATCH; everyone else can SKIP
The case in favor:
- Competently built
- Respectful; minimal rubbernecking
- Gives many who loved him space to grieve and share
The case against:
- About 1/3 again too long
- Too painstaking in some ways (his Friends audition; in-jokes)
- …and too elliptical in others
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.