The Jerusalem PostThree years after the Nova massacre on October 7, what does recovery look like?Daily MaverickWATER WINGS: SA rower wins Youth Olympic gold just 15 months after picking up an oarZDF heuteEntdecken Sie das ZDF-Nachrichtenstudio20 MinutenWarum fehlten die Ehefrauen der Kataris beim Staatsdinner?TechCrunchChips can survive the space environment. Can their financing?VarietyMaleah Joi Moon on Netflix’s ‘A Different World,’ Debbie Allen’s Backstage Offer and Owning the Show’s ‘Complicated History’ With CosbyBillboardBrandy Believes a ‘Moesha’ Reboot ‘Can Really Be Something in Today’s Time’Global NewsRecipe: White Spot’s best everyday mashed potatoesCBS NewsMarine Corps hero under federal investigationالشرقالعراق يعيد رسم السيطرة على جرف الصخر.. ما "المقر المسيطر" ولماذا الآن؟BBC NewsUS man found guilty of British woman's murderBBC BusinessAnthropic shares fall after blockbuster opening as wider tech sell-off continues
The Daily Newsstand · Free, Always
Friday, November 20, 2026

To become Israel's next PM, Eisenkot faces choice between Arab support and haredi demands - opinion

Translate

With coalition negotiations now at a fever pitch, Israel's opposition has an opportunity to end Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's long rule and begin repairing the country's battered democratic institutions and international standing. But the price its leaders may pay could undermine the very future they are trying to secure.

Gadi Eisenkot, the former military chief seeking to form Israel's next government, commands 48 seats in the 120-member Knesset.

With the addition of 19 seats from the Arab parties – an all-time record, whose support is effectively being offered free of charge, he has 67, a comfortable majority.

The obstacle is political, not mathematical: most of Eisenkot's partners promised not to form a government dependent on Arab parties. Accepting their support would break that promise.

The alternative is to bring in the 14 lawmakers from the haredi (ultra-Orthodox) parties, who have for decades been aligned with Netanyahu’s Likud and the Right. But that would compromise another central opposition promise: ending the sweeping military draft exemptions enjoyed by tens of thousands of haredi yeshiva students.

Mansour Abbas is the head of Ra’am, one of four Arab parties vying for a place in the Knesset.
Mansour Abbas is the head of Ra’am, one of four Arab parties vying for a place in the Knesset. (credit: MARC ISRAEL SELLEM/THE JERUSALEM POST)

The costs of these two broken promises could hardly be more different.

The Arab parties are asking for relatively little, principally a crackdown on organized crime and violence in Arab communities. The haredim, by contrast, demand concessions extending beyond conscription to public funding, education and communal autonomy, with potentially devastating long-term consequences.

According to reports, and reading between the lines of his statements, Eisenkot appears willing to take the Arab option, possibly with their support from outside a 48-member coalition. His own conditions, including recognition of Hamas as a terrorist organization, appear acceptable to at least one Arab party, Ra'am.

Netanyahu's mathematical challenges

Contrary to Netanyahu's narrative, such a government would not necessarily collapse quickly. Israel requires a constructive vote of no confidence: 61 lawmakers must agree on an alternative government. Netanyahu's bloc has only 53 seats.

Removing Eisenkot this way would effectively require Arab lawmakers to help reinstall Netanyahu, an exceedingly unlikely prospect. Other dangers exist, including failure to pass a budget, but the supposed inevitability of collapse is unconvincing.

The immediate obstacle appears to be Avigdor Liberman, leader of the fiercely secular Yisrael Beytenu party, who remains unwilling to rely on Arab lawmakers, at least before exhausting negotiations with the haredim.

The irony here is that Liberman has built his political identity around opposing haredi privileges and religious coercion. Now he appears prepared to accommodate the very parties he has spent years denouncing.

Had Eisenkot and Liberman jointly made clear that the Arab option was available, the haredim would have understood they were not indispensable. Their price might have been considerably lower.

And the stakes extend far beyond the draft. After three years of war, equality in military service is a justified demand. Hundreds of thousands have spent long months in the reserves, families have lost loved ones, and the army needs manpower. Sweeping exemptions for yeshiva students constitute a profound moral injustice. But the draft issue pales beside the economic and demographic threat.

Israel’s growing haredi economic burden

Only about half of working-age haredi men are employed, earning substantially less on average than other Jewish Israelis. Haredi boys are systematically denied a core curriculum of mathematics, English, science, and professional skills needed in a modern economy. State subsidies whipped up by Netanyahu’s coalitions encourage prolonged religious study rather than employment, perpetuating dependence across generations.

The haredim already constitute roughly one-sixth of Israel's population, with more than six children per family on average. Research published by the Bank of Israel found that public expenditure attributable to an average haredi household approaches NIS 13,000 monthly ($4,300), including benefits, subsidies, and government services. The incentive structure perpetuates economic dependence.

Israel cannot indefinitely sustain this model as the community becomes an ever-larger share of the population. This is a house of cards that will collapse – and the process will accelerate if productive Israelis conclude there is no solution and simply leave.

The remedies are well known: require a meaningful core curriculum in publicly funded schools, gradually reduce subsidies encouraging indefinite yeshiva study, and reward employment and economic independence while protecting poor families.

Anyone expecting these reforms through pleasant dialogue with rabbinical leaders misunderstands the disagreement. My conversations with haredi rabbis, including those published in The Forward, have shown me how deeply they value separation from broader society. General education and economic independence threaten their authority.

Change requires government policy, funding conditions and economic incentives, alongside support for haredim seeking greater integration.

United Torah Judaism (UTJ) head MK Yakov Asher seen attending the Knesset's Finance Committee, in Jerusalem, November 16, 2026
United Torah Judaism (UTJ) head MK Yakov Asher seen attending the Knesset's Finance Committee, in Jerusalem, November 16, 2026 (credit: MARC ISRAEL SELLEM/THE JERUSALEM POST)

For years, the hope was that a centrist government freed from Netanyahu's dependence on the haredim could finally implement these reforms. Now a government formed to replace him may perpetuate precisely the same system.

The haredi demands include funding for schools without core studies, preservation of religion-and-state arrangements and protection of institutional autonomy. Accepting them wholesale could block reform for years.

I raised this dilemma Sunday on Israel's Channel 13, debating Rafi Ben Shitrit, number two on Liberman's Yisrael Beytenu Knesset list.

Why, I asked, was his party rejecting almost contemptuously the outstretched hand of representatives of Israel's Arab citizens, who constitute a fifth of the population and were offering support at virtually no cost? After all, the haredi demands threatened the entire economic base of the country.

If even the opposition abandoned comprehensive reform, I argued, despair among productive Israelis would be enormous, potentially driving an exodus of the people on whom the country's prosperity depends.

"We are not against the Arab public, and we have nothing against civil rights and full rights for the Arab public," Ben Shitrit replied. But Arab political representatives, he said, "are not our partners and are not partners for anything."

He cited Joint List lawmakers who demonstratively leave during "Hatikvah," Israel's national anthem. "I have not heard a simple statement from the leaders of the Arab public in the Knesset that Hamas and Islamic Jihad are terrorist organizations, that they must be destroyed," he continued.

He demanded explicit recognition of Israel as the Jewish nation-state, in accordance with its Declaration of Independence. "And as long as we have not heard that from them, they are not partners."

He ignored my protestation that Ra'am had indicated its willingness to meet these conditions.

Such objections deserve consideration in a country traumatized by October 7. But insisting on agreed governing principles is fundamentally different from treating the elected representatives of one-fifth of the population as inherently unacceptable.

And what a devastating message it is to Arab citizens: Even when your representatives offer to support a government committed to democratic principles, they are unwelcome.

The message to Israel's productive and military-serving population is scarcely better. Even the parties promising change may preserve the arrangements threatening the country's future. The resulting disillusionment could be enormous.

In theory, there is a third option. Over the weekend, the Eisenkot and Netanyahu teams met to discuss a “unity government” – something Netanyahu tends to push for when he loses an election, and which he always insists on leading. The meeting broke up after one hour.

The “mandate” handed to Eisenkot by President Isaac Herzog runs out in December. Expect more jostling, because the opposition's lackluster election campaign left it in a weaker position than many had expected, facing difficult compromises.

In the end, a government including the haredim may be worth considering. But there is an enormous difference between postponing reform and committing to prevent it. Eisenkot can compromise on the pace of conscription and postpone difficult budgetary battles. He must not guarantee permanent funding for schools refusing core studies, entrench incentives discouraging employment, or accept measures gutting judicial review.

If the haredim insist, he can say he negotiated in good faith, but their conditions were unacceptable. Even Liberman might then reconsider Arab cooperation. Indeed, in betraying his promises on the draft, he has made it much more difficult for himself to run again in a new election.

He should understand, in any case, that Israel cannot indefinitely claim to be a democracy while treating Arab political participation as something to avoid at almost any cost.

And one more thing: Facing one of democracy's most destructive incumbents, the opposition ran a timid, tepid campaign. It did not work well enough. Next time, run an effective one. Incredibly, even the US Democrats finally figured out a way.

The writer is the former Cairo-based Middle East editor and London-based Europe/Africa editor of the Associated Press, the former chairman of the Foreign Press Association in Jerusalem, and publisher of danperry.substack.com

View the original on The Jerusalem Post →

KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.