‘Hindsight is a wonderful thing’: The draft selections your club would want over
For all the deep-dive physical and mental analysis that AFL recruiting departments conduct on prospective recruits, drafting remains an inexact science.
While clubs have plenty of hits, there are misses. We take a look at selections that didn’t quite work out since 2011, when Gold Coast joined the competition.
Adelaide
The choice: 2019. Fischer McAsey (pick six) over Caleb Serong (pick eight), Kysaiah Pickett (pick 12) and Cody Weightman (pick 15).
The fallout: Adelaide took the highly rated Vic Metro backman (he was named Vic Metro’s player of the 2019 championships ahead of Matt Rowell and Noah Anderson) during a major rebuild, hoping he would emerge as a key intercept defender. However, McAsey struggled to have an impact, managing just 10 games before quitting after the 2023 campaign, later acknowledging he lost the “spark” in his final two years. “For whatever reason, I didn’t feel good going into training a lot of the time,” McAsey said. Meanwhile, Serong is one of Fremantle’s prime movers, Pickett one of the stars of the game, while Weightman has had injury issues but is still considered one of the best small forwards in the league.
Brisbane Lions
The choice: 2015. Josh Schache (pick two) over Harry McKay (pick 10) and Charlie Curnow (pick 12).
The fallout: Schache, whose late father Laurence played for the Brisbane Bears in the early 1990s, was drafted with high expectations as a marquee key forward, the Murray Bushrangers product seen as a successor to Jonathan Brown. But he managed only 27 games for the Lions before he was traded to the Western Bulldogs in the dying stages of the 2017 trade period for picks 25 and 40. He logged 45 games in five seasons for the Dogs, and four with Melbourne, never fulfilling his high draft billing. Eventual Coleman medallists McKay and Curnow were snapped by Carlton, and remain key pieces with the Blues and Sydney, respectively.
Carlton
The choices: 2017. Paddy Dow (pick three) over Luke Davies-Uniacke (pick four) and Aaron Naughton (pick nine); 2017. Lochie O’Brien (pick 10) over Zac Bailey (pick 15), Ed Richards (pick 16) and Jack Higgins (pick 17).
The fallout: Carlton hoped Dow and O’Brien would form part of a premiership midfield alongside Patrick Cripps. It wasn’t to be. Dow was rated by several clubs as an explosive inside midfielder, but club insiders soon noted he struggled with ball use, decision-making and an ability to dominate at stoppages under changing coaching regimes. He played 73 games in six seasons and added 10 games in three seasons at St Kilda, where he battled illness and injury. O’Brien could use the ball, but had trouble finding it. After 66 games, he was axed in 2023. Meanwhile, Davies-Uniacke has emerged as one of the game’s best midfielders, Naughton is a forward pillar with the Western Bulldogs, while Bailey and Richards are guns.
Collingwood
The choices: 2013. Nathan Freeman (pick 10) over Patrick Cripps (pick 13) and Dom Sheed (pick 11); 2023. Harry DeMattia (pick 25) over Logan Morris (pick 31).
The fallout: The Magpies used the compensation pick for losing free agent Dale Thomas on Freeman, an explosive midfielder highly rated by several clubs. However, chronic hamstring injuries derailed his career, and he did not play a senior game before shifting to St Kilda, where he managed just two games in three years. Cripps became a dual Brownlow Medallist and Carlton captain, and remains one of the faces of the competition.
Meanwhile, the DeMattia pick remains a selection of reflection for the Magpies. He was taken as a successor to wingman Steele Sidebottom, the one-time star junior cricketer learning Sidebottom’s running patterns in the VFL. However, he has battled injuries, has yet to play a senior game, and has watched other draftees vault ahead. Morris, meanwhile, emerged as a goal-kicking star in Brisbane’s premiership hat-trick. The Magpies had hoped to trade picks with St Kilda and Richmond to secure Logan in the early 30s, but that plan failed when the Lions pounced.
Essendon
The choice: 2015. Aaron Francis (pick six) over Harry McKay (pick 10), Charlie Curnow (pick 12) and Daniel Rioli (pick 15).
The fallout: South Australian Francis was considered the best utility in his draft year, but spent the majority of his career in defence. He played only 54 games for the Bombers, battling injury and mental health issues before he was traded to Sydney at the end of 2022. He had three more seasons with the Swans, playing 30 games. McKay and Curnow, after their own injury issues, have been two of the premier forwards of the past decade, while dashing playmaker Rioli became a three-time Richmond premiership player.
Fremantle
The choice: 2016. Griffin Logue (pick eight) over Shai Bolton (pick 29).
The fallout: The Dockers did well in the ’16 draft, picking up ruckman Sean Darcy, All-Australian defender Luke Ryan and key defender Brennan Cox. But it was top pick Logue that they would have wanted more from. He wasn’t a bust, playing 64 games, but struggled to have the impact he wanted in defence, where the Dockers had depth. In the case of Bolton, all is well that ends well, the Dockers securing the two-time premiership Tiger in a trade in 2024. He won Norm Smith Medal in this year’s losing grand final side.
Geelong
The choice: 2019. Cooper Stephens (pick 16) over Chad Warner (pick 39).
The fallout: Stephens, a big-bodied midfielder, played just the seven games for the Cats, before he was traded to the Hawks after the 2022 campaign as part of a three-way deal that had Ollie Henry move to Geelong and Tom Mitchell to Collingwood. He did not play a game for the Hawks. Warner, meanwhile, has played 130 games for the Swans, becoming one of the competition’s most dynamic midfielders. However, he was one of five players suspended by the club late last season for breaching behavioural standards.
Gold Coast
The choices: 2016. Jack Scrimshaw (pick seven) over Shai Bolton (pick 29); 2020. Elijah Hollands (pick 7) over Max Holmes (pick 20) and Jake Bowey (pick 21).
The fallout: Scrimshaw played just four games in two seasons for the Suns before being sent to Hawthorn for a future third-round pick – a prime example of the Suns’ retention and draft-evaluation struggles at the time. The dashing Bolton is a dual premiership player with Richmond, and continues to star with Fremantle.
Hollands did not play a game in 2020, having torn his ACL, but the Suns remained high on the son of former Richmond player Ben. However, poor form and struggles off the field restricted him to only 14 games in three seasons. Traded to the Blues, who were desperate for a classy linkman, he managed 33 games in three seasons, his career over after a mental health episode against Collingwood.
Greater Western Sydney
The choice: 2014. Jarrod Pickett over Jordan De Goey (pick five), Peter Wright (pick eight), Lachie Weller (pick 13) and Jake Lever (pick 14).
The fallout: “GWS strike rich” was one of the headlines after the Giants, still in their infancy, took Pickett, Caleb Marchbank (pick six) and Paul Ahern (pick seven) in the ’14 draft. Within two years, all had left after a combined total of seven senior games, all by Marchbank. Pickett later managed 17 games in three years with the Blues. De Goey went on to play in the Magpies’ 2023 premiership, and has been a match-winning forward-midfielder. Lever is a premiership defender with Melbourne, while Wright remains at Essendon. Weller is with the Suns.
Hawthorn
The choice: 2020. Denver Grainger-Barras (pick six) over Max Holmes (pick 20).
The fallout: The Hawks haven’t had the best of luck with selection six in the national draft (think Beau Dowler and Mitch Thorp) and Grainger-Barras added to this, the defender/forward from Swan Districts battling injury, including surgery for turf toe, and managing 28 games in four seasons before he was delisted. Holmes, meanwhile, has become one of the league’s elite midfielders, but unfortunately missed the Cats’ 2022 premiership because of injury.
Melbourne
The choices: 2012. Jimmy Toumpas (pick four) over Ollie Wines (pick seven); 2015. Sam Weideman (pick nine) over Charlie Curnow (pick 12) and Harry McKay (pick 10).
The fallout: During a rugged era for the Demons, they took the hard-running Toumpas from Woodville-West Torrens ahead of contested-ball beast Wines, who went on to become a Brownlow medallist with Port Adelaide. Current league recruiters maintain Toumpas was rated ahead of Wines at the time. Toumpas played just 27 games for the Demons before he was traded, later acknowledging he had not been tough enough in the contest. “Hindsight is a wonderful thing,” one AFL club recruiter said.
Weideman, a third-generation AFL player, was not the imposing forward the Demons had sought, managing 59 games before he was traded to Essendon after the 2022 season. The Blues, meanwhile, snapped up eventual Coleman medallists McKay and Curnow, forming their forward spine for several seasons before the latter left for Sydney.
North Melbourne
The choices: 2020. Will Phillips (pick three) over Logan McDonald (pick four), Max Holmes (pick 20) and Jake Bowey (pick 21); 2023. Zane Duursma (pick four) over Nick Watson (pick five) and Logan Morris (pick 31).
The fallout: The pandemic-impacted draft has produced several busts, or first-round selections that never really got going. The Kangaroos were rebuilding their midfield, and wanted to build “from inside out”. Phillips was a natural leader and already trained like a pro, but had setbacks early - he suffered COVID-19, and had two bouts of glandular fever. He struggled to win a regular senior game, managing 50 in four seasons before being axed. McDonald continues to be an important part of the Swans’ forward line, Holmes is a midfield star with Geelong, while Bowey is a premiership player and reliable small defender.
Duursma never really got going at Arden St. He failed to win a regular spot under former coach Alastair Clarkson, managing 38 games in three seasons, and admitted to struggling to deal with expectations and handling online criticism. He is now at Melbourne. Watson, meanwhile, has blossomed into one of the game’s stars, while Morris, like Duursma, a key forward, is a three-time premiership Lion.
Port Adelaide
The choices: 2012. Mason Shaw (pick 30) ahead of Kamdyn McIntosh (pick 31), Mason Wood (pick 41) and Tim Membrey (pick 46); 2021. Josh Sinn (pick 12) over Leek Aleer (pick 15), Jacob van Rooyen (pick 19) and Marcus Windhager (pick 47).
The fallout: The Power were after a key forward and strong mark, and Shaw fit that bill, despite being lightly built. He booted 106 goals in 31 games for South Fremantle’s Colts side, highlighting his goal sense, and added 20 kilograms of muscle in his first two seasons at Alberton. However, battling a groin issue, he did not play a senior game and was delisted in 2015 when the Power traded for Charlie Dixon. McIntosh went on to be a dual premiership player with the Tigers, while Wood and Membrey are still plying their trade.
The Power opted for athletic Sandringham Dragons product Sinn to strengthen their back line. However, the booming left-foot kick took time to get going (10 matches in his first three seasons) but played 20 games in 2025, replacing Dan Houston as a rebounding defender, before a shoulder reconstruction ruined his ’26 campaign. The Power hope a strong 2027 will fully justify their original selection.
Richmond
The choices: 2013. Ben Lennon (pick 12) over Patrick Cripps (pick 13); 2014. Corey Ellis (pick 12) over Jake Lever (pick 14), Jack Steele (pick 24) and Touk Miller (pick 29).
The fallout: The Tigers drafted Lennon to be a multipurpose weapon, with the ability to play in defence, through the midfield and up forward. Recruiting manager Francis Jackson said the Northern Knight was “an outstanding mark for his size”, and “with the footy in hand, he is extremely dangerous with his decision-making and excellent foot skills”. However, Lennon later conceded he had struggled with the rigours of professional football, morphing from a “bubbly kid” to a “dull, paranoid 22-year-old”. His confidence took a major hit when he was dropped for the 2014 elimination final a week after being named the league’s Rising Star of the week. By the end of 2017, with 21 games to his credit, Lennon’s career was over. As for Cripps, we all know what he has done.
Jackson was full of praise for the silky left-footer from the Western Jets, declaring he was “one of the best kicks and decision-makers in the draft”. The Tigers believed he would add to a growing list of classy midfielders, and he was likened to Nick Dal Santo and Steele Sidebottom. But injuries restricted Ellis to only 27 senior games in four seasons at Punt Rd. He added four more with the Suns before being delisted in 2020. Lever became a premiership defender with Melbourne; Steele, at his third club, remains a strong midfielder with Melbourne; while Miller continues to be a dynamic playmaker with the Suns.
St Kilda
The choices: 2013. Jack Billings (pick three) over Marcus Bontempelli (pick four); 2014: Paddy McCartin (pick one) over Christian Petracca (pick two).
The fallout: The Saints’ trajectory may have changed dramatically had they taken “the Bont”. Instead, they opted for the silky, wing/half-forward from the Oakleigh Chargers over the booming 192cm midfielder whose late-season growth spurt at the Northern Knights left recruiters scratching their heads. “The 18-year-old hunts the footy relentlessly and rarely wastes a possession. While he is elusive and skilful on the outside, his work in the clinches is equally valuable and complements a body which looks ready-made for AFL football,” the Saints said of Billings at the time. Billings had a respectable career, managing 155 games for the Saints, and 17 with Melbourne, but Bontempelli is one of the greats of the game, a premiership hero, a three-time AFLPA MVP, eight-time All-Australian and seven-time Charles Sutton medallist.
Then in 2014, desperate for a replacement for club great Nick Riewoldt, the Saints went for a key forward despite internal medical issues about McCartin. He would have eight concussions, limiting him to just 35 games for the club. Petracca, meanwhile, became a premiership great, Norm Smith medallist, and one of the best midfielders in the game.
Sydney
The choices: 2019. Dylan Stephens (pick five) ahead of Hayden Young (pick seven), Caleb Serong (pick eight), Tom Green (pick 10) and Will Day (pick 13); 2017. Matt Ling (pick 14) ahead of Zac Bailey (15), Ed Richards (16) and Jack Higgins (17).
The fallout: Stephens, now at North Melbourne, has carved out a productive career, but the Swans would have hoped for more because of his draft position. The elite-running midfielder from SANFL club Norwood managed 43 games with the Swans, before he was traded to Arden St after the 2023 campaign. The Swans had four picks inside the top 40 of the 2019 draft – their best being Chad Warner (39). Young (Fremantle), Serong (Fremantle), Green (GWS) and Day (Hawthorn) remain key players.
The Swans picked Geelong Falcon Ling to add midfield speed, declaring he was “lightning-quick and has a pinpoint left-foot kick”. But toe and Achilles injuries derailed his opening two seasons. He debuted in 2020, yet his career was over by the end of the 2021 campaign after just four senior games. As for Bailey, Richards and Higgins, they continue to enjoy profitable careers.
West Coast
The choice: 2017. Jarrod Brander (pick 13) over Zac Bailey (pick 15), Ed Richards (16) and Tim Kelly (24).
The fallout: Brander, from the Bendigo Pioneers, had originally been tied to GWS’ academy, but when that region was restructured, one of the best young key-position players in the country was available. The Eagles had high hopes, but Brander managed just 22 games in four seasons, before wanting to explore his options. He logged five senior games with GWS, but his AFL career was over after the 2022 campaign. Bailey, meanwhile, is a three-time Brisbane premiership player, Richards is a star midfielder/half-back, while Kelly is an elite midfielder.
Western Bulldogs
The choice: 2015. Kieran Collins (pick 26) over Blake Hardwick (pick 44) and Jordan Dawson (pick 56).
The fallout: Collins was ranked by recruiters among the top two or three key defenders in the 2015 draft, with the Bulldogs even claiming he was in their mix for the pick 11 spot. The All-Australian junior had attracted interest from Carlton and Hawthorn, the Dogs declaring they were surprised he had fallen to 26th. However, by the end of 2018, and with only one senior game to his credit, Collins’ AFL career was over. Hardwick, meanwhile, remains one of the league’s best medium-sized defenders who can go forward, while Dawson is the Crows’ skipper and one of the game’s premier midfielders.
Keep up to date with the best AFL coverage in the country. Sign up for the Real Footy newsletter.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.