Netanyahu's claim of Arab parties stealing election haunts unity talks with Eisenkot - analysis
On Election Day, the scandal was that someone was allegedly paying off Arab voters. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu seized on the arrests of three Ra’am activists in the Negev, warned that the election was being stolen, and urged his supporters to get to the polls. Two days later, a separate inquiry into suspected foreign interference became public. Likud folded the two cases into a single story that purportedly explained the unprecedented Arab turnout.
The exact nature of the scandal, however, was very much in the eye of the beholder. Was the scandal an alleged plot to buy votes, or was the prime minister using those allegations to cast doubt on the integrity of an election that had cost him his majority?
Over the ensuing days, the story lost some of its steam. On Tuesday, Deputy Supreme Court President Noam Sohlberg, chairman of the Central Elections Committee, wrote that there is no evidence of bribery on the scale that would influence the election results. The three suspects arrested in the case have all been released without charges.
And then came Ilana Dayan’s report on Channel 12’s Uvda on Sunday night.
Dayan is a respected journalist. She has also been sharply critical of Netanyahu, including in the short opening monologues on her Thursday morning Army Radio show. The problem with those editorial monologues is that they ultimately color how some will view bombshell stories like these.
Source tipped off Israel Police about concerns around Ra'am activists
According to Uvda, Netanyahu’s chief of staff, Ido Norden, contacted the police commissioner’s office on the eve of the October 27 election and referred police to a source who could provide information about suspected vote-buying in the Arab sector.
KAN News identified that source as Daniel Greenberg, a former employee of the Prime Minister’s Office.
According to the reporting, the tip was entered into the police intelligence system that night. Then, just hours before the polls opened, police raided homes in Rahat and Segev Shalom, arresting three Ra’am activists. The police did not have search warrants.
Police said they recovered envelopes containing tens of thousands of shekels in cash. The suspects’ lawyers said no cash was found in one home and that the envelopes seized elsewhere contained charitable donations for low-income families.
Greenberg denied involvement in any conspiracy. He told Ynet that his tip came from a Joint List MK whom he would not name. According to Greenberg, the MK told him that “many millions of shekels” were being funneled to help Ra’am, the other Arab party in the election.
Election fraud scandal flips onto Netanyahu
So, on Sunday night, another scandal was born. Same arrests. Same envelopes. This time the question was whether someone in the PMO deliberately fed false information to the police, setting in motion the arrests that Netanyahu then used to cast suspicion on the vote of an entire sector of the population.
The shoe was suddenly on the other foot. An election-fraud allegation that was initially directed at Arab parties had turned around into a question about whether people around Netanyahu had improperly used the police on Election Day. Netanyahu had gone from accuser to accused.
There is a big difference between passing on a tip and knowingly planting false information. So which was it? And what did the police do to check the tip before making arrests just hours before the polls opened? Why did they put out a statement about the arrests a few hours later, at such a sensitive moment? The Likud and Netanyahu quickly seized on it to bolster their claim that the election was being stolen.
Police Commissioner Daniel Levy ordered an internal review on Monday. Attorney-General Gali Baharav-Miara and State Attorney Amit Aisman asked him to hold off while they determine how to examine the matter. Their intervention followed concerns that an internal police review could pose a conflict of interest.
All of this broke just hours after negotiators for Eisenkot’s Yashar and Netanyahu’s Likud met on Sunday, with Naftali Bennett’s B’Yachad also represented, to explore the possibility of forming a broad government based on the Jewish parties. For those hoping for unity, the timing was particularly inopportune.
While little was hashed out at this hour-long meeting – such as which Jewish parties would be included in such a government, who would lead it, and whether there would be a rotation – the sides said they would keep talking.
But any optimism was quickly doused by the Uvda report.
Eisenkot, Netanyahu enter back and forth of accusations
Eisenkot reacted almost immediately, calling the conduct of Netanyahu and those around him a “tangible, direct and immediate threat to Israeli democracy.” He said that “under no circumstances” should Netanyahu remain prime minister “for even one more minute,” and that Israel must never go into another election with him in office. He called for an immediate investigation and said he would work to establish a commission of inquiry.
Likud fired back that Netanyahu’s aide had done what the law required of him to prevent a crime. The party accused Eisenkot and the left-wing bloc of trying to kill off any prospect of national unity and justify favoring parties it accused of supporting terrorism over Zionist parties.
Will anyone remember this story a month from now? Some stories break with a great splash only to fall apart when all the details come out. Some hold up. It will take time to make sense of this one.
But that is the problem: Eisenkot does not have the time to wait and see how it all plays out. He has a firm deadline by which he must form a coalition or pass the mandate back to the president, who will then likely give Netanyahu a chance to form a government.
The clock is ticking on Eisenkot's mandate
Eisenkot’s initial mandate runs through December 6. If President Isaac Herzog gives him the full two-week extension, he has until December 20.
He has essentially three options: a minority government made up of his change bloc with outside support from the Arab parties; a slim coalition of 61 with the haredi (ultra-Orthodox) parties; or a unity government with the Likud and Religious Zionist Party (and possibly the haredi parties).
A rotation with Netanyahu was already hard enough for Eisenkot to explain to some of his supporters. Now imagine him explaining why he would agree to leave Netanyahu in the PMO while authorities are still trying to establish what people in that office did on Election Day.
The story may fade in a month. Eisenkot, however, may have to decide whether to make a deal while it’s still making headlines, and this scandal du jour is not exactly the stuff of which unity is formed.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.