Teachers want to prepare pupils for post-16 life. This is why it’s so difficult | Lola Okolosie

At 16, life should feel like a path leading to endless opportunities. That is at least the carrot dangled in front of young people to motivate them through the gruelling years of exam preparation. “Your life starts now,” their teachers all but tell them. And though for the vast majority that is true, there is a cohort who are forced to accept that the bright futures they were promised are beyond their reach. They are the nearly one million young people aged between 16 and 24 who are not in education, employment or training (Neets).
Alan Milburn’s second report on the nation’s Neets places schools at the heart of the solution. It proposes that schools should be judged not only on grades but also whether pupils continue their post-16 journey into further education or work. Technical education, it also argues, must be regarded with the same gravitas as the academic. Most people working in education won’t argue with this rationale. As ever, the sticking point is how it is to be funded.
There is much to trouble teachers in Milburn’s review, but perhaps topping the list is that about 30% of Neets left school with good GCSEs or their equivalent. They did their part. They got the qualifications we drummed into them. But forgotten somewhere in the process was what we, as teachers, learned from countless interviews with prospective employers in our own youth: grades were never the full sum of our parts. Or to quote Milburn, young people must be provided with both the “aptitudes” as well as “qualifications”.
For those of us working in education, time has been one of our biggest impediments. With the GCSE curriculum being so content-heavy, anything not on the specification becomes sidelined. In practice, schools have tended to leave careers advice to a 30-minute meeting at the beginning of Year 11. Once a fixture of the Year 10, now less than half of GCSE pupils conduct work experience. This is why school leaders will no doubt welcome the report’s recommendation that at key stage 3, Years 7-9, schools should be given the power to use 10% of curriculum time as they see fit. Work experience must take up some of this freed time.
Schools should start by rethinking where to concentrate careers guidance and accept that leaving it to Years 10 and 11 is too late. At my local secondary school, a “careers carousel” is hosted each year for Year 8 pupils. Run like a freshers’ fair, pupils move from stall to stall, talking to professionals from the construction and carpentry industries, as well as office workers and nurses. It means that when GCSE options are chosen in Year 9, some pupils have a better understanding of how their choices might lead to the career goals they are beginning to set themselves.
Schools will also have to rethink how they share Year 9 subject choices with pupils. Too often, subjects can appear to have little to do with the world beyond the school gates. A Year 9 student deciding whether to choose a GCSE in food preparation and nutrition cannot always clearly see how that qualification can form the basis for an apprenticeship, degree apprenticeship or other meaningful work.
There will always be pupils who drift into listlessness because they draw a blank whenever their thoughts land on life after GCSEs. That blank is frightening and the young people who feel that fear rarely have the language to articulate it. They need an adult to ask what they would like to do when they grow up and the space to answer with a truthful shrug that they haven’t the faintest idea.
Milburn’s report recommends a “risk of Neet indicators” should be made mandatory for schools to use, or that a new test should be made statutory at key stage 3 to “identify pupils who need additional support”. Teachers might pause at this, because we already know which of our students are at risk of becoming Neet. They are pupils with special educational needs, those who will struggle to achieve grade 4 in all but a few of their GCSEs and those who, because of behaviour and poor attendance, already suspect they will “fail” and so reject the schools they believe have given them nothing. By Year 11, these are the students on reduced timetables, if they are still attending school at all. Their sense that they will be labelled disappointments is palpable in their rejection of the very corridors they feel have cemented that failure. For at-risk pupils, transition planning that starts years before a mad scramble at the end of Year 11 will only be effective if there are dedicated staff with the time to write and see the plan through.
If reached out to by Year 9, good careers advice could have those at risk open up about what interests them and the non-academic strengths that they do have. Are they great bakers? Do they have a knack for putting people at ease? Are they great with animals? Do they know an infinite amount about crochet patterns? Can they dissect the workings of an Audi Q7? Their interests and expertise are as ripe for career development as the grades they are awarded. Someone just needs the time to show them. For this to work however, schools need fully funded specialist careers leads.
after newsletter promotion
On ambition, Milburn’s report cannot be faulted. Most of its recommendations meet the scale of the challenge before us. But any teacher reading it will want to know: where is the money? Until schools are given a definitive answer, we might find the most disadvantaged young people are yet again being promised futures no one has shown them how to reach.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.