Avengers: Doomsday Vs. Dune 3: 4 Biggest Ways They Are Competing & Which Will Win

Cooper Hood is the Associate Editor for all new movie releases, in theaters and on streaming. In addition to writing articles about these titles and upcoming releases, he also oversees content planning for each, ensuring that ScreenRant continues to cover major releases for months after their release.
He has written various reviews for ScreenRant that appear on Rotten Tomatoes, coordinated Oscars and San Diego Comic-Con coverage, appeared on CNN to talk about Mission: Impossible - The Final Reckoning, and done select interviews with talent over the years.
We're officially one month away from Avengers: Doomsday and Dune: Part Three facing off for supremacy in several categories. The two sci-fi blockbusters would normally be the undisputed biggest movie hitting theaters whenever they arrived, but they've instead chosen to face off in an unprecedented battle for glory beyond just the box office by launching simultaneously worldwide on December 18, 2026.
When Disney/Marvel Studios and Warner Bros. initially each put these movies on that date, it was assumed that one would blink and move to a different date. Considering Dune 3's IMAX exclusivity, I argued for Doomsday to change release dates to secure the Premium Large Format screens for itself. Instead, Disney chose to create InfinityVision, putting the box office battle in a completely different context.
The competition, known as Dunesday, will go well beyond the box office, though. These movies will inevitably be compared in many ways due to them coming out on the same day. Their respective critical reception, impact on pop culture with general audiences, and ability to win awards are also part of the equation.
In honor of Doomsday and Dune 3's release dates being just one month away, it is the perfect time to look at where things stand for both films and gauge which movie will win in these key categories.
Avengers: Doomsday Will Win At The Box Office
Even though Doomsday was the movie most suggested should move off the December 18 date, that was never due to concerns that the Marvel Cinematic Universe event film would lose at the box office. Audiences have always flocked to the Avengers movies, and that will be no different for Doomsday, even after some more uneven years for Marvel Studios.
Avengers is simply a much bigger franchise at the box office than Dune. Every Avengers movie has made over $1.4 billion, while Denis Villeneuve and Timothée Chalamet's first two Dune movies didn't even gross that much collectively. Interest clearly hasn't died in seeing the MCU's biggest heroes, either, as Avengers Endgame: Encore's $143 million gross this year proved.
The most recent projections for Doomsday and Dune 3's opening weekends show how much of a lead Marvel has. Early tracking forecasts a $340-$410 million debut for Avengers, while Dune 3 is aiming for $91-$115 million. The latter would be a franchise record, but still not good enough for what could be an all-time domestic launch for Marvel.
Even if Doomsday's number comes in a bit lower and Dune 3's grows, the gap is too large for Villeneuve's sci-fi epic to overcome and win at the box office.
Dune 3 Will Likely Beat Avengers: Doomsday Critically
The box office crown might be out of reach, but Dune 3 is in a great position to win the critical battle. Villeneuve's previous two films have been acclaimed, with excellent direction, performances, technical qualities, and more contributing to largely glowing reviews. Dune scored an 83% on Rotten Tomatoes, but Dune: Part Two rose to 92%.
Given how great Dune 3 looks in its trailers, it's expected to score another 90+% rating with critics on the review aggregator. Villeneuve may very well deliver one of the best-reviewed movies of the year overall, which Avengers: Doomsday is almost assuredly not going to be.
There is a certain level of cynicism attached to Doomsday and Marvel fatigue that could contribute to harsher reviews. That's not to say critics will be unnecessarily negative or less forgiving out of spite for the MCU, but the positive glow that covered this franchise for most of the Infinity Saga is gone.
Despite the mixed reception to Marvel's decision to bring Anthony and Joe Russo, the directing duo have a stellar track record in this sandbox. Three of their four MCU movies scored 90% or better on Rotten Tomatoes; the lowest is Avengers: Infinity War at 85%.
Doomsday may wind up getting largely positive reviews if everything comes together nicely, but it still seems more likely that Dune 3 will be the victor in this category.
Dune 3 Is Better Positioned To Win Awards
The third film about Paul Atreides is also certainly in the lead when it comes to award considerations. The previous Dune movies have been quite successful at the Oscars and other award shows, but the Avengers franchise (and MCU overall — minus the Black Panther films) have hardly been recognized by Academy voters.
Villeneuve's last two Dune movies earned Best Picture nominations, even if he was snubbed from Best Director both times. The first film received 10 nominations and won six, while the sequel had five nominations, winning two. Dune 3 is viewed as a likely 2027 Oscars Best Picture nominee and should earn recognition across several below-the-line categories, too.
Doomsday's most realistic Oscar play will be a VFX nomination. It could earn award recognition at fan-driven shows like the MTV Movie & TV Awards or People's Choice Awards, but Dune 3 should wipe the floor with Avengers in terms of accolades otherwise.
Avengers: Doomsday & Dune 3's Toughest Battle Is Pop Culture Relevance
The box office, critical reception, and awards consideration categories are fairly easy to call, but the toughest is how they land within the grand scheme of pop culture. Both movies will be hugely popular for different reasons, as we've outlined. However, all of that will play into the perception of which is bigger and more relevant.
The winner in terms of pop culture impact will be defined by how easily the film becomes a common reference point, starts social or viral trends, inspires new memes, or has lines that become widely quoted. The Dune and Avengers movies have both done this very well in the past, with Dune 2's Lisan al-Gaib meme an example of how these films have permeated pop culture.
This one really could go either way, especially since both films' target audiences are very present online. But given the wider audience that Doomsday should have, it has a slight edge in this department. Yet, it shouldn't come as a surprise if Dune 3 winds up winning this category.
The Real Winner Of Avengers: Doomsday & Dune 3's Showdown
Which movie "wins" Dunesday will ultimately come down to what criteria each person judges the showdown on. If box office/overall popularity is the priority, Doomsday should be victorious. If overall quality, critical acclaim, and awards take precedence, Dune 3 is positioned to win.
In either case, the real winner in this scenario is movie fans. Audiences are hopefully on the cusp of seeing two great, massive blockbusters. Lots of people will see both films on their opening weekend, and they should each be quite rewarding on the big screen and play even better as communal viewings.
The expected popularity of Avengers: Doomsday and Dune: Part Three also makes theaters a bonus winner. These films will drive substantial (likely record-breaking) business across the holiday season and into 2027. They will effectively cap off an incredible year for movie theaters as millions flock to their local cinemas to see both sci-fi event films.
-
Avengers: Doomsday
- Release Date
- December 18, 2026
- Runtime
- 165 Minutes
-
Victor von Doom
-
Reed Richards / Mr. Fantastic
-
Thor
-
Vanessa Kirby
Sue Storm / Invisible Woman
Avengers: Doomsday is the fifth Avengers film and kicks off Phase 6 of the Marvel Cinematic Universe. A stacked cast of heroes both new and old to the MCU — including members of the X-Men — will face off against Victor von Doom, revealed at San Diego Comic-Con in 2024 to be played by a returning Robert Downey Jr.
-
Dune: Part Three
- Release Date
- December 18, 2026
- Runtime
- 140 Minutes
-
Paul Atreides
-
Princess Irulan
-
Alia Atreides
-
Chani
The epic adaptation of Frank Herbert's sci-fi saga continues, this time drawing from his books Dune: Messiah and Children of Dune.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.