The Guardian view on Ofsted: its damaged relationship with schools in England needs fixing | Editorial

The inspection and rating of schools is, by definition, a fraught process. There are few things that parents care more about than the education of their children. For teachers and headteachers, it is stressful and exposing to have their work judged. At a time when shrinking school rolls are leading to closures, the stakes are even higher. An unpopular school with empty places is far more likely to be asked to merge, or close, than one that is sought after by parents.
Policymakers have a tough job to strike a balance between the undeniable pressure that the watchdog places on schools in England and the benefits to families of information to aid their choices. But the coroner’s verdict on the death of Ruth Perry, a headteacher who took her own life in 2023, tipped the balance away from a system that relied too heavily on one-word judgments. The inspection that led to the downgrading of her primary school to “inadequate” was judged to have contributed to her death. In its 2024 manifesto, Labour promised to replace one-word labels with more nuanced overviews of schools’ performance.
But 12 months after the introduction of a report card to replace the old grades, Ofsted’s critics remain frustrated. The National Association of Head Teachers tried to challenge the revised framework in the high court. Two-thirds of teachers who responded to a survey said that the new inspections were as bad or worse than the old ones. In October the education secretary, Lucy Powell, said that further reforms were on the way. (After devolution in 1999, Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland rejected England’s model of school competition, academies and league tables.)

If, as expected, the framework is adjusted to take more account of a school’s context, and to ease workload pressures, that will be a good result. Analysis shows that schools in England with more deprived intakes are much less likely than schools with low deprivation to meet expected standards. This raises questions about whether inspections fairly account for the challenges facing schools in poorer areas. As well as being wrong in principle, a framework skewed against demanding socioeconomic conditions has practical effects, lowering morale in schools that are judged to be underachieving, and potentially making it harder for them to recruit staff.
The Department for Education and Ofsted must take responsibility for such missteps, and for an inspection regime that many now find more onerous. Advocates of more radical reforms, whose goal is a less adversarial alternative to Ofsted, should be listened to as part of this process. Peer review between schools can be a constructive route to improvement. Local authorities already monitor standards in the schools they oversee, as do academy trusts – although their highly uneven results offer some of the best evidence of the need for an independent inspectorate with a focus on governance as well as other aspects. Resource pressures must also be considered; the current level of funding does not enable the kind of exchange between inspectors and schools that some would like.
It is shocking and tragic that Ofsted needed a coroner’s warning to seemingly recognise its duty to treat school staff with courtesy and respect. The new framework, evidence suggests, remains flawed. Ms Powell must ensure that inspections help schools improve, rather than merely find fault.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.