The Jerusalem PostActivists rally at Erez Crossing against Gaza aid deliveries, accuse Israel of strengthening HamasInquirerWalang Pasok: Class suspensions on Friday, Nov. 20PunchEPL: My ex-agent blocked dream move to Arsenal – MudrykSky TG24Pagine, la rassegna stampa di Sky Tg24 del 20 novembreInquirer EntertainmentBINI members fangirl over BTS at Taiwan concertRTL BoulevardTwee gewonden na felle brand op zolder van rijtjeshuis in DelftCNN TürkGÜMÜŞ FİYATLARI NEDEN DÜŞÜYOR? 20 Kasım Gümüş Gram Fiyatı Ne? Gram Gümüş ve Ons Gümüşte Sert KayıpStraits Times SportLoh Kean Yew bows out of Hong Kong Open after q-final defeat by India’s Lakshya SenWirtualna PolskaZawyły syreny. Rodzice pytali, czy posyłać dzieci do szkółZDF heuteEntdecken Sie das ZDF-NachrichtenstudioSRF NewsKrankenkassenprämien – Veraltete Prämienregionen: Die Ungerechtigkeit bleibtObservador DesportoSó 13% dos PPR conseguiram superar a inflação em cinco anos
The Daily Newsstand · Free, Always
Friday, November 20, 2026

Controversial birthing model abandoned after community backlash

Translate

The trial of a birthing model at two SA Mid North hospitals has been abandoned one month after it began, following a community backlash. 

The planned six-month trial by the Yorke and Northern Local Health Network (YNLHN) entailed a one-team, one-site birthing model that would see services alternate between the Jamestown and Crystal Brook hospitals. 

The local health network today announced it would discontinue the trial, after local clinicians this week advised they would not participate. 

A hospital car park with a tall sign that reads "Jamestown Hospital".

The hospitals at Jamestown and Crystal Brook were involved in the trial. (ABC North & West SA)

Local GPs wrote to the health minister when the trial began in October with "urgent concern" about the changes, which they said restricted doctors from simultaneously providing maternity and emergency on-call roles, while complicating and heaping pressure on clinical handovers.

YNLHN governing board chair John Voumard said the trial had been put in place to address workforce shortages and non-compliance with SA Health rostering requirements at the two hospitals, which he said were the only sites in the state that did not comply. 

John Voumard, wearing a suit, sits at a desk, looking at the camera.

John Voumard says the change could lead to more frequent diversions of birthing services. (ABC North & West SA)

"The risk aspect that was not acceptable to the governing board was that we must have compliant medical rosters, and that requires five doctors per site, per roster, 365 days a year," Mr Voumard said.

Both sites will continue offering birthing services, but only when they meet the rostering requirement.

The trial began on October 12, and was only in effect during weekends. 

Staffing issues

Chief industrial officer of the South Australian Salaried Medical Officers Association (SASMOA), Bernadette Mulholland, said the local practitioners did not agree with the network's "rostering position".

She said SASMOA would be writing to the YNLHN to say that the rosters were "unsustainable".

"It is being determined by the GPs that they will return to the previous rostering practices, and they expect the support of the YNLHN," she said.

"It will be up to the YNLHN leadership to make those doctors understand why it is important to have 10 doctors on at the same time. It doesn't seem conceivable by those expert doctors as to why these arrangements continue."

Mr Voumard said he was "disappointed" the local clinicians had decided not to participate in the trial. 

"When that [workforce] pressure can't be addressed through supplementation with locum workforce, there will be short-notice diversions.   

"The rostering requirements will not change.

"The community has chosen to go back to the previous system, with all its uncertainty for birthing families. That will not change unless we have an influx of midwives and doctors wanting to work in Crystal Brook and Jamestown."

SA Health paused birthing services at the hospitals for one month in June, citing a workforce shortage. 

There were a total of 41 birthing service diversions from Jamestown and Crystal Brook between July 2025 and June 2026. 

Birthing backflip

The change follows weeks of community advocacy against the birthing-model trial, including a petition which closed today, having attracted more than 10,000 signatures in two weeks.

Local private midwife Chrissy Mackinnon said she was "absolutely thrilled" by the change.

"It doesn't matter how they've listened, but they have listened," she said.

"If it's been the petitions, the hundreds of letters written into them, the media campaign, the papers, the radio, I don't know what, but something finally has got through to them that we're not happy.

A piece of paper with blank boxes for a petition. A pen is on top.

The petition attracted more than 10,000 signatures. (ABC North & West SA)

"It has just been an incredible support of community for their health services. How blessed we are in this region to have such permanent, residential, caring, compassionate people that work in health."

Not the end

Member for Stuart Geoff Brock said he would still table the petition in parliament next week, seeking an "investigation" into the matter.  

He said there was a "lack of confidence" from the community in the YNLHN board and its operation. 

"The communities out there were very, very frustrated with the lack of clear communication from the board," Mr Brock said. 

Geoff Brock speaks at a press conference.

Geoff Brock says "common sense" has prevailed. (ABC News: Rory McClaren)

Ms Mackinnon agreed the lack of communication was a big issue. 

"How could we all be just happily going along until one day … it came out in the paper that this was all changing and we all found out from the newspaper,"

she said.

Mr Voumard said communication with expectant mothers could have been better, but said the wider community concerns were "based on misinformation".

"I regret that the community has been put through the level of anxiety, which was completely unnecessary," he said.

"It was not a decision that you would consult communities about, as to whether or not you would follow an SA Health policy."

View the original on ABC News (Australia) →

KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.