Unfortunately, Hannah & Dean’s Story Is More Frustrating In Chicago Med Season 12

Laura Hurley has been writing about the entertainment industry for more than twelve years, after a decade as a content producer and editor at CinemaBlend after writing for WhatCulture and Examiner. Attending events like SCAD TVfest and San Diego Comic-Con over the course of her career, she has been immersed in the world of network, streaming, and cable TV.
Warning: This article contains spoilers for Chicago Med season 12, episode 7, "Borders and Battle Lines."Chicago Med rarely delivers fully functional relationships for the hospital's doctors and nurses, and even the best can end in tragedy. The main romance of season 12 hasn't involved any heartbreak or tragedy yet, but "Borders and Battle Lines" served up a twist that just complicates the couple's dynamic all over again. Just when it started to seem like smooth sailing, one of the two raised the stakes so enormously that the fallout is likely to be messy, based on how One Chicago has handled their story in the past.
Hannah Asher and Dean Archer have one of the most unconventional relationships in the history of Chicago Med, and not just because their romance evolved despite an age gap of more than 20 years. Archer originally didn't even want Hannah to come back to Gaffney due to her drug problem, and the medical drama spent years developing their bond into one of One Chicago's most solid friendships. Hannah even had a moment of vehemently denying the very idea of a romance with Archer while talking to his son, Sean, who also happens to be her own age.
Then, an off-screen night together and an unexpected pregnancy complicated their dynamic all over again. Hannah's pregnancy did force them to face some issues head-on, like the age difference and whether they should attempt a romantic relationship along with co-parenting. By the end of episode 7 in NBC's fall 2026 schedule, Hannah made a grand gesture that could turn their functional little family unit into something totally different—and that may not be a good thing.
Dean & Hannah's Chicago Med Situation Is More Frustrating Than Before
Archer was technically the first to propose a big change in "Borders and Battle Lines," when he suggested he should move in with Hannah and Mabel rather than renew his apartment lease. Hannah found a reason to leave rather than continue the conversation, which was clearly not how he intended things to go.
As it turned out, all she needed to completely change her mind about committing to a future was an incredibly stressful case, and she asked him to marry her in the final moments of the episode. If not for what happened in that case of the week, Hannah proposing could have been a beautiful step forward for a character who was nervous about her future with Archer, and the fact that he didn't answer before the credits rolled wouldn't have been troubling.
Even though Chicago Med is usually as procedural with medical cases as Chicago Fire is with emergencies and Chicago P.D. with crimes, Hannah's patient of the week was absolutely a factor in her proposal to Archer. She and Dr. Frost treated a woman with lupus, but the diagnosis wasn't her only problem. Her husband had only hours to get on a plane back to Scotland because he hadn't yet been approved for a green card to stay in the United States full-time. If he didn't leave in time, he'd overstay his visa and lose his chance at staying permanently.
Despite promising his wife that he'd leave her to get on that plane, he couldn't bring himself to abandon her when her life was on the line. Even though they'd be split apart moving forward, they had each other for that moment. The husband's decision to stay was beautiful but tragic.
Seeing the couple make the most of what little time they had left motivated Hannah to propose, which she probably wouldn't have done if she'd slept on it. She may love Archer, but she went from balking at the idea of him moving in to asking him to marry her in less than a day. There are more complications than whether they love each other, and they'll likely cause problems if he says yes. Suffice it to say that Chicago Med ending its biggest storyline in episode 7 has set up a complicated new one.
What Is The Best Future For Dean & Hannah In Chicago Med?
Once upon a time, the best future for Archer and Hannah might have been to go back to their strong friendship and continue with the co-parenting plan. As soon as he confessed his feelings to an exhausted, freshly postpartum Hannah in the season 11 finale, however, simple friendship was off the table. Either Hannah was going to reciprocate, or they'd be starting their co-parenting journey on a very awkward note.
Their romance going well in the first several episodes of season 12 proved that they could work out as a couple, and their relationship was fully stable for the first time since Hannah realized she was pregnant. Settling into a status quo worked wonders for making them less frustrating, and developing their relationship in baby steps worked well. Hannah inviting him to move in after he'd mentioned it made sense as the next step; getting married when they're parents of a newborn and haven't spent much time as a couple is too much, too soon.
If Chicago Med intends to deliver a wedding for Hannah and Archer, then the medical drama needs to slow down and let them earn that future as a couple. How Archer responds to her proposal is the key to what happens next, and One Chicago fans will find out whether they're on the same page in the fall finale in December. The long-awaited return of Connor Rhodes may mean that there's not much time to devote to Hannah and Archer.
- Release Date
- November 17, 2015
- Network
- NBC
- Showrunner
- Michael Brandt
- Directors
- Michael Waxman, Michael Pressman, Charles S. Carroll, Milena Govich, Anna Dokoza, Bethany Rooney, Fred Berner, Tess Malone, Mykelti Williamson, SJ Main Muñoz, Donald Petrie, Martha Mitchell, Vincent Misiano, Timothy Busfield, Jonathan Brown, John Polson, Stephen Cragg, Anthony Nardolillo, Michael Berry, David Rodriguez, Afia Nathaniel, Oz Scott, Valerie Weiss, Gonzalo Amat
- Writers
- Joseph Sousa, Lily Dahl, Natalie Drayer, Darin Goldberg, Shelley Meals, Melissa R. Byer, Treena Hancock, Mary Leah Sutton, Simran Baidwan, Joshua Hale Fialkov, Jason Cho, Will Pascoe, Liz Brixius
-
Marlyne Barrett
Maggie Lockwood
-
S. Epatha Merkerson
Sharon Goodwin
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.