InquirerHealth advocates push funding for smoke-free, vape-free billBollywood HungamaEXCLUSIVE: IMPPA denies legal setback in Nikhil Dwivedi’s Saffron Magicworks dispute, clarifies Bombay High Court order was passed by consentPunchAtiku knocks defence ministry for promoting APC campaign rally on social mediaThe Jerusalem PostBoard of Peace: Israeli steps could pave way for Hamas disarmamentCapital FMGachagua gives IEBC Jan ultimatum, threatens mass action over election concernsVanguardABUAD warns students against cultism, cybercrimeSportstarIndia A vs Pakistan A LIVE score, Rising Stars Asia Cup 2026: PAK-A 234/4 (35); Hasan reaches fifty, Samad run outCNN بالعربيةإدانات خليجية للهجوم الإيراني على البحرين.. ماذا قالت السعودية والكويت وقطر والإمارات؟Rai NewsSerie A, Juventus-Venezia 2-0: sblocca Woltemade al 53', raddoppia Koopmeiners al 59'CNN Brasil“Não acreditem em tudo que vocês leem na internet”, diz Mariah Carey no RioMyJoyOnlineIllegal mining, destructive fishing threaten inland fisheries – Vice PresidentANSA SportSerie A: Juventus-Venezia in campo 2-0 DIRETTA
The Daily Newsstand · Free, Always
Sunday, November 22, 2026

China has real economic troubles, ‘Japanification’ not among them

Translate

If one manifestation of the economic difficulties Japan faced from the 1990s was falling inflation and bond yields, then China is falling into the same malaise.

Starting with longer maturities, interest rates on government debt in China have been falling below equivalents in Japan. The People’s Bank of China’s recent announcement of an overnight policy rate of 1.25 per cent brings the process close to completion. Japan’s rate, already at 1.25 per cent, is highly likely to be raised in the coming months.

But while China’s economy faces real difficulties, comparisons with Japan’s deflationary experience are misleading.

Both have suffered real-estate implosions, but so have many other economies, few of which went on to experience the long-lasting economic malaise that afflicted Japan. With companies still borrowing, the currency cheap and exports booming, China is unlikely to either.

China’s economic slowdown after 2020 has been dramatic. The pandemic and related policy response occurred as one shock, interacting with a second, the “three red lines” policy aimed at controlling property developer debt.

Economic growth has slowed but the bigger shift has been in inflation. The consumer price index has risen by more than 1 per cent in just four months since end-2022. The gross domestic product deflator – a broad measure of prices – has been negative for 12 of the last 14 quarters. This is the context for the steady fall in interest rates.

00:45

China’s ‘golden week’ draws large crowds despite weak consumer spending

But while China is seeing some of the symptoms, it isn’t suffering the broad-based malaise experienced in Japan. One popular way of characterising “Japanification” is a balance sheet recession, with Exhibit A being a shift in corporate behaviour from borrowing and investing in factories to instead saving and paying off debt. But in China in 2024 – three years into the property collapse – companies were still borrowing the equivalent of 8 per cent of GDP.

Focusing on just one dynamic is a simplification. Fortunately, the Bank of Japan in 2024 produced a comprehensive report examining the country’s deflationary experience. From that, we can tease out a list of 15 factors that contributed to Japanification, from demographics to rising import penetration. Using this as a report card, I estimate that China scores just 30 per cent.

By starting its analysis mainly in 1995, the BOJ didn’t focus on one of the big causes of Japan’s problems: yen strength. It is widely known that Japan’s currency appreciated sharply in the second half of the 1980s. It is often forgotten that its rise didn’t slow in the first half of the 1990s. In the 10 years to 1995, the yen appreciated by about 170 per cent in real terms, undermining competitiveness and adding downward pressure on domestic prices.

China’s currency has appreciated in nominal terms since 2020, but only by a little over 10 per cent. That has been more than offset by deflation, and as a result, the yuan in real effective terms – which is what matters for global competitiveness – has depreciated, and is now as low as any time since 2013.

To put this differently, Japan was already an expensive place when the bubble burst, and by 1995 had become pricier still. China wasn’t expensive in 2021, and is now yet cheaper.

01:16

Why are Japan’s claw machines offering groceries as prizes?

With real interest rates rising and the yen appreciating, Japan in the 1990s faced a double whammy as both the domestic and external sectors hit a wall. Today, while China’s domestic economy is suffering, its export sector is booming. In volume terms, China’s global market share is increasing almost as quickly as it did in the heyday of globalisation before the 2008 global financial crisis.

SCMP Plus is a new premium news platform that gives you an

all-inclusive edge to stay ahead on China news.

To access our exclusive content you’ll need to subscribe.

Already a subscriber?

LOG IN

The rise in exports is supporting economic growth. The impact may not be so great as to create the 4-5 per cent expansion rate the government is reporting. But with exports rising, it is unlikely that growth momentum has evaporated. That also offers a contrast with Japan, where the natural nominal interest rate from the 1990s fell towards zero, limiting the scope for conventional monetary policy to combat deflation.

Continued growth in China’s manufacturing and exports does have side effects for the rest of the world; the intensifying debate around the yuan’s undervaluation is valid. And exports are not a cure-all for China’s problems. With domestic demand so weak, manufacturing expansion adds to deflationary pressure. China’s economy would be performing better if policy did more to address the weakness in domestic demand caused by the property collapse.

But that isn’t the same as saying China is sinking into a Japan-style, generational funk. Corporate borrowing, international competitiveness and the sources of growth look very different.

While 1990s Japan faced the challenge of a dramatic loss of international price competitiveness, China’s weakness is coinciding with an extraordinary expansion in global market share. The economic problems China is experiencing don’t amount to Japanification.

View the original on South China Morning Post →

KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.