Abby Choi murder trial: ex-in-laws blame each other as 2 accounts of killing emerge


Kwong, a former police sergeant, insisted he had forgotten how and why he had carved up and boiled his former daughter-in-law’s remains with carrots and radishes before asking his elder son to dispose of them.
“I cannot remember,” the 69-year-old said when the prosecutor questioned how he had severed the legs of the deceased. “At the time, my mental condition was reaching the point of a breakdown. How could I remember so much?”
Anthony, 35, conceded that all three accused had made up a litany of lies, from providing bogus reasons for renting a rural village flat and borrowing a car to transport equipment, to sidelining the model’s chauffeur under false pretences and concocting a fictitious account of Choi’s killing to minimise the damage to the Kwong family.
Explaining his decision to delete his call records with his father, he said: “Because at that time the incident happened, I wanted to cover up for my family. I wanted to protect my family. I wanted to erase everything related to the incident.”
Meanwhile, Alex made various claims regarding what he called his “complicated” triangular relationship between him, Choi and his former schoolmate, Chris Tam Fong-chun.
The 31-year-old insisted that Choi started a new relationship with Tam only because of his family’s wealth, and that the model had remained romantically and sexually involved with him after their divorce and up until her death.
The defendant testified that Tam, whose father founded the popular TamJai Yunnan Mixian restaurant chain, harboured feelings for him and once bought him a bowl of rice noodles as a romantic gift.
Choi’s ex-husband further stated that he began a sexual relationship with Choi as soon as they started dating when they were 14, and that she helped with his thefts of HK$6.29 million worth of gold and jewellery between 2013 and 2015.
The prosecution alleges that Kwong Kau enlisted his sons to help kill Choi and destroy evidence after the 28-year-old insisted on selling a HK$72 million flat at the Kadooria development in Ho Man Tin, which she had bought and registered in his name.
Alex allegedly killed his ex-wife with a hammer while Anthony drove them to pick up the former couple’s daughter from school on February 21, 2023.
Anthony and his father allegedly dismembered and disposed of Choi’s body inside a 600 square foot rented flat in Tai Po’s Lung Mei village. Some of her remains, including her head and legs, were discovered three days later.
All three defendants have denied murder but have pleaded guilty to preventing the lawful burial of Choi’s body.

The high-profile trial continues to grab the public’s attention, with people sharing on social media pictures of long queues outside the High Court hours before the hearings.
With more than 300 seats in the court’s live broadcast areas but only a dozen seats in the gallery open to the public, spectators started lining up in the early hours of the day to secure a place at the hearing.
Some of the answers provided by the accused in the witness box regarding their actions drew laughter from spectators.
Anthony said Alex had carried a bag of clothes with him during the car ride on February 21 not because he could change his bloodstained outfit after killing Choi, but because he had intended to put them on in the gym later that day.
After the prosecutor pointed out the bag contained a long-sleeved shirt and long trousers, Anthony suggested that his younger sibling often covered his limbs while exercising because he was “weak” and “fragile”.
Kwong Kau sought to justify his acquisition of electric saws, commercial kitchenware and protective equipment before the model’s death, saying they were essential to ensuring a comfortable life at his supposed new home.
He said he bought the saws to cut bamboo sticks to be erected outside the village flat, although he had not yet bought the bamboo when he was arrested on February 24 that year.
Prosecutors contended that Kwong cooked Choi’s dismembered remains with carrots and radishes before the boiled contents were filtered using a commercial frying sieve and dumped at a refuse collection point in the village.
Kwong argued that a 14-inch soup pot containing the disfigured head of the deceased was originally intended to be used for growing vines, while the carrots and radishes inside the pot were bought to feed stray cats and dogs.
He also said that to pay tribute to mainland China’s “hotpot culture”, he needed a frying sieve larger than a household hotpot.
In their testimonies, Kwong Kau and Alex highlighted the assets they had supposedly accumulated through business activities on the mainland to counter the prosecution’s theory that their family had clung onto Choi’s wealth before her death.
The elder Kwong said he had earned more than HK$10 million by running a property agency in the mainland city of Zhuhai. After turning his focus to his catering business in Guangzhou in 2009, he made monthly profits of up to 280,000 yuan, he said.
Asked whether the socialite had ever given him money, the former police officer said: “No, only I had given her money.”
Alex claimed that he had made a fortune since illegally entering the mainland by speedboat in August 2015 to evade a theft trial.
He said he had earned around HK$20 million by reselling luxury timepieces on the mainland, while receiving a monthly profit of up to 300,000 yuan by subleasing office spaces in Guangzhou. He said he had also worked as a land wholesaler in Haikou.
The father and son claimed that they had both sent money to Choi, who purportedly served as a treasurer overseeing the family’s finances and distributing money to members in need.
Both defendants maintained that they had a financial interest in the Kadooria property. Kwong Kau said he had paid half the purchase price of HK$60 million when Choi acquired the luxury home in 2019.
The former sergeant denied ever impeding Choi’s efforts to sell the home in 2022.

Alex corroborated his father’s claim, but noted the elder Kwong was initially reluctant to sign a power of attorney allowing Choi to negotiate the flat’s sale because of the animosity between them.
Kwong Kau backed his elder son’s account, saying he saw Choi lying unconscious inside the car with Alex crying next to her after the vehicle arrived at his rental flat.
Anthony admitted that while in prison, he had concocted a story with his brother falsely blaming their father for Choi’s death to exonerate themselves.
But Alex insisted that the story contained the true account of the events leading to the influencer’s death.
Alex suggested that Choi had asked Anthony to drive her to a car park in Tai Mei Tuk, Tai Po, so she could reprimand Kwong Kau for seeing her two children from her first marriage without her permission.
He claimed that he and his brother left Choi alone with their father inside her vehicle at the car park, only to see the model lying unconscious there five to six minutes later.
Alex rejected the prosecution’s contention that he was calm and indifferent to his ex-wife’s death, saying he had only wept in his bedroom because he had to suppress his emotions and pretend to be calm in front of his children.
The court is expected to finish hearing witness testimonies next week. An eight-member jury may retire to consider their verdict in early December.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.