Racism row erupts in France after TV panellists say all Chinese potential spies

The Chinese embassy in France has protested after public broadcaster Franceinfo aired a show in which two panellists suggested that the country’s entire Chinese diaspora could be spies for Beijing.
Analysts and activists said the episode highlighted a growing acceptance of racist views against people of Chinese and Asian descent in France amid rising geopolitical tensions with China and an increasingly febrile political debate.
In a statement on Friday, the embassy said the “Chinese spies” narrative was “completely groundless” and had “seriously hurt the feelings of overseas Chinese and people of Chinese descent in France”.
It expressed “firm opposition” to the comments, and urged the French media outlets and individuals concerned to “respect the dignity and reputation” of the Chinese community and “immediately take concrete measures to eliminate the negative impact” they had caused.
The remarks were made on an episode of the Franceinfo show Les Informes aired last week, in which the panel discussed the scandal surrounding Nvidia’s former CEO Jensen Huang.
Asked how many Chinese spies there were in France, Marie-Cecile Naves, research director at the French think tank Institut de Relations Internationales et Strategiques, replied with a laugh: “The entire diaspora, potentially.”
Another panellist, Vincent Crouzet, a television commentator who claims to be a former agent of France’s foreign intelligence agency, the DGSE, went on to say that “every Chinese citizen or every Chinese person originally from China … continues to be tied to the [Communist] Party and has to report back regularly.”
Crouzet also claimed that China was able to use “a large part of the diaspora” as informants through its alleged network of clandestine police stations in France.
Western governments and rights groups have long accused Beijing of running secret overseas police stations to monitor and intimidate dissidents and pro-democracy activists, an accusation Beijing has repeatedly denied.
However, there is no public evidence to support the claim that the alleged outposts are used to run a large network of informants from the Chinese diaspora.
When you see people on public television using these kinds of words … it means that this idea is within the Overton window, that it can be acceptable
Neither Naves nor Crouzet immediately replied to a request for comment.
SCMP Plus is a new premium news platform that gives you an
all-inclusive edge to stay ahead on China news.
To access our exclusive content you’ll need to subscribe.
Already a subscriber?
LOG IN
The remarks quickly triggered a backlash, with critics calling them racist. Economist Benjamin Burbaumer declared the exchange a moment of “conspiratorial and xenophobic vertigo” in a social media post, and criticised the host, Hadrien Bect, for failing to intervene.
Bect acknowledged a request for comment from SCMP but had yet to respond to questions by the time of publication.
For analysts, the episode reflects increasing racism towards the Chinese community in France fanned by concerns over geopolitical tensions with Beijing.
“When you see people on public television using these kinds of words and there is no reaction from the journalist … it means that this idea is within the Overton window, that it can be acceptable,” said Sacha Courtial, a China specialist at the Institut Jacques Delors.
Racism towards the Asian community has always existed in France and Europe, as became clear during the Covid-19 pandemic, according to Courtial. Now, it is resurfacing to target the Chinese community amid Europe’s growing rivalry with China.
By broadcasting this kind of message, which is factually false, the broadcaster could be endangering the safety of people who are perceived as Chinese, according to Remi-Kenzo Pages, spokesman for the Association of Anti-Racist and Racialised Journalists (AJAR).
Similar episodes during the pandemic had led to harassment and attacks against the Asian community in France, Pages said, adding that such a “racist imaginary” would also hurt the morale of journalists of Asian descent in France.
France’s National Consultative Commission on Human Rights recommended in its annual report on racism, published in June, that Arcom, the country’s broadcast and digital regulator, raise awareness among media outlets of the importance of avoiding any hateful content and step up its sanctions policy.
The point was echoed by Courtial, who said the French media and public had developed a fantasy of China – a mysterious secretive state run by the Communist Party – that fuelled the generalised perception that Chinese people could all be threats.
There are certainly Chinese spies in France and France needs to counter these efforts, according to Courtial, but people should be judged on their actions, not by their origin, colour of skin or nationality.
“We cease to be European if we do not maintain our values,” Courtial said.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.