Traitors: New Blood’s ending is exactly what this season deserved

Before The Traitors: New Blood’s final two episodes—and the reveal of whether the traitors succeeded and/or Victor shattered the castle walls by bouncing off them—NBC surprised me. It’s renewed the US all-civilian edition. For NBC, not Peacock!
Even though this season’s insane schedule and editing drove many of us to contemplate murdering the show from our watchlists, it did its job: NBC says the show “added more than 14 million new viewers, increasing the franchise’s overall reach by 85% to nearly 31 million viewers. Over half (61%) of its audience are watching The Traitors universe for the first time.”
I’m not sure how those numbers are calculated; only about 2 to 2.5 million people are watching the show live on NBC on Thursdays. Obviously, a lot more are watching on DVR or Peacock.
I’ve been critical of—and annoyed by—the editing and schedule for this season. Creatively, it was a mess!
But the finale was a solid two hours, the best two episodes of the season. It built to the perfect, dramatic ending this game deserved: two generic faithful, eyes wide with shock that they’d lost to a player who was severely under-edited for a winner.
As a bonus, Jay and Victor were both banished, giving us a few moments of peace.
The game came down to traitors Katie and Shane, and faithful Abbey, Wyatt, and Victor. In other words, two main characters (Victor and Katie), one over-exposed (Victor), and three under-edited players.
Everyone voted out Katie first at the fire, making for a flat ending. Good for Shane—he made the right move turning against her alongside the others—but he did basically nothing as a traitor. He was forced into the role and managed only to make enough noise in the mission for Clyde to suspect him.
I won’t be surprised if we learn a lot more about his game, because that’s been the story of this season. But even if the editing was accurate, I’m happy for him.
“I just feel like I’m barely making it. I can change my life now. I can finally help people,” Shane told Alan Cumming. That’s nice, but his prize is just $246,300—minuscule compared to other competitions, and that’s before taxes.
C’mon, NBCUniversal: give The Traitors a $1 million prize. At least the civilian version, since the celebs don’t seem to care about the cash.
After Katie’s exit, Abbey and Wyatt voted to banish again, and Victor was out, thanks to his own 11th-hour blunder.
The big moment of tension: Would Abbey act on noticing that Clyde voted to end the game before Victor was banished? She did not.
“We just won this game,” Wyatt wailed—which makes him a traitor, according to his declaration that Kriste was a traitor because of her tears and “emotion.”
I was absolutely riveted as Shane revealed himself as a traitor and Wyatt and Abbey’s eyes showed us more than the editing had all season.
Shane had an Alan Carr-style reaction, crying and apologizing. “I would have done the same,” Wyatt reassured Shane, and they hugged it out, so that was nice.
Also nice: First out was “bad faithful” Jay, at long last. “I’m doing everything possible to deliver a team win,” Victor said. “You’re not helping Team Faithful. You’re helping Team Jay.”
Before Jay left, he was annoying one more time, voting for “Uncle Vic” (stop) and then screamed ” I AM A …faithful.” Wyatt said, “What the hell was that?”
Then the traitors murdered Clyde, because he pointed to the two traitors: “unfortunately I’ve been suspecting Katie” and then said “maybe it’s Shane.” That was a result of the very revealing challenge last episode.
Shane and Katie tried to pit Wyatt and Victor against each other, and it seemed like that’d work—thanks to Victor’s own fuckup.
He revealed that he retrieved, hid, and lied about a shield. “Why was I not included?” Wyatt said. Victor’s terrible answer: “It doesn’t matter.”
That played perfectly into Shane’s plan to turn Wyatt vs. Victor. Wyatt spiraled, as I spiraled to figure out who Wyatt is and if he’s been on the show all season. “Why did the person I trust the most lie to my face?” he asked Kriste.
Katie and Shane sat in the kitchen and she kept saying “us,” which is a stunningly bad idea on The Traitors. Kriste didn’t hear as she ran in with the news. Then Katie just said, in her normal voice, “Finally, something we can use against him.” Why would you say that out loud?!
While Victor couldn’t convince anyone about the murder in plain sight earlier in the season, somehow his explanation about the shield convinced Wyatt.
“If y’all don’t vote him off right now, you all don’t deserve the money,” Kriste said. Amen. “Victor, it’s your word against mine: let’s go.”
Wyatt ended up voting for “Kristee,” based on her “emotion.” Shane voted for “Krisie,” and Victor voted for “Kristie. “Abbey had the deciding vote: “Kristi.” So that’s four different people.
Because of this season’s dumbed-down editing, I have to wonder if the players purged Kriste just to get out a known faithful before the endgame—more money for them, easier decision at the end. After all, the Jay vote was mostly about just burning through another faithful, albeit one who made my brain burn with the fire of hell every time he voted for “Miss ___” or, you know, talked.
Besides the moment when the remaining faithful realized they were screwed, my favorite part of The Traitors: New Blood finale was the final mission. Not because of the task itself—Win the Mall’s challenges were more challenging—but because of the joy and excitement the players had for the final mission.
They seemed genuinely thrilled to be zipping around the property in buggies, flying in a helicopter, and fake blowing things up. Unlike Survivor, Big Brother, and Real Housewives, they’re not used to the participatory spectacle of reality TV, and had a ball.
Abbey was so thrilled to be “propelling out the side of the helicopter.” Thankfully, it was just rappelling, though had they flung her out of the helicopter with a propeller on her, that would have been cool, too.
Both Abbey and Katie went out of the helicopter dramatically: Abbey fell to the skid, and looked like she could have hit her face on it; Katie flipped upside down before righting herself and dropping into the water.
Alan screamed “hurry, players, hurry,” yet the production had time to do a fake dynamite explosion and then swap out the lid for one with a cartoon-style hole in it, and light a smoke bomb next to it to make it look like it was smoldering.
That’s kind of the story of this season for me: more time with B-roll than with the players and their strategies. But I am glad NBC is committing to another civilian season.
Next season, though, can we please have a predictable weekly schedule and episodes that have structure instead of time-wasting bullshit like this and this?
All of reality blurred’s content is independently selected, including links to products or services. However, if you buy something after clicking an affiliate link, we may earn a commission. Learn more.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.